UK government drops gender self-identification plan for trans people

Medical diagnosis will still be required in England and Wales after consultation on 2004 Gender Recognition Act

Plans to allow people to officially change gender without a medical diagnosis are not being adopted by Downing Street, which is instead cutting the cost of applying for a gender recognition certificate as part of moves to revamp the process.

In a written ministerial statement setting out the government’s long-delayed response to the 2004 Gender Recognition Act consultation, the women and equalities minister, Liz Truss, said the act struck the correct balance, “in that there are proper checks and balances in the system and also support for people who want to change their legal sex”.

Proposals developed under Theresa May’s government to allow people to “self-identify” as their chosen gender – by signing a statutory declaration without having to provide evidence of a medical diagnosis of gender dysphoria – are not part of the government’s response.

Instead, the government will cut the £140 cost of applying for a gender recognition certificate to a “nominal amount” in England and Wales, as well as placing the whole procedure online as part of changes to make the process “kinder and more straightforward”.

In an attempt to combat lengthy NHS waiting lists for transgender people, Truss said the government was opening three new gender clinics this year. Truss said she was “deeply concerned at the distress” the long waiting lists could cause and the move should result in them being cut by about 1,600 patients by 2022.

Truss said: “We have also come to understand that gender recognition reform, though supported in the consultation undertaken by the last government, is not the top priority for transgender people. Perhaps their most important concern is the state of trans healthcare. Trans people tell us that waiting lists at NHS gender clinics are too long. I agree, and I am deeply concerned at the distress it can cause.”

The government was immediately condemned by Stonewall, which has been campaigning for the rights of trans people to change their birth certificates without a medical diagnosis, for putting forward “only minimal administrative changes”.

The charity’s chief executive, Nancy Kelley, said: ‘Today, the UK government has fallen far short on its promise to reform the Gender Recognition Act, and has missed a key opportunity to progress LGBT equality.

“It’s a shocking failure in leadership that after three years and a robust public consultation, the UK government has put forward only minimal administrative changes to improve the process for legal gender recognition of trans people in England and Wales. While these moves will make the current process less costly and bureaucratic, they don’t go anywhere near far enough toward meaningfully reforming the act to make it easier for all trans people to go about their daily life.”

Mermaids, a charity that supports young trans people, raised concerns that none of the proposals offered help to those under the age of 18. Susie Green, the charity’s CEO, added: “We are disappointed that the government reforms make no mention of non-binary identities and fall short of self-declaration, a move which would have brought England and Wales into line with our neighbours in the Republic of Ireland, where society has benefited from a de-medicalised system for gender recognition since 2015, without any problematic outcomes.”

Under the current gender recognition legislation, which was passed in 2004, in order to change their birth certificate an individual must be over the age of 18 and apply to a panel providing medical evidence of a diagnosis of gender dysphoria as well as proof that they have been living in their preferred gender for at least two years. Trans people have described the current medical requirements of the process as intrusive and humiliating.

Labour rounded on the government’s response, accusing Downing Street of failing trans people. The shadow women and equalities secretary, Marsha de Cordova, said: “After three years of toxic debate, it is deeply disappointing that the government have let trans people down at the last minute.

“Trans people face daily discrimination and it is vital that steps are taken to tackle discrimination and provide the services and support people need. Labour is committed to equality and inclusion for trans people and we continue to support updating the Gender Recognition Act to introduce self-declaration for trans people.”

A spokesperson for the Equality and Human Rights Commission said: “We welcome steps to reduce fees and NHS waiting times. However, this was a missed opportunity to simplify the law on gender recognition whilst maintaining robust safeguards.”

Critics of the concept of self-identification welcomed the announcement. Fair Play for Women, which argued that the reform would significantly undermine women’s sex-based rights, described it as “a fair decision balancing the rights of all; trans people and women”, adding that “today marks a fresh approach to all policies on sex and gender. The government has acknowledged women are stakeholders too and policies must fairly balance the conflicting rights of trans people and women”.


Simon Murphy and Libby Brooks

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Let trans people self-identify their gender, Corbyn urges May
Labour leader says party would support any attempt to change law that would remove need for medical checks

Rowena Mason

19, Jul, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Labour suspends activist challenging gender self-identification policy
David Lewis stood for women’s officer role claiming that he was ‘a woman on Wednesdays’

Jessica Elgot Political correspondent

23, May, 2018 @9:07 AM

Article image
Holyrood committee backs self-declaration for transgender people
Report on Scotland’s gender recognition reform bill supports removing need for psychiatric diagnosis

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

06, Oct, 2022 @3:34 PM

Article image
Labour mayors urge government to speed up gender law changes
Khan and Burnham among those saying process for trans people to self-ID should be easier

Helen Pidd and Maya Wolfe-Robinson

18, Jul, 2019 @1:56 PM

Article image
Stonewall is at centre of a toxic debate on trans rights and gender identity
Some have called the LGBT rights charity extremist, others say it’s on the right side of history

Haroon Siddique

05, Jun, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Nicola Sturgeon pledges gender recognition law reform for trans people
SNP leader’s vow includes pledge to ensure Scotland legislates for non-binary gender recognition if party wins Holyrood election

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

01, Apr, 2016 @12:54 PM

Article image
Women's Equality party runs consultation on self-identification for trans people
Party hopes to ‘shift the dial’ on fraught debate ahead of decision on Gender Recognition Act

Libby Brooks

17, Sep, 2020 @3:32 PM

Article image
Court battle looms as UK ministers block Scottish gender recognition law
Nicola Sturgeon says her government will ‘vigorously defend’ legislation by seeking judicial review of decision

Peter Walker and Libby Brooks

17, Jan, 2023 @4:23 PM

Article image
Trans people can be excluded from single-sex services if ‘justifiable’, says EHRC
UK government’s equalities watchdog says justifications could include reasons of privacy or health and safety

Rajeev Syal Home affairs editor

04, Apr, 2022 @2:31 PM

Article image
Regulator escalates investigation into trans charity Mermaids
‘Newly identified’ governance and management issues prompt Charity Commission statutory inquiry

Amelia Gentleman

02, Dec, 2022 @6:32 PM