Four-week cancer treatment delay raises death risk by 10% – study

Concern for NHS cancer patients after record numbers miss treatment due to pandemic

Delaying cancer treatment by just four weeks increases the risk of death by up to 10%, according to new research that shows the devastating impact of missed NHS treatment targets due to Covid.

Earlier this year, Dr Ajay Aggarwal at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine estimated that diagnostic delays caused by lockdown measures and changes to patient behaviour as a result of Covid-19 would result in 3,500 avoidable deaths from breast, lung, oesophageal or bowel cancer in England over the next five years. However, the impact of delaying treatment for patients with an existing cancer diagnosis was unclear.

To investigate, Aggarwal, together with colleagues led by Timothy Hanna from Queen’s University in Kingston, Canada, turned to international studies that had assessed the impact of treatment delays on patients with bladder, breast, colon, rectum, lung, cervix, and head and neck cancers over the past 20 years. Pooling the results of 34 such studies involving more than 1.2 million patients they found that delaying surgery, radiotherapy or drug treatment by just four weeks could have a devastating impact. The study, published in the British Medical Journal, suggests that the risk of death increases the longer that treatment is delayed.

An unprecedented number of cancer patients missed out on vital treatments, diagnostic tests and outpatient appointments as the pandemic unfolded, according to NHS England data, and waiting times for all the key stages of cancer care soared as many NHS services were suspended during the first lockdown.

In April 2019 almost 200,000 people in England were referred to a consultant by their GPs for suspected cancer; in April 2020 that figure fell to 79,573.

“I don’t think we’ve realised how significant the impact of treatment delays are until now,” Aggarwal said. “There was a suggestion at the beginning of the pandemic that for some surgeries like bowel cancer, you could have a 12-week delay [with minimal impact on patient outcomes]. This tells us that that is not the case. There is no safe delay for these cancers.”

For surgery, each four-week delay was associated with a 6-8% increased risk of death for all cancers, and for head and neck radiotherapy it was 9%. Meanwhile, delaying follow-up drug treatment after surgery for patients with colorectal cancer was associated with a 13% increased risk of death.

Bowel cancer is the UK’s second-biggest cancer killer, and the pandemic has led to many patients having their treatment delayed or cancelled, said Dr Lisa Wilde, the director of research and external affairs at Bowel Cancer UK. “We’re extremely concerned that we will see a further increase in deaths from the disease as a result of delays to treatment,” she said.

The researchers also calculated that, for breast cancer, a surgical delay of 12 weeks would add up to 1,400 excess deaths in the UK over the course of a year.

A recent analysis by Cancer Research UK (CRUK) estimated that about 12,750 fewer cancer patients had had surgery, 6,000 fewer had received chemotherapy and 2,800 fewer had had radiotherapy due to the postponement of routine NHS care during the pandemic.

“Worryingly, the latest England cancer waiting time data for August shows that targets for patients beginning treatment within 62 days of an urgent cancer referral are still being missed,” said Dr Jodie Moffat, CRUK’s head of early diagnosis. “As health services are now having to manage a resurgence of Covid-19 on top of usual winter pressures, investment is urgently needed to make sure the NHS has the staff and equipment it needs to provide patients with life-saving diagnosis and treatment.”

Contributor

Linda Geddes Science correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Cancer survival rates three times higher with early diagnosis
Data from Cancer Research UK suggests 80% of patients survive for at least 10 years after being diagnosed in early stages of eight of most common cancers

James Meikle

09, Aug, 2015 @11:43 PM

Article image
Daily glass of wine increases a woman's cancer risk, finds study

Study suggests drinking just one small glass of wine a day significantly increases the risk of common cancers

Ian Sample, science correspondent

24, Feb, 2009 @9:00 PM

Article image
Too many cancer patients delay going to doctor with symptoms
The worst are those with rectal bleeding and those living in deprived areas, research at King's College London reveals

Denis Campbell, health correspondent

10, Jun, 2014 @11:05 PM

Article image
Coronavirus may cause 3,500 deaths in England from four main cancers
Study shows diagnosis delays most likely to affect young or middle-aged in next five years

Sarah Boseley Health editor

20, Jul, 2020 @9:30 PM

Article image
Even moderate intake of red meat raises cancer risk, study finds
People more or less keeping to NHS guidelines at higher risk than those who eat little

Sarah Boseley Health editor

17, Apr, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
New breast cancer treatment offers hope of longer life to younger women
Combining ribociclib with hormone therapy found to cut risk of death by up to a third

Jamie Doward

01, Jun, 2019 @3:59 PM

Article image
Study points toward personalised treatment for breast cancer
Research indicates that cancers are highly individual and would therefore respond best to individualised treatments

Nicola Davis

02, May, 2016 @7:29 PM

Article image
NHS cancer patients 'failing to be correctly monitored'
Concerns expressed that opportunities to save lives may be missed

Jessica Glenza in Chicago

01, Jun, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
Healthy lifestyle reduces cancer risk

Eating fruit and vegetables and keeping weight down can reduce risk of 12 major cancers by 39%, says international report

Staff and agencies

26, Feb, 2009 @10:48 AM

Article image
Woman whose NHS cancer trial was halted seeks to buy drug privately
Psychologist was due to get life-saving NHS cancer treatment until coronavirus struck

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

05, Jul, 2020 @11:01 PM