Tory peers to make last-ditch effort to reverse universal credit cut

Philippa Stroud will table amendment to highlight concern in party about ending £20 a week uplift

Conservative peers will launch a last-ditch attempt to force the government to reverse the £20 a week universal credit cut on the eve of Rishi Sunak’s budget next week.

Philippa Stroud will table an amendment to the social security uprating bill in the House of Lords, with the support of Tory colleagues including the former work and pensions secretary David Willetts.

Constitutional precedent means it is usually considered unacceptable for the Lords to try to interfere in the financial aspects of legislation passed by the House of Commons.

But Lady Stroud – a close ally of the MP Iain Duncan Smith, who devised the universal credit system – is keen to highlight the scale of concern in the Conservative party about the cut, which has already come into force.

“I do not take lightly the idea of disagreeing so fervently with my Conservative government, or of breaking with parliamentary convention. But this cut is a grave misstep and risks undermining the levelling up agenda, leaving behind society’s most vulnerable people and putting at risk the stability of many homes up and down the country as we enter an unpredictable winter,” she said.

As well as Willetts, she is understood to have the backing of other Conservative peers including David Cameron’s former aide Gabby Bertin.

It is understood Lords clerks have warned Stroud they believe the amendment is out of the scope of the bill – but she still hopes to push it to a vote.

One seasoned Lords watcher said it had perhaps a one in five chance of reaching a vote. Stroud’s supporters point to a 2013 Lords vote on a boundary review that could have handed Cameron’s Conservatives 20 extra seats. The clerks objected on that occasion but peers voted nevertheless, delaying the review for five years and infuriating Cameron’s government. However, that issue did not have direct financial implications.

Liberal Democrat peers are supporting Stroud’s manoeuvre. Barbara Janke, the party’s work and pensions spokesperson in the Lords, said: “This cut hurts both those in and out of work, and risks pushing millions of families into deeper poverty. It’s encouraging to see that now even loyal Conservatives are taking a stand and opposing this decision.

“The Liberal Democrats want to see the £20 uplift retained and will be backing Baroness Stroud’s amendment, which we hope will receive cross-party support.”

Removing the £20 a week increase in universal credit that was introduced in the early days of the Covid pandemic amounted to the largest overnight benefits cut in history, according to the Resolution Foundation thinktank.

In his party conference speech earlier this month, Sunak said: “Picture this: you’re a young family. You work hard, saving a bit each month. But it’s tough. You have ambitions for your careers for your children. You want to give them the best – more than you had. Now you tell me: is the answer to their hopes and dreams just to increase their benefits?”

Labour has tabled a separate amendment to the bill – more likely to come to a vote – that would force the government to set out the impact of the cuts on pensioner poverty in six months’ time.


Heather Stewart Political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Universal credit rollout should be paused, say Tory MPs
Former government adviser and 12 MPs raise concerns over impact on people already receiving universal credit in trial areas

Matthew Weaver

29, Sep, 2017 @1:50 PM

Article image
John Major calls for Tory review of 'unfair' universal credit
Former PM says party needs to ‘show its heart again’ or it risks opening door to ’return of a nightmare’

Anushka Asthana Political editor

08, Oct, 2017 @11:33 AM

Article image
Peers call for universal credit boost to be made permanent
Committee says £20 a week increase should stay and ministers need to ‘wake up’ on unemployment

Richard Partington and Larry Elliott

14, Dec, 2020 @6:01 AM

Article image
Universal credit rollout may be delayed again amid Tory backlash
Reports suggest major welfare change not fully operational until December 2023

Jessica Elgot

16, Oct, 2018 @9:08 AM

Article image
Universal credit rollout will go ahead despite Tory MPs' call for delay
Work and pensions secretary David Gauke confirms introduction of controversial benefit will continue as planned

Matthew Weaver and Peter Walker

02, Oct, 2017 @1:35 PM

Article image
Doctors, charities and Tory thinktank urge PM to drop universal credit cut
Letter signed by 100 organisations warns £20 a week reduction would push 500,000 people into poverty

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

01, Sep, 2021 @11:01 PM

Article image
Has universal credit been delayed again?
The government’s new benefits system may have a slower rollout

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

16, Oct, 2018 @3:55 PM

Article image
Watchdog bans DWP's 'misleading' universal credit adverts
ASA found claim that people could move into work faster on UC to be unsubstantiated

Haroon Siddique

06, Nov, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
Reverse universal credit cuts, Iain Duncan Smith tells chancellor
Thinktank says 340,000 people could be taken out of poverty if Philip Hammond takes action

Anne Perkins

13, Mar, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Labour inflicts symbolic defeat over universal credit rollout
Tories under fire for abstaining from vote hours after work and pensions secretary David Gauke ends helpline charges

Jessica Elgot and Peter Walker

18, Oct, 2017 @7:45 PM