The ‘human rights’ sex trade case that will harm women

A European court judgment this week could reverse laws that protect the vulnerable and abused

A case to be heard in the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg this week could have disastrous consequences for those campaigning to eradicate prostitution.

The hearing is the first step in determining whether France’s laws on prostitution – which criminalise paying for sex – are constitutional, or whether they contravene the human rights of self-titled “sex workers”.

France introduced the legislation, known as the abolitionist model, in 2016, joining a growing list of countries (Sweden, Norway, Canada, Northern Ireland, the Republic of Ireland and Israel) where it is illegal to buy sex, shifting the criminal responsibility to the buyer, who is fined if caught.

It was controversial from the start, with sex workers’ rights campaigners arguing that a better solution would be to decriminalise the entire sex trade, including pimping, brothel owning and kerb crawling.

But prostitution is dangerous and degrading for the vast majority of women involved. Removing laws pertaining to pimping and brothel owning, and legitimising men paying for sex, results in a further entrenchment of the view that prostitution is an inevitability, and, as has been said to me countless times, “the oldest profession”. I prefer to use the phrase “the oldest oppression”.

In December 2019, a challenge to the law in France was lodged before the French constitutional court, but the law was upheld. In its ruling the judges said that the law helped protect women “by depriving pimps of their profits” and that it “fights against this activity and against the sexual exploitation of human beings, criminal activities founded on coercion and enslavement”.

The claimants – 250 individuals involved in prostitution, supported by 19 French NGOs – are now taking the case to the ECHR.

The fact that the applicants are using human rights legislation to argue for the “right” of men to pay for sex is staggering. Prostitution is a human rights violation of the women involved, and men have no right to pay for sex. In this case, the so-called “human right” of women to sell sex is being used as a smokescreen to protect the men and their right to sexual access to the most vulnerable women.

The applicants claim that the law contravenes three articles in the European convention on human rights: the right to life; prohibition of inhuman and degrading treatment; right to a private life. One of the arguments is that the law puts women’s lives in danger by driving prostitution underground; that they are more likely to face violence from sex buyers because only “bad” punters will take the risk; and that women have the right to make autonomous decisions to sell sex.

There is no evidence for these claims – on the contrary, research in those countries that have adopted the abolitionist model has shown that rates of violence and homicide perpetrated on women by pimps and punters is far lower than in decriminalised regimes.

The implications are huge – if the plaintiffs win, all the other countries with a similar law will doubtless be challenged by pro-prostitution lobbyists. If, however, they lose, this will further entrench the legality and highlight the successes of the abolitionist model. A lot is hanging on this case in terms of the direction that other countries take when dealing with its own sex trade.

What are the alternatives to curbing the demand? Blanket decriminalisation or legalisation, as adopted by Holland, Germany, and Switzerland.

But legalisation has failed miserably. Under this regime, demand for sexual services, trafficking of women and girls, and illegal brothels have increased. There is no evidence of a decrease in violence, HIV rates or murders of women in legal sex trades, but there is evidence that the rights and freedoms promised by lobbyists for legalisation and decriminalisation were transferred to the brothel owners and sex buyers.

Space International, a feminist NGO founded by sex trade survivors that campaigns for the abolitionist model, has applied to intervene in the case and will submit evidence about the benefits of the law. For example, that the law includes provision for exiting services for women who wish to leave prostitution, and protection from pimps and other exploiters.

If the applicants are successful, the judgment will become case law to be relied upon in the future and could lead to pimps funding big campaigns to repeal sex buyer laws in other countries to protect profits.

Let’s hope that the judges see sense and understand that a repeal of the abolitionist model will lead to more misery for women, and amnesty on sexual exploiters.

Contributor

Julie Bindel

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sex trafficking trade forces women from streets of Odessa to massage parlours of Britain
Many women drawn to the Ukrainian city end up working as prostitutes in the UK, but our government seems unwilling to act

Mark Townsend

02, Jul, 2011 @9:54 PM

Article image
In Riyadh and the Riviera, women have to fight for the right to be themselves
Compared with the problem of radicalisation in jails, the burkini ban was a distraction, but an all-too-familiar one

Sanam Naraghi Anderlini

27, Aug, 2016 @11:05 PM

Article image
Outlaw prostitution websites to protect enslaved and trafficked women, say MPs
Online advertisements accessible in the UK are at the heart of a sex industry with organised crime links

Toby Helm

30, Jun, 2018 @9:25 PM

Article image
Zahia Dehar: from teenage escort to the summer star of French cinema
At 17, Zahia Dehar was caught up in a football sex scandal. Now her first film is the talk of Paris

Kim Willsher in Paris

25, Aug, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
How do we talk to teens about sex in a world of porn?
Teenage boys’ easy access to violent sexual images is creating a crisis for them – and for women, argues the anti-porn campaigner

Julie Bindel

10, Oct, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Revealed: women making clothes for west face sexual abuse
Study finds workers in Vietnamese factories have been harassed, groped and even raped

Kate Hodal

07, Apr, 2019 @5:59 AM

Article image
Vaccine wars: the week that rocked the UK’s Covid jab rollout
After a week of bans, U-turns and warnings of supply shortfalls, public confidence in vaccination has been dented. Can Britain get back on the fast track out of lockdown?

Robin McKie, Michael Savage, James Tapper and Kim Willsher in Paris

21, Mar, 2021 @9:30 AM

Article image
France's burqa ban upheld by human rights court
European judges declare that preservation of a certain idea of 'living together' was legitimate aim of French authorities.

Kim Willsher in Paris

01, Jul, 2014 @11:10 AM

Article image
Revealed: Priti Patel U-turn on end to detention for refugee women
Home Office accused of betrayal over network of new asylum-seeker centres

Mark Townsend Home Affairs Editor

27, Feb, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
Vice case puts Dominique Strauss-Kahn and French attitudes to sex on trial
The former presidential hopeful’s fall will reach its nadir in a sordid sex-party trial that signals a moral shift in France, writes Kim Willsher

Kim Willsher in Lille

31, Jan, 2015 @8:07 PM