Why we need to talk about prostate cancer | Letters

Readers respond to news of George Monbiot’s diagnosis with their own experiences and best wishes

Both George Monbiot (I have been diagnosed with prostate cancer, but I am happy, 14 March) and Bill Turnbull (Former BBC breakfast host Bill Turnbull has prostate cancer, 6 March) have performed a service to men by sharing their shock at discovering they have prostate cancer. Bill wishes he had had PSA testing more often than every five years; George says that this standard assessment is of limited use. I agree with Bill and take issue with George. My prostate cancer was discovered by two private PSA tests taken 11 months apart. My Gleason score was nine out of 10. I was finally clear of cancer last year after 14 years of treatment. I suggest things could have been a lot worse if I had not had these two tests within a year.

George should have mentioned the Prostate cancer risk management programme whose aim is: “… to ensure that men receive information about prostate cancer and the associated risks, and clear and balanced information about the advantages and disadvantages of the prostate specific antigen (PSA) test. This will help men to decide whether they want to have the test.”

It would appear that in both George’s and Bill’s cases, they did not receive clear and balanced information about the test. The implication is that surgeries need to have a notice on the wall that draws men’s attention to their rights under the risk management programme. And, if their GP does not inform them, they should make the first move.
Robert Redpath
Jordans, Buckinghamshire

• It is commendable that George Monbiot shares with us his experience of prostate cancer diagnosis. Also his happiness in where it puts him in his life. It is so important to inform and educate men about this disease, to broadcast the news far and wide. Anecdotally, following 15 years of PSA monitoring due to family history, then two biopsies that make your eyes water a bit, I too was diagnosed with this disease. Like George, I am overwhelmed by the love and support from friends, family and the teams of NHS radiologists who irradiate me daily with their linear accelerators. There is almost a social group in the waiting room, where we prepare for our treatment. A dry camaradie exists and humour too, as we fill our bladders to bursting point with water and insert our microenemas, so the radiologists can see what they’re aiming at. (Big shout out for the radiotherapy teams at the Churchill hospital, Oxford.)

Cancer is the great leveller. But there is room for happiness when you do realise, by comparison, how lucky you are. Good luck with your treatment, George.
Gordon Cooper
Flackwell Heath, Buckinghamshire

• I was diagnosed with prostate cancer, with a Gleason score slightly higher than George’s. I opted for radiotherapy rather than surgery, and the seven weeks I spent travelling five days a week to the Churchill hospital in Oxford were an eye-opener for me, since I have never had any contact with the NHS beyond my (very good) general practice and the odd minor operation. At every stage I was dealt with courteously, informatively and sympathetically, often by staff who were not English. There were six radiotherapy machines, each costing about £2m, to which I had free access, along with the ancillary hormone treatment. The true cost of my treatment came home to me when I read in the Guardian last week of the man who has lived in the UK for over 40 years who was asked to pay £54,000 for a course of radiotherapy for his prostate cancer.

Unless there is a change of government soon, this unique healthcare organisation will be irreparably damaged by politicians who despise anyone who is not rich, who use private medicine, and who advocate the discredited use of PFI companies that make profits from selling inferior and overpriced services to the NHS.
Karl Sabbagh
Bloxham, Oxfordshire

• George Monbiot’s response to his diagnosis and forthcoming radical surgery for prostate cancer is impressive and inspiring for others in similar position. But there is a third choice of treatment other than the rather dismal choice between surgery or radiation – namely high-frequency ultrasound, which has fewer side effects and – as with a friend of mine – can be very effective. For some reason it has a lower profile, but is available - and would appear a far less daunting prospect.
Andrew Broadbent

• Thank you, George, for that courageous and necessary writing. We admire your brave and clear-sighted approach to your private crisis. Thank you for sharing your thoughts, so that we can emulate your attitude. And we all wish you well in your surgery and aftercare. May the force be with you.
Frances Middleton

• George is fit and healthy and his prostatectomy should be very successful. I had the same operation nine years ago and I have no doubt that my life was saved by my excellent GP who insisted that I had regular annual PSA tests. Although my Gleason Score was only 4.5, my doctor was concerned by the sudden increase since my previous test and “for peace of mind” (his and mine), he suggested a biopsy. Like George, my cancer was aggressive and the operation was carried out in under a month. Fortunately, the lymph glands were unaffected and apart from the expected debilitation following major surgery, I was soon fitter than before the operation. Erectile dysfunction is an expected side-effect, but don’t worry, George, medication will help that.

All men should have regular PSA tests from age 50 and, if there is a family history of prostate cancer, tests should begin earlier. Delay does kill. I am looking forward to reading George’s next article following his discharge from hospital.
Joe Haynes
Reading, Berkshire

• Thank you, George. I have just been diagnosed too and, at 77, I like the idea of being part of this season’s smart young men. And I like the reasons you give for being happy. They make a lot of sense. My hormone treatment started yesterday and every member of staff was wonderful, kind, thoughtful, skilful and reassuring. Like you, I am happy, but I am also very angry. The idea that the government is determined to sell this national service off to US private business is unbearable.
John Airs

• George Monbiot has covered everything accurately. His urinary tract infection bad luck turned out to be life-saving good luck. For me a hip replacement pre-op test discovered a heart condition, treatment for which led to the diagnosis of prostate cancer, early developing, responding well to the simplest treatment. Definitely good luck. “All the smart young men have it this season” – no, but all the smart men of any age should be aware of it, speak of it and check for symptoms. I’m old enough to remember when tuberculosis was unmentionable. Let’s not fear to speak of prostate cancer. All the best with the surgery, George.
Denis Ahern
Stanford-le-Hope, Essex

• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
George Monbiot’s experience can help other men with prostate cancer | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to the Guardian columnist’s experience of surgery and recovery


10, May, 2018 @4:46 PM

Article image
We need learning disability doctors | Letters
Letters: Janet Chambers and Michael Baron on the need for GPs specialising in the health and welfare requirements of people with intellectual disabilities


05, Aug, 2019 @4:15 PM

Article image
Fostering must be a public service for the public good | Letters
Letters: Clive Sellick writes that by allowing the private sector to flourish in fostering, a two-tier service has been created; plus a letter from a reader who is on the verge of collapse for want of support for her son with Huntington’s disease


01, Feb, 2018 @6:32 PM

Article image
Joint role in sectioning decisions under Mental Health Act | Letters
Letters: Robert Wightmore and Wally Johns respond to Mariam Alexander’s article on sectioning patients under the Mental Health Act


14, Nov, 2018 @5:55 PM

Article image
Data on death rates in hospitals and general practice | Letters
Letters: Accessing and analysing the data on death rates under GPs is no simple matter, writes Meic Goodyear


24, Jun, 2018 @4:13 PM

Article image
GP-patient bond stretched to breaking point | Letters
Letters: Dr Carl Brandt GP says proper healthcare requires a strong and personal relationship based on trust, Richard Gilyead says that in Saffron Walden it is difficult to get any appointment with a GP at all, and Laura Marshall-Andrews GP describes a patient in tears


10, May, 2018 @4:45 PM

Article image
A flu jab may save your life – if you can get one | Letters
Letters: Readers on the benefits of the flu vaccine and the difficulties in tracking it down


04, Nov, 2018 @6:33 PM

Article image
Why haven't doctors been better protected against this virus? | Letters
Letters: Two readers on the shocking truth behind why NHS staff are being infected with coronavirus, putting their families and patients at risk


24, Mar, 2020 @7:38 PM

Article image
Antidepressants are better than placebos | Letters
Letters: A retired psychiatrist says the drugs helped her without any side effects, while Richard Bartley highlights a study that shows they are significantly better than placebos


08, Apr, 2019 @5:01 PM

Article image
Without action, general practice faces extinction | Letters
Letters: Doctors describe the perfect storm of austerity, staff shortages and increased demand that is hitting GPs, and call for a rethink to save primary healthcare


28, Sep, 2021 @4:00 PM