GPs in England ‘finding it increasingly hard to guarantee safe care’

Exclusive: UK’s top family doctor says medic shortage means GPs are unable to cope with demand

GPs in England are “finding it increasingly hard to guarantee safe care” for millions of patients as a shortage of medics means they are unable to cope with soaring demand, Britain’s top family doctor has warned.

Amid a debate over access to face-to-face appointments, Prof Martin Marshall, chair of the Royal College of GPs (RCGP), defended the growing use of remote consultations during the pandemic.

He said a 4.5% fall in GP numbers across England was to blame for the crisis in primary care and warned it had led to a risk of mistakes being made.

In 2015, the government vowed to hire 5,000 more GPs within five years. But the number has instead fallen. The number of family doctors working the equivalent of full-time hours fell by 1,307 to 28,096 between September 2015 and March 2021, according to an analysis of NHS data by the RCGP, with growing numbers quitting due to burnout both early and late in their careers.

At the same time a growing and ageing population with complex conditions in addition to an overall increase in demand for care means GPs are beginning to crack under the pressure of unsustainable workloads, according to Marshall. As a result, overworked family doctors are increasingly fearful of making serious mistakes or missing crucial signs of potentially life-threatening conditions.

In an interview with the Guardian, Marshall said: “The fact that general practice is under such enormous pressure means it can’t deliver the patient-centred services that it wants to. Many GPs are even finding it challenging to maintain a safe service.

“That’s a consequence of increased consultations, increased complexity of consultations, the vaccination programme and a larger population. All of that [means] a massive increase in need and demand. And there hasn’t been a commensurate increase in supply – particularly in staff.”

Prof Martin Marshall, chair of the Royal College of GPs, with a Covid vaccine recipient last December. Photograph: Leon Neal/Getty Images

In a stark warning, Marshall said the crisis had implications for patient safety. “GPs are finding it increasingly hard to guarantee safe care to their patients,” he said. “The chances of making a mistake in a diagnosis or a mistake in a referral decision or a mistake in prescribing are all greater when you’re under stress. And if you’re working 11-, 12-hour days, seeing 50, 60 patients … the chances of you making a mistake, we all know, are higher.”

Marshall spoke out amid a row over the ability of patients to access face-to-face appointments. Family doctors were told in March 2020 to adopt a “total triage” approach and only see patients in person after a video consultation to reduce the risk of spreading coronavirus.

NHS England then wrote to GPs in May this year telling them to “ensure they are offering face-to-face appointments”, adding that remote appointments “should be done alongside a clear offer of appointments in person”. But some patients have struggled with access. In July, in-person appointments made up 57% of the total compared with 80% in the same month in 2019.

This week it emerged that a coroner had warned the inability of some patients to see GPs in person was contributing to deaths. Alison Mutch presided over five inquests during the Covid pandemic in which she said patients should have had better care, the Health Service Journal reported. Some could have been referred to hospital more quickly for vital treatment had they been seen face to face, said Mutch, the senior coroner for Greater Manchester.

Marshall said the move to remote consultations during the pandemic was necessary to stop the spread of the virus and keep patients and GP teams safe, and that they were welcomed by many patients who find them more convenient. They would remain an option as things got back to normal, he added, because they had advantages.

“We know that some patients love remote consulting,” he said. “It’s more convenient, they don’t have to leave work, they don’t have to sit in waiting rooms, they don’t have to find childcare. There are people who think that remote consultations are brilliant.

“We know there are some people who absolutely need face-to-face appointments, either for examination or for taking a blood test. But we also know there is this group of people who don’t necessarily need face to face appointments for clinical reasons – but would prefer them. And that’s the group that general practice is struggling with.”

Growing numbers of GPs are quitting due to burnout. Six in 10 say their mental health deteriorated in the last year, and about two-thirds (63%) say they expect things to get worse, surveys show.

“A growing number of younger doctors are leaving general practice completely,” Marshall said. Others in their 50s were retiring early “because they don’t want to die in the harness”, he added. There were positive signs that more trainee GPs were coming through the system, but the number leaving the profession was still greater than that joining, he said.

Despite restrictions easing, the pandemic was far from over, Marshall warned. He said GPs could not afford to be complacent or unnecessarily put patients at risk of becoming infected.

“People think the pandemic has gone,” he said. “[But] one in 70 people in England are still infected. And if a fit person shedding the virus sits next to a vulnerable, older person in a waiting room and that person picks up the infection, the consequences will be dire. Although it’s unpopular, as GPs we’re still following good infection control guidance.”

The RCGP wants the government to introduce an emergency rescue package to shore up surgeries. This would include recruiting 6,000 more GPs and 26,000 additional support staff such as nurses and receptionists by 2024. Without these changes, Marshall said, patients would not get the care they needed.

This week the prime minister announced a new health and social care levy, including a £9.4bn funding boost for the NHS next year.


Andrew Gregory Health editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
NHS will take months to return to normal in England, says hospitals boss
Exclusive: Chris Hopson says public should expect longer waiting times to continue after second Covid peak

Denis Campbell

31, Jan, 2021 @7:48 PM

Article image
Tory pledge to bolster GP surgery staff set to be broken, say health leaders
Only 9,500 of the promised 26,000 extra personnel for practices in England have been recruited

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

09, Jan, 2022 @4:20 PM

Article image
GPs in England get green light to provide less care and join Covid jab drive
Government says doctors can do less monitoring of people with diabetes and heart problems

Denis Campbell and agencies

03, Dec, 2021 @5:23 PM

Article image
NHS facing ‘mass exodus’ of GPs in England, experts warn
Exclusive: 23% of GPs – or more than 6,000 – are over 55 and expected to quit in next few years

Andrew Gregory Health editor

29, Oct, 2021 @11:01 AM

Article image
GPs warn over plans to share patient data with third parties in England
Doctors say NHS Digital’s proposals could erode the relationship between them and their patients

Sarah Marsh

30, May, 2021 @1:26 PM

Article image
Ministers urged to strip away red tape to hit UK vaccine rollout target
Doctors say 24/7 vaccine centres and recruiting retired health workers could help reach goal

Linda Geddes Science correspondent

01, Jan, 2021 @6:13 PM

Article image
Javid’s hard line on making NHS staff in England get jabbed may pay off
Analysis: vaccination rates jumped in care homes after compulsion was introduced, suggesting the health secretary may be right

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

03, Nov, 2021 @6:06 PM

Article image
'We're bursting': a day inside a Covid intensive care unit
The Guardian spends a day with Covid patients and staff at Milton Keynes University hospital

Helen Pidd

08, Jan, 2021 @5:23 PM

Article image
NHS in England delays sharing of medical records

GP and patient groups hail decision to put launch of back six months to give more patients more time to evaluate opt-outs

Peter Walker, James Meikle and Randeep Ramesh

18, Feb, 2014 @6:33 PM

Article image
NHS England waiting list reaches record high for second straight month
Experts warn 5.3m backlog could exacerbate burnout with staff facing ‘unprecedented levels of exhaustion’

Rachel Hall and Pamela Duncan

08, Jul, 2021 @3:15 PM