Agents ‘will make hundreds of millions’ from post-Grenfell safety work

Labour calls for nationalisation of process of fixing high-rise flats to eliminate administration fees

Property agents stand to earn hundreds of millions of pounds by charging administration fees on works to make buildings safe after the Grenfell Tower fire, Labour has said, as it urged the government to nationalise the process of making high-rise flats safe.

Managing agents of tower blocks caught up in the building safety crisis are charging fees of around 4% on multimillion-pound works to fix cladding and combustible walls on thousands of homes. With the government having pledged £5.1bn for the works so far, the opposition has estimated that the fees on publicly funded repairs could reach £200m, with more charged on additional safety bills to be met from leaseholders’ own pockets.

Leaseholders have complained that the charges are excessive for the amount of administration the managing agents are undertaking and may amount to “profiteering”. So far, 2,820 buildings have registered with the government’s building safety fund to fix problems with buildings higher than 18 metres, and the deadline for applications is this Wednesday. Only 10% of the money in the latest £3.5bn fund announced has so far been allocated.

On one high-rise in Manchester where £5.1m is being sought from the fund, the managing agent is proposing to charge 4% on the works, according to Jamie Robb, one of the leaseholders. It is double the amount they are charging on repairing defects not covered by the fund, which will be paid by leaseholders.

Robb said he had called around other buildings in Manchester and found that managing agents were routinely charging between 3% and 5%. “The fact they are charging more on the taxpayer-funded works suggests … they are profiteering,” he said. “The managing agents will incur costs, but there have to be economies of scale. I can’t see how 4% is going to be a fair price.”

Robb said he backed Labour’s proposal of a public agency as it “takes out the opportunity for profiteering and guarantees fairness”.

Labour’s Mike Amesbury, the shadow housing minister, said it was “scandalous that money meant to prevent another Grenfell is being siphoned off by management agents”.

Giles Grover, 42, who lives in another complex in Manchester which is going to require £8m in taxpayer-funded repairs, said the managing agent was proposing a 4% fee. “Any percentage basis is not a fair way of doing things,” he said. “I am not sure what they are doing [for the fee]. The contractor updates us on a weekly basis and the engineer manages the project. There is no transparency around it. Everyone seems to be making money out of us.”

The housing minister, Chris Pincher, has said it is the responsibility of leaseholder groups applying for public funding to check that management fees are “informed by an industry-standard approach”. He told parliament this month that while the government has not analysed the fees, “higher than expected costs will be challenged and … the level of grant may be reduced”.

Lucy Powell, the shadow housing secretary, said: “The government’s hands-off approach is blighted by inertia and beset by spiralling costs. Ministers are leaving industry bosses to mark their own homework and refusing to keep tabs on the fees these companies are charging.”

Labour’s proposed Building Works Agency, featuring engineers and building safety experts, would decide what works are necessary, commission and pay for them, and have legal powers to pursue those responsible through the courts. The agency would direct the remediation process, “cutting out middle men”.

A spokesperson for the Association of Residential Managing Agents said fees “have to be fair and proportional” and could be challenged in the courts.

“Although no one likes charging for cladding-related works, were managing agents unable to recover their costs, the only other option available to them would be to resign or face insolvency,” they said.

The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government said Labour’s claims were “a fundamental misrepresentation of the existing remediation process”. A spokesperson said: “It is vital that … work is professionally managed, which is why necessary project administration costs have been factored into the budget … and our cost safeguards ensure they are not excessive.

Contributor

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Post-Grenfell fire safety checks stepped up as cladding pulled from sale worldwide
75 blocks at risk of fire identified as government urges landlords of more than 500 others to provide samples urgently

Robert Booth and Matthew Weaver

26, Jun, 2017 @6:23 PM

Article image
Post-Grenfell fire safety: leaseholders risk being fleeced, warns top adviser
Exclusive: Dame Judith Hackitt urges people to challenge huge bills by insisting on second opinion

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

08, Sep, 2021 @11:47 AM

Article image
Outrage as ministers reject post-Grenfell safety plans for disabled people
Personal fire evacuation plans were in public inquiry’s proposals, which ministers had said they would ‘accept in full’

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

18, May, 2022 @5:47 PM

Article image
Grenfell survivors accuse government of fire safety ‘Russian roulette’
Ministers have failed to fix hundreds of thousands of dangerous homes in four years since disaster, say campaigners

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

14, Jun, 2021 @4:00 AM

Article image
Anger as Grenfell boss is invited to speak at housing safety event
Woman in charge of TMO at time of fire quits conference after criticism from survivors

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

02, May, 2019 @6:06 PM

Article image
Delays to safety reforms ‘risk a repeat of Grenfell disaster’
MPs say ministers must work faster as hundreds of towers still have dangerous cladding

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

17, Jul, 2019 @11:44 PM

Article image
Group linked to Grenfell foam supplier awarded building safety contract
Exclusive: consortium with links to Kingspan awarded £600,000 housing ministry grant

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

11, Nov, 2020 @1:25 PM

Article image
Post-Grenfell social housing reforms in England to be unveiled
Housing secretary to publish white paper advocating better protections for tenants

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

16, Nov, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Grenfell firm stretched truth with fire safety claims, ex-worker says
Inquiry hears insulation maker Kingspan was struggling to get its product to pass tests

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

23, Nov, 2020 @2:49 PM

Article image
Multiple fire safety risks found at flats with Grenfell-style cladding
Residents at 11-block New Capital Quay in London tell of fear as fire officials raise concerns

Robert Booth and Lisa O'Carroll

15, Feb, 2018 @4:17 PM