Woman with Down’s syndrome takes Sajid Javid to court over abortion law

Heidi Crowter alongside Máire Lea-Wilson and her son Aidan argue the 1967 act is discriminatory

Allowing pregnancy terminations up to birth if the foetus has Down’s syndrome is discriminatory and stigmatises disabled people, the high court has heard.

Heidi Crowter, a 26-year-old woman with Down’s syndrome from Coventry, Máire Lea-Wilson, 33, and her son Aidan, who has Down’s syndrome, who both live in Brentford, west London are challenging Sajid Javid over the Abortion Act 1967. The act sets a 24-week time limit for abortions unless there is “substantial risk” of the child being “seriously handicapped”.

The three argue it is discriminatory, interferes with the right to respect for private life in article 8(1) of the European convention on human rights (ECHR), including the decision to become or not to become a parent and “rights to dignity, autonomy and personal development of all three claimants”.

Jason Coppel QC, representing the claimants, told the high court in London on Tuesday that Crowter, who has her own flat, recently got married and has pursued studies up to NVQ level, “has been the subject of abuse because of her disability and believes that the existence of a law allowing abortion up to birth for babies with DS [Down’s syndrome] is a contributory cultural cause of this type of abuse”.

Aidan was diagnosed with Down’s syndrome at 35 weeks’ gestation in 2019 and his mother was repeatedly offered an abortion. “The pressure she was put under, the lack of support offered to her, the guilt she was made to feel for not having undergone screening, the impression conveyed that by going ahead with the pregnancy she would be going against medical advice, the negativity about DS and the fear engendered about having a child with DS all conveyed the message to her that a life with DS was of no value,” said Coppel.

He told the court Down’s syndrome was the single largest justification for “late-term abortions” justified under the Abortion Act 1967.

Coppel said the current law “perpetuates and reinforces negative cultural stereotypes to the detriment of people with disabilities, such as the first [Crowter] and third [Aidan] claimants. They continue to suffer a serious diminution in the perception of the value of their lives, which affects all aspects of their day-to-day life. The effects of this negative stereotyping were also felt by the second claimant [Lea-Wilson] as carer and parent of the third claimant.”

Speaking before going into court, Crowter said: “I find it extremely offensive that a law doesn’t respect my life, and I won’t stand for it. I want to change the law and I want to challenge people’s perception of Down’s syndrome.”

Lea-Wilson said: “I have two sons who I love and I value equally and I can’t understand why the law doesn’t.

“I want Aidan to grow up knowing he’s not someone people have to cope with, he’s not a burden to society, he is a wonderful human being in his own right. And so I want the law to change so that the rules for a typical baby apply for those with Down’s syndrome.”

The case is scheduled for two days with judgment expected to be reserved.


Haroon Siddique Legal affairs correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Woman with Down’s syndrome loses court of appeal abortion law case
Heidi Crowter argued that the law was discriminatory and stigmatised disabled people

Matthew Weaver

25, Nov, 2022 @2:38 PM

Article image
Woman with Down’s syndrome loses UK abortion law case
Heidi Crowter has argued allowing terminations up to birth if foetus has Down’s syndrome is discriminatory

Alexandra Topping and agencies

23, Sep, 2021 @11:37 AM

Article image
Down's syndrome test could see condition disappear, C of E warns
Church says new NHS test could lead to more terminations and fewer people born with condition

Harriet Sherwood Religion correspondent

19, Jan, 2018 @2:28 PM

Article image
Down’s syndrome and the threat of eugenics | Letters
Letters: Sally Phillips’ programme offers a timely reminder of the dangers of embarking on a determinist view of society and the risk that selective breeding is acceptable


09, Oct, 2016 @6:42 PM

Article image
Campaigners await UK decision on abortion clinic buffer zones
Pro-choice activists say they expect announcement from Home Office within weeks

Caroline Davies

13, Aug, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Living with Down’s syndrome: ‘He’s not a list of characteristics. He’s my son’
Most women whose babies are diagnosed with Down’s syndrome end the pregnancy. But with a more accurate test on the horizon, a group of parents want to change perceptions

Olivia Gordon

17, Oct, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
Sorry, Sally Phillips, but a woman should be able to know if her unborn baby has Down’s syndrome | Hadley Freeman
A woman’s right to terminate a pregnancy is non-negotiable. Even if Phillips – someone I’ve long-admired – doesn’t like their reasons

Hadley Freeman

06, Oct, 2016 @4:02 PM

Article image
Abortion campaigners target Sajid Javid over Northern Ireland
Pro-choice MPs seek to put down amendment to grant right to access terminations

Rajeev Syal

11, Jun, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Sajid Javid vows to ‘go after’ those responsible for NHS maternity scandal
Health secretary says he wants people held to account for Shrewsbury and Telford hospital trust failings

Andrew Gregory and Denis Campbell

31, Mar, 2022 @4:40 PM

Article image
A woman’s right to abort a foetus with Down’s syndrome | Letters
Letters: Every baby should be wanted, and forcing a woman to carry an unwanted foetus to term is hardly the best start, says Ruth Brandon

28, Nov, 2022 @5:40 PM