LGBT+ groups call for EHRC to lose international status over trans stance

Equality watchdog accused of excessive government interference and ‘politically motivated’ appointments

The UK’s equalities watchdog is facing calls for it to lose its status as an internationally recognised human rights body amid claims of politicisation and taking a “determinedly anti-trans stance”.

A coalition of 19 LGBT+ organisations led by Stonewall and supported by the Good Law Project says the Equality and Human Rights Commission has taken a “recent and significant” shift on trans rights that has prompted them to make a submission to the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions calling for the body to lose its “A-rating”.

The chief executive of the commission, Marcial Boo, said Stonewall and others were “aiming at the wrong target” and urged them to “work with us to identify discrimination against LGBT people so we can take action together to stop it”.

The call follows two interventions by the commission at the end of January, in which it recommended that the UK government’s proposed ban on conversion practices not extend to trans people, and it wrote to the Scottish government asking it to pause plans to simplify the legal requirements for gender recognition, reversing its previous position.

At the time this was met with fury by some Scottish campaigners who railed against “UK government appointees telling us in Scotland how to legislate in devolved areas”. The commission insisted impartiality was “a core value” and that all decisions “are made independently of any government”.

The 19-page submission outlines what the Stonewall-led coalition claims is evidence of “the numerous ways the EHRC now finds itself falling short of international standards”.

This includes a “complete absence” of financial autonomy from the UK government and “excessive” governmental interference, including “politically motivated” appointments to the chair and board, “many of whom have repeatedly and publicly demonstrated their opposition to the expansion of human rights, and whose appointments have drawn widespread criticism from NGOs”.

A spokesperson from the commission said it took all decisions “impartially, based on evidence and the law, both in the UK and internationally”, that its independence was “guaranteed in statute”, and that all appointments were made through “a fair, open and transparent recruitment process”.

“Our statutory mandate and role as a national human rights institution is to protect and promote equality and human rights for everyone – and that includes trans people. Where rights may conflict, our role is to advise on striking an appropriate balance. We uphold fairness for all, and our work is rigorous and impartial.”

Calling on the UK government to “revive” an independent EHRC, Nancy Kelley, the CEO of Stonewall, said: “The politicisation of the UK’s human rights body has placed trans people in the firing line, but this attempt to create a hierarchy of human rights in the UK is a very real threat to everyone, particularly those of us protected by the Equality Act”.

The submission comes amid growing concerns about the role and independence of the EHRC. Last year its former head David Isaac suggested the watchdog was being undermined by political pressure to support the UK government’s shift in equalities priorities away from gender and race.


Libby Brooks

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Trans people can be excluded from single-sex services if ‘justifiable’, says EHRC
UK government’s equalities watchdog says justifications could include reasons of privacy or health and safety

Rajeev Syal Home affairs editor

04, Apr, 2022 @2:31 PM

Article image
LGBT activists criticise minister for women over trans comments
Victoria Atkins said she is ‘a little cautious’ about use of gender reassignment

Mattha Busby

26, Aug, 2018 @11:54 PM

Article image
Trans women can take seats on public boards set aside for women, Scottish judge rules
Guidance that extends definition of ‘woman’ to transgender women with gender recognition certificate is lawful, court rules

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

13, Dec, 2022 @4:16 PM

Article image
LGBT groups quit UK conference over failure to ban trans conversion practices
More than 80 charities to boycott government event as Boris Johnson criticised for ‘broken promise’

Tobi Thomas

04, Apr, 2022 @5:32 PM

Article image
Life in Scotland is getting worse, say young LGBT+ people
Concerns about bullying, homophobia and hate crime revealed in latest five-yearly report

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

26, Apr, 2022 @1:03 PM

Article image
Trans model Munroe Bergdorf to advise Labour on LGBT issues
Conservatives say controversial comments on race made last year make her unsuitable for the post

Anushka Asthana Political editor

27, Feb, 2018 @4:40 PM

Article image
Puberty blockers ruling: curbing trans rights or a victory for common sense?
A highly anticipated judgement on Tuesday concluded children under 16 are unlikely to be mature enough to give informed consent

Libby Brooks

03, Dec, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Rosie Duffield calls for talks with Keir Starmer on Labour’s trans rights stance
Canterbury MP, who will not attend party conference, says meeting with leader could help find way forward

Peter Walker Political correspondent

20, Sep, 2021 @10:05 AM

Article image
EHRC has not taken sides in debate on impact of transgender laws, Scottish court told
Equalities watchdog tells judicial review of law on gender balance it is ‘regrettable but probably inevitable’ it is seen as partisan

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

10, Nov, 2022 @7:36 PM

Article image
Equality gains in the UK risk being reversed by coronavirus, says EHRC
Watchdog says pandemic is hitting older people, minorities, the young and disabled people the hardest

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

19, Oct, 2020 @11:01 PM