Lawful to imprison trans women sex offenders in female jails, judge rules

High court for England and Wales rejects challenge of former inmate who claims she was sexually assaulted by trans prisoner

A legal challenge to prevent transgender inmates with convictions for sexual or violent offences against women being imprisoned alongside other women has been rejected by the high court.

A female former inmate, who claims she was sexually assaulted by a transgender women prisoner with a gender recognition certificate (GRC) while in HMP Bronzefield in 2017, asked judges to declare the justice secretary’s policies on the care and management of trans prisoners in England and Wales to be unlawful.

The claimant, known only as FDJ, argued her human rights were violated by having to be in the same prison as transgender women prisoners with convictions for sexual or violent offences against women.

In a judgment handed down on Friday, Lord Justice Holroyde, sitting with Mr Justice Swift, dismissed the claim. He acknowledged the “fear and anxiety” some female inmates would suffer if a transgender inmate was in the same jail, but said existing policies should mitigate this.

“The difficulty which the claimant faces, in my view, is that it is not possible to argue that the defendant should have excluded from women’s prisons all transgender women,” he wrote.

“To do so would be to ignore, impermissibly, the rights of transgender women to live in their chosen gender; and it is not the course which the claimant herself says the defendant should have taken. The submissions on behalf of the claimant attached weight to the offending history of the transgender woman concerned; but that is a factor which the care and management policy specifically requires the LCB [local transgender case board] and/or CCB [transgender complex case board] to consider.”

The court heard that in 2019 there were 163 transgender prisoners in England and Wales, 81 of whom had been convicted of one or more sexual offences. Of the 163, 34 were held in women’s prisons.

Between 2016 and 2019, a total of 97 sexual assaults were recorded in women’s prisons, of which seven appeared to be committed by transgender prisoners without a GRC. It is not known whether any were committed by transgender women with a GRC but the number of transgender prisoners with a GRC across all jails is thought to be in single figures.

Holroyde said the statistics were too low and had insufficient detail to provide a safe basis for conclusions, adding: “I can accept, at any rate for present purposes, that the unconditional introduction of a transgender woman into the general population of a women’s prison carries a statistically greater risk of sexual assault upon non-transgender prisoners than would be the case if a non-transgender woman were introduced. But that statistical conclusion takes no account of the risk assessment which the policies require.”

The judge said the “fear and anxiety” some female inmates would suffer if a transgender inmate – “particularly one with male genitalia and/or with a history of sexual or violent offending against women” – was accommodated in the same prison would be assessed by the LCBs and CCBs, who “will surely be well aware of the vulnerabilities of the women who are held in the female prison estate”.

FDJ argued that the justice secretary should have invoked schedule 3 of the Equality Act 2010, which allows exemptions against discrimination – in this case against trans women – in relation to single-sex spaces. But the judges said schedule 3 was discretionary.

• This article was amended on 2 July 2021. An earlier version incorrectly stated the proportion of transgender prisoners held in women’s prisons.


Haroon Siddique

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Trans woman guilty of raping two women remanded in female prison in Scotland
Politicians, campaigners and UN special rapporteur concerned by case of Isla Bryson, who offended before she had transitioned

Libby Brooks

25, Jan, 2023 @6:49 PM

Article image
Why Scotland’s gender reform bill is sparking concern over trans prisoner policies
Analysts warn of legal challenges if bill makes inmates’ access to gender recognition certificates easier – though jail allocation is decided case by case

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

26, Jan, 2023 @5:37 PM

Article image
Self-harm among female prisoners in England and Wales at record high
Official figures show steep rise during pandemic in number of incidents involving women

Jamie Grierson Home affairs correspondent

28, Jan, 2021 @1:54 PM

Article image
Number of offenders with indefinite sentences recalled to prison soars
Exclusive: Campaigners say people are being sent back to jail in England and Wales ‘for no good reason’

Haroon Siddique Legal affairs correspondent

03, Sep, 2023 @4:00 PM

Article image
Rules on whether transgender prisoners go to male or female jails to be reviewed
Ministry of Justice says it will re-evaluate how transgender people are treated, after recent deaths of women in male prisons

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

08, Dec, 2015 @6:52 PM

Article image
Number of children in custody in England and Wales set to double by 2024
Report also highlights increasing over-representation of black and minority ethnic children in custody

Sally Weale Education correspondent

28, Apr, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Karen White: how 'manipulative' transgender inmate attacked again
Former neighbours describe 52-year-old as volatile and violent amid questions over placement in all-female prison

Nazia Parveen North of England correspondent

11, Oct, 2018 @4:30 PM

Article image
More male staff could help with offenders, says England and Wales probation chief
Kim Thornden-Edwards says it may be good to tackle issues of masculinity and power from a male perspective

Amelia Hill

04, Apr, 2023 @9:51 AM

Article image
Number of supervised offenders charged with violent crimes rises 21%
There were 627 serious further offence reviews in England and Wales last year, FoI data shows

Jamie Grierson Home affairs correspondent

14, Oct, 2018 @3:43 PM

Article image
Trans violent offenders banned from women’s prisons in England and Wales
New rules also cover transgender women ‘with their male genitalia intact’, says Dominic Raab

Peter Walker Political correspondent

26, Feb, 2023 @5:15 PM