The Glamour Boys: gay MPs who gave early warning of Nazi threat

The group, who visited Weimar Berlin to enjoy its nightlife, witnessed the danger Hitler posed, a new book reveals

They were attacked as warmongers, threatened with deselection and despised by Neville Chamberlain, who branded them “the Glamour Boys”. Yet a new book has claimed that a group of gay MPs were among the first to warn Britain about the danger Hitler posed. Four of them later died in action.

The extraordinary untold story of gay and bisexual British politicians and their bravery in the second world war has been unearthed by Chris Bryant, Labour MP for Rhondda.

Without these parliamentary rebels sounding the alarm as early as 1932 and speaking and voting against Chamberlain’s policy of appeasement, Bryant argues, Britain “would never have gone to war with Hitler, Churchill would never have become prime minister and Nazism would never have been defeated”.

Using previously unseen documents, including diaries, private letters, photo albums and material found in the National Archives, Tate galleries and Eton College library, Bryant spent five years piecing together the stories of men whose sexuality and heroism has been excised from history until now.

The Night of the Long Knives in Berlin, 1934
The Night of the Long Knives in Berlin, 1934. Photograph: Photo 12/Alamy

From Jack Macnamara, the young Conservative MP for Chelmsford, and Ronnie Cartland, the younger brother of the novelist Barbara, to Victor Cazalet, a first world war hero, and Robert Bernays, a Liberal member of the national government, Bryant charts their alarm at Hitler’s territorial ambitions, prompted by their frequent trips to Berlin, then considered the most sexually liberated place in the world.

“Everyone was fascinated by Germany,” Bryant told the Observer. “There was the feeling that the country had been treated terribly by the Versailles treaty and it was time that Germany should be allowed to get up off his knees.

“So in this Weimar Republic, you had a phenomenal flourishing of bars and restaurants – which is what gave us Cabaret the movie – and lots of men went there two or three times a year.”

Chris Bryant MP
Chris Bryant: ‘These men’s sexuality was an essential aspect of their bravery.’ Photograph: Phil Warren

But the treatment of Jews and the assassination of homosexuals in Hitler’s purge of political opponents in the Night of the Long Knives in 1934 propelled the so-called Glamour Boys to vehemently oppose what they witnessed taking place. Swimming against the tide in their political and personal lives, the men risked exposure and imprisonment when they enlisted and became ardent campaigners for rearmament.

“We like to think we know the story of how Britain went to war in 1939, but this part of the story has never been told,” says Bryant. “And this hidden history matters because, for centuries, homosexual men have been portrayed as hedonistic, effeminate, limp-wristed, couldn’t catch a ball and that sort of thing. It was assumed they would be physically and morally weak.

“But [for these men] their sexuality was an essential aspect of their bravery, and they showed the courage of their convictions by enlisting.”

Homosexuality in Britain remained illegal until 1967, and the men lived their lives in practised subterfuge: ruffling bedsheets in a second bedroom to pretend their lover had slept there, changing pronouns from him to her and he to she to talk about their partners. Some married, as in the case of Bernays, whose two sons Bryant tracked down for what became a crucial trove of material.

“By definition, gay men’s private lives from the 1930s weren’t much documented – families conveniently left them out or got rid of their diaries and so on. Jack Macnamara’s brother, for instance, who was a famous RAF man in his own right, refused to inherit from Jack when he died [as an officer in Italy in 1944] because Jack was gay.”

Rob Bernays, right, in Italy in 1944
Rob Bernays MP, right, visiting a British outpost in Italy in the winter of 1944. Photograph: Mondadori Portfolio/Mondadori/Getty Images

Macnamara was MP for Chelmsford from 1935 until he died, and his personal assistant was the Soviet spy Guy Burgess. “Burgess told people that he went on sex trips with [Macnamara] in Nazi Germany. Now who’s not going to be intrigued by that sentence?”

Bryant, an author of six political histories, thought he might have to tell the story as a novel, but was amazed at how much he discovered through persistent digging. The former priest says his interest was piqued by the 23 shields in the House of Commons commemorating MPs killed in action. At least four of them, Bryant could confidently identify as “queer” in the modern sense.

“I’ve been very careful in the book not to overstate what I can prove or go beyond what I can state with certainty,” says Bryant. “But my working assumption has been that they had more sex than we know about. He hopes The Glamour Boys, published next month by Bloomsbury, will have an impact on the national curriculum and of what is and isn’t taught in school history lessons.

“Churchill gets all the credit all the time because that’s what he wrote. He was opposed to the policy of appeasement, and all the rest of it, but what nobody, I guess, would know is that half the time when Churchill and [Anthony] Eden were plotting with the rebels, roughly half the men in the room were ‘queer’. At the time, we had the most strict laws we’ve ever had on homosexuality, and dozens and dozens of people were being arrested all the time and going to prison. These men had their phones tapped, they risked exposure, but they were made of stern stuff.”

By the end of the decade, Berlin’s sexual liberation seemed all but over as gay men were sent to concentration camps. “Progress is never won permanently,” warns Bryant. “It is not linear and I hope people realise that parliamentary rebels are our most precious jewels.”


Nosheen Iqbal

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A Renaissance masterpiece, Nazi looters, a double murder … and a happy ending
His grandparents had to sell their paintings for a pittance – and then were killed. Bernard Goodman on why one means so much

Dalya Alberge

26, Jul, 2020 @6:33 AM

Article image
'The slate will never be clean': lessons from the Nuremberg trials 75 years on
Three Holocaust survivors reflect on a milestone in international justice and their struggle to come to terms with the past

Harriet Sherwood

15, Nov, 2020 @10:30 AM

Article image
My grandmother’s Nazi killer evaded justice. Modern war criminals must not
As the 75th anniversary of the Nuremburg trials approaches, Ilse Cohn’s grandson calls for international law to ensure those committing atrocities today face retribution

Robin Lustig

19, Sep, 2021 @7:15 AM

Article image
From fleeing Hitler to Mars: the scientist who changed space travel
The remarkable journey of Ben Abeles will be celebrated next week by the opening of a new archive

Robin McKie Science editor

28, May, 2023 @9:00 AM

Article image
How the BBC’s truth offensive beat Hitler’s propaganda machine
Accurate radio reporting of British defeats helped win trust of German listeners

Jamie Doward

15, Apr, 2017 @3:49 PM

Article image
Germany to quash historical convictions of gay men
Government plans to annul convictions of tens of thousands of men who were criminalised under 19th-century law

Kate Connolly in Berlin

11, May, 2016 @4:08 PM

Article image
How the ‘art of the insane’ inspired the surrealists – and was twisted by the Nazis
The author of an acclaimed new book tells how Hitler used works by psychiatric patients in his culture war

Charlie English

08, Aug, 2021 @8:45 AM

Article image
Churchill tried to suppress Nazi plot to restore Edward VIII to British throne
PM sought US and French help to withhold publication of telegrams revealing German overtures to Duke and Duchess of Windsor, cabinet papers reveal

Alan Travis Home affairs editor

20, Jul, 2017 @9:01 AM

Article image
Richard Strauss was no unrepentant Nazi | Letters
Letters: Among the later operas that Hitler didn’t listen to was, of course, Strauss’s pacifist Friedenstag (1936), with a libretto essentially by the Jewish Stefan Zweig


13, Apr, 2016 @6:11 PM

Article image
Unknown heroes who faced death behind Nazi lines keep their secrets
Ex-SOE and SAS agents are being honoured by France but some still shun the limelight

Jamie Doward

22, Aug, 2015 @3:23 PM