England’s north-south divide is deepening, says new report

Despite Boris Johnson’s persistent levelling-up rhetoric, the figures show government has not put its money where its mouth is

England’s north-south divide continues to deepen despite two years of “levelling-up” rhetoric from the government, according to a landmark new report to be published tomorrow.

Entitled State of the North 2021, and produced by IPPR North, the northern branch of the Institute for Public Policy Research thinktank, the report compares levels of public investment in London and the south-east with that in the north. Its authors estimate that, in the five years to 2019/20, London received the equivalent of £12,147 per person, while in the north the figure was only £8,125.

Treasury data indicated that if investment in the north had matched that in London over the five years from 2014/15, it would have meant an extra £61bn of spending in areas such as transport, infrastructure and skills. The south-east, the report states, is home to one-third of the UK population but now accounts for 45% of its economy and 42% of its wealth.

The stark disparities will fuel concerns among “red wall” Conservative MPs that the government’s flagship policy is underfunded, and do not fulfil Boris Johnson’s promise to rebalance the economy. The chancellor, Rishi Sunak, has effectively capped the main levelling-up fund at £4.8bn for this parliament. Critics say this is a drop in the ocean after decades of underinvestment and 10 years of austerity cuts.

In November, after pressure from the Treasury, the promised eastern leg of HS2 from Birmingham to Leeds was scrapped and a proposed high-speed line between Manchester and Leeds downgraded. At the time of those decisions, the chair of the Northern Research Group of Tory MPs, Jake Berry, challenged Johnson over whether “voters in the north [were] right to take the prime minister at his word”.

As well as highlighting the scale of the funding gap between the north and south-east, the IPPR report also points to Germany, where successive governments have spent an average of €70bn a year reducing regional divides since reunification in 1990.

Jonathan Webb, one of the report’s authors, said: “However we measure investment in levelling up – whether we compare with Germany’s successful efforts to rebalance its economy, or to London-level investment – it’s clear that central government simply hasn’t put its money where its mouth is when it comes to rebalancing the economy. Levelling up will be consigned to the list of hollow, unmet promises made to people in regions like the north for a long time now, if it isn’t underpinned by investment and, crucially, fiscal devolution.”

The levelling-up white paper, detailing the government’s plans, has been repeatedly delayed. It is now due by the end of the month. Responding to the IPPR study, the shadow secretary of state for levelling up, Lisa Nandy, said: “For all the talk of levelling up, the story of this government has been to strip power from communities across Britain. After a decade of empty slogans and broken promises, the levelling-up paper must finally provide the resources and a plan to deliver the radical change we have been promised.”

A Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities spokesperson said: “This analysis is misleading as it focuses on just one part of our investment to level up the North of England.

“In addition to the £4.8bn Levelling Up Fund, we’re providing record investment in infrastructure worth over £96bn, £12bn in affordable housing and a £2.6bn Shared Prosperity Fund to help rebalance opportunity across the UK.

“The government will publish a white paper that will drive forward this central mission in due course.”

• This article was amended on 17 January 2022 to include a comment from the department, which was provided after publication.


Julian Coman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
After a smooth path to the top, is Sunak now in for a bumpy ride?
The chancellor is caught between ministers who want to spend more as he prepares for a fiscally conservative budget

Michael Savage

24, Oct, 2021 @9:45 AM

Article image
Conservatives accused of ‘levelling up’ stunt to save Boris Johnson’s job
Lisa Nandy slams claim of boost for 20 towns saying ‘new’ fund for poorer areas is recycled pledge

Toby Helm and Mark Townsend

29, Jan, 2022 @10:00 PM

Article image
Regionalism needed to bridge north-south divide | Letters
Letters: Establishing a large movie studio, rather than just TV studio, in Manchester would be another key step toward a British Hollywood


14, Nov, 2016 @7:42 PM

Article image
Charities cut off by north-south divide as donors focus on London

'Big society' under pressure with philanthropy biased towards the capital, says leading thinktank

Jamie Doward and Mario Ledwith

23, Apr, 2011 @7:28 PM

Article image
HS2 and the continuing north-south divide | Letters
Letters: Mixed reactions to Simon Jenkins’ call to halt the planned high-speed rail link between London and the Midlands


12, Aug, 2018 @4:21 PM

North versus south: the old divide just got wider

North-south divide shows no sign of diminishing

Amelia Hill, social affairs correspondent

24, Feb, 2008 @12:06 AM

Article image
High time to invest in the north's infrastructure
Dithering over HS2 undermines the credibility of Boris Johnson’s promised infrastructure revolution

09, Feb, 2020 @6:08 PM

North-south divide in lethal roads
Drivers in the north and midlands are more likely to be involved in accidents due to lighter traffic.

Juliette Jowit, transport editor

23, Jun, 2007 @11:04 PM

Article image
'Build northern stretch of HS2 first' to boost poorer UK cities
Linking Birmingham with Manchester and Leeds would bring greater benefit than a fast link to London, says economist Jim O'Neill. Toby Helm reports

Toby Helm, political editor

01, Mar, 2014 @10:29 PM

Article image
New homes bonus for councils will 'worsen England's north-south divide'

Impending £1bn funding crisis will hit the north of England as the affluent south prospers, warn housing experts

Jamie Doward

27, Feb, 2011 @12:06 AM