Autistic people listen to their hearts to test anti-anxiety therapy

Trial seeks further proof that tuning into our internal organs’ activity can reduce anxiety

A pioneering therapy aimed at lowering anxiety by tuning into your own heartbeat is being put to the test in the first clinical trial of its kind.

The treatment, known as interoception-directed therapy, is being tested on 120 autistic people, for whom anxiety is a common problem.

The trial follows a decade’s research by Prof Sarah Garfinkel, a psychologist at the University of Sussex, into the intriguing ways that interactions between the heart and the brain influence emotions and behaviour. The latest work, funded by the mental health charity MQ: Transforming Mental Health, aims to turn these insights into a therapy.

“Anxiety is really high in the autistic population,” said Garfinkel. “Fifty percent of people with autism also potentially have anxiety, which is so high and really not known.”

The ability to tune into the activity of our internal organs is called interoception and there is emerging evidence that this ability is linked to how well a person is able to identify their own emotional state and to empathise with others.

Garfinkel believes that altered interoception may be a factor in why autistic people experience the world differently. Her work has shown that autistic people tend to find it far harder to detect their own heartbeats – and the worse they are at this task, the greater their anxiety tends to be.

Prof Sarah Garfinkel, whose research has helped lead to the trial of interoception-directed therapy.
Prof Sarah Garfinkel, whose research has helped lead to the trial of interoception-directed therapy. Photograph: Martin Godwin/The Guardian

The 120 trial participants are being asked to complete eight training sessions over several weeks. During training, their heartbeat is tracked using a pulse oximeter and they are asked to “listen in” to their heart and count how many beats occur in a set time period. They are then given the correct answer and the exercise is repeated.

A pilot study involving participants without autism showed the training improved people’s interoceptive awareness and significantly reduced anxiety levels.

Becka, a 41-year-old from Brighton, who was diagnosed as autistic as an adult, is one of the trial participants. “I don’t really remember a time I wasn’t anxious,” she said. “It seems [to be] always there in the background … and at times I have felt taken over by my anxiety.”

Becka struggles to manage sensory overload, saying the world sometimes feels “intense, loud, fast, painful”, which she said contributes to feelings of stress and anxiety. Focusing on her heart and breathing is something she has learned to do naturally as a coping strategy and she enjoyed the training. “It was good to tune in and focus on my heartbeat,” she said. “No matter how busy outside or inside is, I can still focus on that.”

Garfinkel’s interest was sparked after reading a scientific paper on autism and empathy.

“I found within this paper an almost buried graph showing that if you measure the bodily response of someone with autism to seeing someone in pain, it’s actually greater,” said Garfinkel. “They have a heightened bodily response to the pain of others.”

This finding runs counter to the idea that autistic people “lack empathy”, she said. “Early accounts of autism sometimes said they didn’t have empathy and for me that’s really not true at all,” she said.

However, autistic people can feel disconnected from their own emotions and struggle to assess what people around them are feeling.

“It made me wonder, if they’re having this very heightened bodily response, is there something altered about their interoception, their capacity to sense and use these signals?”

One hypothesis is that, in autistic people, empathetic responses are occurring at the brain’s fast, instinctive level, reflected by changes in heartbeat. However, the brain may be less adept at interpreting these signals and so having these constant unexplained increases in heart rate could potentially leave people feeling under threat, causing anxiety.

Garfinkel hopes the latest trial could provide further insights into whether the hypothesis, which is under active debate in the field, is correct. The participants will also have brain scans before and after training to look for any potential changes in a brain area called the insula, which picks up signals from the heart and is also involved in emotion.

Sophie Dix, director of research at MQ: Transforming Mental Health, said: “This project has so much potential to inform treatments and further understanding of anxiety in autistic people. Research like this provides hope for better treatments for mental health kindled by our increased understanding of the link between the mind and the body.”

How to test your own interoceptive awareness

1) Find a quiet place.

2) Set a timer for one minute.

3) Close your eyes and try to detect your heartbeat. When you’re ready, start the timer and try to count your heartbeats for a minute.

4) Repeat the exercise, but this time feeling your pulse to take an accurate reading of your heart rate.

Tip: if you’re struggling to tune into your heartbeat, try running up and down some stairs or doing star jumps until your heart pounds and then try to stick with it as it returns to normal.


Hannah Devlin Science correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Fears Covid anxiety syndrome could stop people reintegrating
Exclusive: compulsive hygiene habits and fear of public places could remain for some after lockdown lifted, researchers say

Natalie Grover Science correspondent

24, Apr, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Scary monsters: how virtual reality could help people cope with anxiety
Guardian science correspondent is put to the test in the panic-inducing VR world of a game that teaches breathing technique

Linda Geddes Science correspondent

13, Jan, 2023 @12:00 PM

Article image
Very premature babies at risk of mental health problems – research
Studies reveal greater likelihood of attention disorders, shyness and anxiety in childhood and then adulthood for survivors with very low birth weight of 1kg

Ian Sample Science editor

13, Feb, 2017 @2:00 PM

Article image
Sexual assault victims more likely to have anxiety and depression – study
Poor sleep and high blood pressure are also more common in women with experience of assault or harassment, research shows

Nicola Davis

03, Oct, 2018 @1:09 PM

Article image
Electroconvulsive therapy mostly used on women and older people, says study
Findings are a cause for concern and symptom of the ‘over-medicalising of human distress’, says co-author of report using NHS data

Nicola Davis

20, Oct, 2017 @2:39 PM

Article image
Automated virtual reality therapy helps people overcome phobia of heights
Scientists hope computer programme which requires no human therapist could be used to treat other mental health problems

Nicola Davis

11, Jul, 2018 @10:30 PM

Article image
‘I had no confidence and suffered from anxiety. Exercise helped me tackle it’ | Louise Taylor
A scheme that helps young people achieve wellbeing through sport is filling a gap left by children’s services cuts, says Louise Taylor

Louise Taylor

24, Sep, 2019 @12:00 PM

Article image
Online CBT is not a therapy substitute, but a step to help manage anxiety
Emotional disorders in young people are prevalent while NHS services are in crisis. Apps are not the cure but a stopgap ‘Inadequate’ NHS services put under-18s with mental health issues at risk

Nihara Krause

30, Dec, 2018 @5:31 PM

Article image
Therapy v medication? How to choose the best treatment for anxiety
Medication is often prescribed as a quick-fix but therapy can be more helpful in the long-run, if accessible. Here’s how to work out what is best for you

Emine Saner

25, May, 2022 @9:00 AM

Article image
Reasons to be cheerful: optimists live longer, says study
Those with a positive attitude to life may lower their anxiety levels by avoiding arguments or not perceiving traffic jams as stressful

Ian Sample Science editor

07, Mar, 2022 @5:00 AM