Low mood or clinical depression? Taking a critical approach to psychology | Letters

Readers respond to Lucy Foulkes’ article on what we are getting wrong in the conversation around mental health

It is pleasing that Lucy Foulkes’ experience (What we’re getting wrong in the conversation about mental health, 29 March) of supporting her friend through a relationship breakdown leads her to question the helpfulness of applying psychiatric diagnoses uncritically in this and other situations. Critical approaches to psychiatry, and indeed psychology and psychotherapy, now form a substantial body of work. Most importantly, this includes the experiences of service users who have found themselves to have been treated badly by traditional mental health services.

One example, thankfully gaining visibility, is the cultural insensitivity of models of practice that have been developed in Europe and America, but which are then applied uncritically to people from a wide range of backgrounds. A forthcoming book, Racism in Psychology, edited by Craig Newnes, covers this ground in relation to psychology and psychotherapy practice. I know from many years of experience in mental health services that psychiatry and psychology/psychotherapy can be enormously helpful to people when their needs and wishes are carefully listened to and given the highest priority, rather than the insensitive application of theory.
Dr Sim Roy-Chowdhury
Brentwood, Essex

• There is a long history of resistance to the inappropriate use of labels. The latest catalogue of psychiatric disorders, DSM-5, compiled by the American Psychiatric Association, has been widely, though sometimes unfairly, criticised, including for embracing half the population as “disordered” – good if you want a box to tick to claim from your patient’s health insurance, but hardly a reasonable description of people at large.

And that is the point that Lucy Foulkes seems to miss. Psychiatric diagnoses are categories that many of us in the mental health profession sometimes use to make sense of the problems brought to us, and particularly to communicate economically with colleagues. But they are not good scientific categories, nor do they bring alive the lived experience of distressed people.

One of the many reasons why psychiatric research has uncovered so little that is reliable, despite the massive sums of money spent, is that it uses categories designed to help professional practice, but not to further science or to colour personal understanding.
Dr John Richer
Wallingford, Oxfordshire

• Lucy Foulkes’ article struck a chord with me. As a listening volunteer for a local hospice, I support patients, carers and bereaved families, and I have lost count of the times I have been asked, “Am I going mad?” by bereaved relatives. Very occasionally, some degree of depression may be present, but almost always the answer is, “No, you’re just very sad”. Because as a culture we talk so little about bereavement and loss, people are often unprepared for the sheer disabling power of grief, and assume they must be mentally ill. We need to talk more openly if people are to be equipped to recognise, manage and, if necessary, seek help for the impact of the events and emotions that most will encounter in a normal life.
Jill Wallis
Aston Clinton, Buckinghamshire

• Some years ago, during training to become an approved social worker, our tutor asked us to list as many symptoms of mental illness that we could think of. She then asked us to identify any of these symptoms that we personally had not experienced. It quickly became clear that we had all been affected by most, if not all, of these at some time. It is chronic or persistent symptoms that require intervention from mental health services.
Michael Wild
Postbridge, Devon


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
How can every mind matter in a broken mental health system? | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to the launch of the NHS Every Mind Matters campaign and share their thoughts on other mental health issues


09, Oct, 2019 @4:29 PM

Article image
Ensuring a good standard of therapy | Letters
Letters: The three leading regulatory bodies for the counselling and psychotherapy profession have created a new competence framework as a response to the mental health crisis


30, Nov, 2018 @4:08 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on mental health: saving lives requires money and monitoring | Editorial
Editorial: Lessons are not being learned from the deaths of hundreds of mental health patients, despite the warnings of coroners


06, Mar, 2018 @5:27 PM

Article image
The potential post-traumatic legacy of the Covid pandemic | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to the prospect of coronavirus posing the greatest threat to mental health since the second world war


30, Dec, 2020 @5:54 PM

Article image
Understanding depression and developing empathy | Letters
Letters: Dr Annie Hickox advocates for the powerful combination of medication plus talking therapy. And Laurel Farrington highlights how empathy reduces when we are anxious and stressed


08, Mar, 2021 @5:25 PM

Article image
Therapists too quick to assume someone has a personality disorder | Letters
Letters: Keir Harding says those who have lived through trauma deserve better, and Ash Charlton says it is a myth that one of the biggest predictors for an adult becoming an abuser is if they have been abused themselves


28, Mar, 2019 @6:21 PM

Article image
How to think clearly in beleaguered times | Letters
Letters: Rorie Fulton on combating unwitting support for populists, and Richard Bryden on civic spaces that facilitate ‘reasoned conversation’


06, Oct, 2019 @4:34 PM

Article image
Anorexia, DNA, and false distinctions | Letters
Letters: All psychiatric conditions are caused by an interaction between a person’s mind and body, writes Peter White. Anorexia is a quite recent phenomenon, writes Declan Flynn


17, Jul, 2019 @4:55 PM

Article image
Good practice in the treatment of mental illness | Letters
Letters: A lack of note-taking is not always a red flag in therapy, writes Dr Helen Damon, and Ruth Medhurst says that the terminology around illness is totally outdated


21, Jul, 2021 @5:28 PM

Article image
What is depression and why is it rising?
It’s an illness that fills our news pages on an almost daily basis. Juliette Jowit asks what causes depression, who is susceptible and what the best treatment is

Juliette Jowit

04, Jun, 2018 @5:00 AM