Veganism row breaks out after Joaquin Phoenix is told: be kinder to farmers

Claim that celebrity campaigns cause ‘enormous damage’ draws ire from animal rights groups

He has been called a diva and pretentious, and there are even those who don’t like his acting – but never before has Joaquin Phoenix been accused of causing mental health problems for British livestock farmers.

On Tuesday, the National Farmers’ Union (NFU) president, Minette Batters, changed all that, opening a new front against the US actor by claiming that he and other celebrity campaigners for veganism had played a part in demonising the UK’s meat producers and doing “enormous damage” to their wellbeing.

Days after the Joker actor’s Oscars speech attacking the meat industry, Batters said farmers fearing the imminent loss of their livelihoods and family holdings were in a state of stress and anxiety.

Asked at the union’s annual conference who she thought was driving the view that meat was bad and plants were good, she said: “A lot of people who seem to hit the red carpet at the Bafta awards.”

She added: “Celebrities have to be careful [because] there are real-life consequences for others … Joaquin Phoenix, he’s had a really challenging life, and you really feel for him and a lot of the things he was saying, but he has to remember there are people at the end of this, there are small family farms and they get hurt too.”

Her comments were immediately criticised by vegan and animal rights groups, who accused Batters of making claims without evidence and ignoring the ethical problems posed by meat production.

“Veganism is something of an easy target at the moment and I’m not sure that we are the cause of farmer’s problems,” said a spokesperson for the Vegan Society. “There are many causes of mental health issues and stress in farming and I haven’t seen evidence, a piece of research, showing that veganism is one of them.”

The NFU president, Minette Batters.
The NFU president, Minette Batters. Photograph: Fototek/PA

Phoenix, who has been a vegan since he was three, made a plea for tolerance and equality in his acceptance speech for the best actor award at the Oscars, saying no race, gender or species had rights over another.

“I think we’ve become very disconnected from the natural world,” he said. “We go into the natural world and we plunder it for its resources. We feel entitled to artificially inseminate a cow and steal her baby, even though her cries of anguish are unmistakeable. Then we take her milk that’s intended for her calf and we put it in our coffee and our cereal.”

Veganism continues to grow in popularity in the UK, with supermarkets clearing shelf space for plant-based ready meals, and meat-free dining in restaurants and pubs now commonplace.

Other celebrities who have spoken about the health benefits of plant-based diets are Benedict Cumberbatch, Ellie Goulding and Beyoncé, with their support credited with aiding a rise in veganism’s popularity.

Batters said she was not saying “veganism is wrong”, but argued that the debate around animal products had become so binary that meat was being put in the same category as tobacco.

“I remember the interview I did with Evan Davis on PM to talk about the government’s new food strategy and he said: ‘Is eating meat the new smoking?’ He compared us with the tobacco industry and you think, ‘Whoa, just think about all of this’.”

But the Vegan Society questioned whether its members were really so influential, pointing out that the total number of vegans in the UK was still only 600,000, and saying: “The fact is 99% of the population are still eating animal products. There might be a lot more meat reducers, but this is not an industry that has been threatened by veganism.”

Dawn Carr, the director of vegan corporate projects at People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (Peta), said farmers were not the only ones feeling anxious.

“We can’t turn a blind eye to the visible fear and distress shown by animals raised for their flesh, milk and eggs,” she said. “They have no choice, but farmers do: instead of sending sentient animals to slaughter, they can sow oats or soya beans or grow vegetables, grains, nuts or fruits instead, depending on the quality of their land.”

Batters called for kindness to be shown to farmers and an understanding that they were “human” too. “It’s very polarised and it’s doing enormous damage to the mental health of livestock farmers,” she said.

“It’s just about instilling this philosophy and being kind and farmers need – we all need – to think that too … in this world of social media, we just need to take a step back sometimes.”


Lisa O'Carroll

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Joaquin Phoenix saves cow and calf from slaughterhouse
Two days after his Oscars speech criticising the meat industry, the actor rescued Liberty and Indigo at a California slaughterhouse

Catherine Shoard

21, Feb, 2020 @2:44 PM

Article image
'The omnivore is alive and well in LA': the Oscars attempt to go green
The movie industry’s biggest bash boasts a 70% vegan menu and DIY candle in the gift bag. But meat eating is still readily present – as is a heavy reliance on air travel

Benjamin Lee in Los Angeles

08, Feb, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Calves and ‘cries of anguish’: why Joaquin Phoenix decried the dairy industry
The best actor Oscar winner gave a speech about humanity’s treatment of cows, shining a light on the harsher realities of milk production

Chas Newkey-Burden

10, Feb, 2020 @4:26 PM

Article image
Joaquin Phoenix's Oscars speech casts him as Hollywood's poster boy of progress | Steve Rose
The Joker star went off-script to bare his teeth at the meat industry, risking ridicule to advocate profound social change

Steve Rose

10, Feb, 2020 @9:56 AM

Article image
Joaquin Phoenix's Oscars speech in full: 'We feel entitled to artificially inseminate a cow and steal her baby'
The full text of Phoenix’s passionate winner’s speech, as he accepts the best actor Academy Award for Joker

Guardian film

10, Feb, 2020 @2:46 PM

Article image
'Some of the darkest places in the world': Joaquin Phoenix on a photobook about slaughterhouses
In Hidden, 40 photographers go inside factory farms and abattoirs to create a global indictment of the meat industry. Warning: contains images you may find upsetting

Olivia Wilson

18, Nov, 2020 @1:11 PM

Article image
Joaquin Phoenix responds to best actor Oscar with impassioned speech
Star of origin story for Batman supervillain takes top male acting prize at the Academy Awards

Andrew Pulver

10, Feb, 2020 @6:48 AM

Article image
Farm animals and humans should be treated the same, children say
Moral hierarchy giving different value to different animals is learned during adolescence, survey suggests

Steven Morris

11, Apr, 2022 @1:00 PM

Article image
Profile: Joaquin Phoenix

John Patterson wonders if Joaquin Phoenix has finally risen from his brother's ashes, and whether he'll make a good Cash.

John Patterson

14, Aug, 2004 @4:33 PM

Article image
Parasite's brilliant win is a portent of change in the conceited Hollywood club | Peter Bradshaw
The Academy has finally caught up with the outside world – its task now is to avoid returning to its insular ways

Peter Bradshaw

10, Feb, 2020 @6:45 AM