Perspectives on the trans debate | Letters

The recognition and support of a minority group should never be thought of as threatening rights for all, write several academics. I received no grant; only death threats, says another

We, as feminist academics and gender studies experts, wish to begin by expressing our support and commitment to the trans community both within higher education and beyond. We recognise that the recent letter published in the Guardian (Academics harassed over trans research, 17 October) may have caused pain and distress, and we find it deeply disappointing that some of our colleagues hold these views. While the signatories of the letter may feel like “outsiders” for their outdated views on gender, we would like to remind them that trans and non-binary people are literally dying for their right to exist (see Pearce, 2018).

Debate and disagreement that arises from these tensions across findings can indeed be productive. There seems to be little academically rigorous evidence informing these trans-exclusionary viewpoints. Much seems to be based in the scaremongering and moral panics experienced by other minority groups in the past (Muslim people of the 2000s, gay men in the 1980s and black people in the 1970s).

Moreover, we are particularly concerned with the letter’s suggestion that higher education is being led by some kind of trans and non-binary agenda. The recognition and support of a minority group should never be thought of as threatening or in conflict with securing rights for all. Over the years higher education institutions have developed increasing links with trans-advocacy organisations who provide training to ensure the safety and wellbeing of all staff, and to ensure that the Equality Act 2010 is fairly and legally implemented. This is not ideologically driven, this is policy-driven and evidence-based.
Dr Victoria Cann Lecturer in the humanities, University of East Anglia (UEA)
Dr Francisco Costa Lecturer in the humanities, UEA
Dr Miriam Kent Lecturer in film and media studies, UEA
Dr Helen Warner Lecturer in cultural politics, communication and media studies, UEA

• So, Dr Luke McGuire (Letters, 19 October) thinks that the academics who signed the letter in your pages calling for an end to the harassment of researchers into transgenderism are motivated by shallow “self-interest”? He thinks that we are only in it because of our “desire to publish or receive grants”?

I laughed a bitter laugh of incredulity (and, frankly, scorn) when I read this. No academic in their right mind would say or write anything whatsoever of a feminist nature in this area if they were acting out of self-interest; because to do so invites instant flaming of the kind clearly visible on your letters page. When I spoke out on the issue, I received no grant; only death threats. Self-interest? What a joke.

The only conceivable motivation for academics speaking out in this area is that we want to speak feminist truth to the power of the now-hegemonic trans lobby. We want it to be possible for people working in this area to actually be able to think – rather than having to kowtow to the received unwisdom that having the thought “I feel like a woman” is enough to give one instant full access to everything that those born and raised (and oppressed as) women have struggled for centuries to make their own.
Name and address supplied

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit

• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Protecting the rights of women and trans people | Letters
Letters: Gillian Dalley and Dr Jane Hamlin respond to an article by Zoe Williams, and Jacqueline Darby reacts to a piece by Susanna Rustin. Plus Prof Martin Marshall on the ban on conversion therapy


12, Apr, 2022 @5:12 PM

Article image
Differing perspectives on transgender rights | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to an article by Suzanne Moore


04, Mar, 2020 @6:30 PM

Article image
Reframing the need for single-sex spaces under the Equality Act | Letter
Letter: Jacqui Lewis responds to a letter on the rights of trans people with regard to single-sex spaces

13, Apr, 2023 @5:08 PM

Article image
The polarised debate on transgender and women’s rights | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to an article by Susanna Rustin on balancing the views of trans activists and gender-critical feminists


14, Oct, 2021 @5:05 PM

Article image
Transgender rights are not a threat to feminism | Letters
Letters: Readers Readers respond to the Guardian’s editorial, a recent letter, and other media coverage of the debate surrounding the consultation on reform of the Gender Recognition Act


18, Oct, 2018 @5:39 PM

Article image
Trans or cis, women are stronger united | Letters
Letters: Laura Mauro writes in support of Zoe Williams’ piece calling for solidarity, and Angela Price agrees that feminism is an inclusive movement that should fight for the rights of all minorities


12, Mar, 2020 @5:58 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Gender Recognition Act: where rights collide | Editorial
Editorial: It should be possible to advance trans equality without harming the interests of women. But a toxic debate has made it harder


17, Oct, 2018 @5:14 PM

Article image
The Gender Recognition Act is controversial – can a path to common ground be found?
In early 2016, the government proposed changes to the law regarding self-identification – there has been furious debate ever since. But could a more nuanced conversation between gender-critical feminists and trans activists now be starting?

Gaby Hinsliff

10, May, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Time’s Up rally showed you can be both a trans ally and a feminist | Amelia Abraham
It is high time for trans women to be included in the fight for gender equality, says Amelia Abraham, a freelance journalist writing on music, film and identity politics

Amelia Abraham

23, Jan, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
Woman’s Place UK is not a ‘trans-exclusionist hate group’ | Letter
Letter: Senior Labour MPs’ support for calls to expel party members who support WPUK is condemned by several academics from University College London


20, Feb, 2020 @6:32 PM