Bolder moves required as Michael Gove tackles building safety crisis

Previous housing secretaries have failed to make much headway, but two sledgehammer options are available

“Michael Gove, we want justice!” rang the chant across Parliament Square 24 hours after Boris Johnson had placed his new secretary of state for levelling up in charge of fixing the building safety crisis.

Placards at the End Our Cladding Scandal protest last month read: “No sale, no help, no future” and “Leasehold is legalised theft”. Some took hope in Gove’s reputation as an energetic problem-solver. After the prior failures of Sajid Javid, James Brokenshire and Robert Jenrick to find a solution, others were more jaundiced. When the former Conservative leader Iain Duncan Smith declared that “the developers have got away scot-free”, one heckler yelled: “Your government, you hypocrite.”

In the four years since the Grenfell Tower fire, the building safety crisis has spread like an infestation of Japanese knotweed, remorselessly undermining the security of more and more homes. It has plunged hundreds of thousands of leaseholders into a misery of potential financial ruin and safety fears. Daily, householders open new remediation bills with five and sometimes six digits. Insurance renewals soar and mortgage companies declare their homes worthless.

Now Gove is hatching his response, asking whether insurance costs can be capped and whether freeholders can be forced to pay up. These are not new lines of inquiry, and previous housing secretaries have failed to make any substantial headway with them. With leaseholders facing £10bn in what many think are unjust repair costs, and a persistent and possibly growing Tory backbench rebellion, Gove will be aware this is a national crisis that requires bolder moves.

Two sledgehammer options are available. The first is a Treasury bailout to pay for the repairs. So far the government has promised £5bn, partly funded by a new tax on developers. That is to remove combustible cladding from homes over 18 metres in height. MPs reckon the bill, when lower-rise buildings found to have dangerous cladding and faults such as missing fire breaks and faulty fire doors are included, tops £15bn. There is no sign of Rishi Sunak agreeing to that, and arguably it is unjust. Why should taxpayers fix endemic failures in the property industry?

The second is to move the goalposts and redefine what constitutes a dangerous building, and at a stroke reduce the number of homes affected. Ministers and their fire safety advisers have been developing this idea for several months. Johnson said this week: “A lot of people are living with a frankly unnecessary sense of anxiety about the homes they are living in, because those buildings are as safe as any other.” Essentially, they say there has been an overreaction, albeit one the government triggered.

The government’s advice to owners, which has stood since January 2020, is to assess “risks of any external wall system and fire doors … irrespective of the height of the building”. That triggered a wave of risk aversion from surveyors and mortgage companies that some consider disproportionate.

Jenrick, Gove’s predecessor said in July that this advice would “shortly be retired”. It hasn’t happened yet.

“The general feeling among leaseholders, especially those in blocks below 18 metres, is that this is a bureaucratic problem, not a safety issue,” said Rituparna Saha, a co-founder of the UK Cladding Action Group. There have been fires in defective apartment blocks since Grenfell and some have come close to costing lives.

When leaseholders are sent remediation bills (residents of a five-storey block in south London this month were told the bill could reach £85,000 each), they are largely unable to challenge the quotes, which raises fear of financial exploitation. One cheaper alternative could be to install sprinklers in blocks with safety problems rather than stripping back their walls. It would safeguard life but may not satisfy insurers and mortgage lenders, who care about preventing building damage too.

As well as large numbers of hardworking young adults and downsizing retirees, the building safety crisis is hurting thousands of key workers in shared ownership homes. So Gove need not fear that fixing the building safety crisis is a distraction from his main job of “levelling up”.


Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
New housing secretary Michael Gove urged to fix building safety crisis
Iain Duncan Smith joins Westminster rally of homeowners trapped in unsellable and dangerous homes

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

16, Sep, 2021 @4:02 PM

Article image
Gove looks at cutting insurance costs to tackle building safety crisis
Housing secretary may also push developers to pay for repairs in signs of renewed push to fix problem

Heather Stewart and Robert Booth

08, Oct, 2021 @11:21 AM

Article image
Labour plans to make landowners sell to state for fraction of value
Exclusive: party proposes raid on private land to cut cost of building new council houses

Robert Booth

01, Feb, 2018 @6:00 PM

Article image
England needs 3m new social homes by 2040, says cross-party report
Commission including Sayeeda Warsi and Ed Miliband has been researching ways to tackle housing crisis

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

08, Jan, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
Social housing crisis can no longer be ignored, says housing chief
David Orr says Grenfell Tower fire highlighted neglect of sector government must urgently make money available

Peter Walker Political correspondent

18, Sep, 2017 @11:01 PM

Article image
Housing crisis: we will borrow to invest in new homes, says Sajid Javid
Communities secretary calls for ‘big increase in all types of home’ including social housing and shared equity homes

Peter Walker Political correspondent

22, Oct, 2017 @1:42 PM

Article image
Housing crisis could push young voters to extremes, says former Whitehall chief
Bob Kerslake says failure to provide cheap social housing may boost far right

Robert Booth

27, Dec, 2017 @1:00 PM

Article image
Hundreds of thousands living in squalid rented homes in England
Estimated 338,000 properties rented by under-35s likely to cause harm

Robert Booth

28, Jan, 2018 @4:33 PM

Article image
Plan to change shared ownership equity rules described as 'tinkering'
Labour dismisses housing secretary’s plan to allow buyers to boost stake in smaller steps

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

27, Aug, 2019 @11:01 PM

Article image
Michael Gove tasked with solving housing crisis in latest role
New secretary of state must also oversee planning reforms and navigate post-Grenfell building safety bill

Rowena Mason and Robert Booth

15, Sep, 2021 @6:29 PM