Samsung cleared by UK watchdog over ad showing woman running at 2am

ASA received complaints that ad encouraged unsafe behaviour, but firm said a ban would lead to gender stereotyping

A Samsung ad featuring a woman running alone at 2am has avoided a ban by the UK advertising watchdog, despite complaints that it was irresponsible after a spate of late-night attacks on women.

The TV and cinema ad for Samsung products including a smartwatch featured a woman getting up at 2am and going for a run through a large city while wearing wireless earbuds. A voiceover encouraged the idea of running at unusual hours, stating: “Sleep at night. Run faster. Push harder. Follow the herd. Not for me. I run on a different schedule. Mine.”

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) received 27 complaints from viewers who felt that in light of a number of recent high-profile cases where women had been attacked in similar circumstances the ad was harmful and irresponsible for encouraging unsafe behaviour.

In April, women’s safety group Reclaim These Streets described the campaign as “beyond unrealistic” in light of the death of Ashling Murphy, a 23-year-old teacher from Ireland who was attacked after she went for a run in January. Her death prompted vigils and led to the #SheWasOnARun movement as women shared stories about being harassed while out running.

Samsung Electronics acknowledged the ad “might have been perceived as insensitive by some viewers” and apologised, saying it would not be broadcast again in the UK.

The South Korean electronics firm asked the ASA to investigate whether the ads were in breach of the UK marketing code.

“The ads were not intended to encourage women to go running at night,” the company said. “They were intended to celebrate individuality and demonstrate the use of Samsung products when exercising, whatever the time of day.”

The company said the unsafe element was the risk of “predatory individuals” – not running alone at night in itself – although it admitted the risks might be higher in a city or at night. An ad ban could lead to “harmful gender stereotyping” if it was interpreted that advertisers could therefore show only men in activities that could present any risk of a predatory individual attacking them, it said.

“[The risk is] also presented in numerous other scenarios shown in advertising, such as individuals in a taxi alone, walking alone at any time of day, getting drinks in a bar [and] going on a first date,” Samsung said.

Clearcast, the body responsible for checking if ads are likely to meet the UK code before they are broadcast, said that if the ad was banned, it “could set a precedent for wider victim blaming, making it difficult to assess future ads”.

The Cinema Advertising Association (CAA) said that if the ad was deemed to be irresponsible for encouraging unsafe practices, “that could be taken akin to the police saying that women should not venture into town centres after dark. That attitude was, understandably, castigated as victim blaming”.

The ASA’s investigation cleared the ads of breaking the UK code, finding that they did not encourage an unsafe practice and were not irresponsible.

“We recognised that some care would need to be taken when going for a run alone in the middle of the night, particularly for women,” the ASA said. “And we considered that people would be likely to realise in doing so, they could be placed in a vulnerable position.”

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

The woman in the ads was not shown behaving recklessly or obviously placing herself in danger, it ruled.

“The woman shown in the ads appeared alert and aware of her surroundings, and was seen running in well-lit, main streets where other people were present. We considered that running alone at night, of itself, was not likely to result in harm or injury. Whilst we acknowledged that an attack could happen, that was outside of a person’s control and it could also happen in other, everyday scenarios and at all times of the day or night.”


Mark Sweney

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Samsung ad featuring woman running alone at 2am criticised as ‘naive’
Reclaim These Streets joins running groups in calling ad insensitive ‘especially in light of Ashling Murphy’

Hibaq Farah

28, Apr, 2022 @2:33 PM

Article image
Ad break: Ikea, Nike's Derek Jeter tribute, Samsung Galaxy S5

Jason Stone: Watch a dream-like campaign for the furniture store, plus Jay-Z, Tiger Woods and Michael Jordan hailing the baseball star

Jason Stone

17, Jul, 2014 @2:54 PM

Article image
Watch Bradley Wiggins and Jack Whitehall in a Samsung ad
The Olympic gold medallist tries to get the comedian on track in our review of new advertising work

Jason Stone

28, Jul, 2016 @11:00 AM

Article image
Tesco ad featuring Santa with Covid vaccine passport cleared by watchdog
Exclusive: Christmas advert prompted more than 5,000 complaints, plus criticism on social media from anti-vaxxers

Mark Sweney

02, Dec, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Apple ordered to run adverts stating Samsung did not copy iPad
Judge rules that Apple must take out newspaper and magazine ads that say Samsung did not copy its iPad, according to Bloomberg. By Charles Arthur

Charles Arthur

19, Jul, 2012 @6:44 AM

Article image ad showing woman carrying out subservient tasks banned for being sexist
TikTok campaign showed woman making sure football was on TV to ‘make him realise I’m a keeper’

Mark Sweney

04, Oct, 2022 @11:01 PM

Article image
Samsung introduces adblocking to its Android devices
World’s largest smartphone manufacturer releases update to its default web browser enabling users to block advertising

Jasper Jackson

01, Feb, 2016 @11:02 AM

Article image
Google pulls adblocking app for Samsung phones
Adblock Fast downloaded 50,000 times since Monday – but is thought to have breached Google’s rules for disrupting third-party services

Jasper Jackson

03, Feb, 2016 @11:19 PM

Microsoft appoints Samsung ad executive Mikah Martin-Cruz
Martin-Cruz, best known for Sony campaigns Paint and Play Doh, will be Microsoft's UK chief marketing officer. By Mark Sweney

Mark Sweney

08, Sep, 2010 @10:39 AM

Article image
Motorola smartphone ad banned after complaints from Samsung fans
Advertising watchdog rules Motorola must withdraw claim that its Atrix handset is the world's most powerful smartphone. By Mark Sweney

Mark Sweney

24, Aug, 2011 @6:20 AM