Sainsbury’s faces anger over London plot with just 4% affordable homes

Campaigners say number of homes offered in supermarket’s Ilford high-rise development is ‘insulting’

Sainsbury’s is facing housing campaigners’ anger over a proposed high-rise development surrounding an east London superstore that includes just 4% affordable homes.

Local opponents have described the supermarket’s proposal that just 27 of the 683 homes in the Ilford project will be available for affordable rent as “insulting”.

Planning experts for the mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, have said the offer “falls substantially short” of City Hall’s plan to deliver 17,000 affordable homes per year – equivalent to 40% of the strategic housebuilding target.

It also falls well short of the London Borough of Redbridge’s target of 50% affordable housing across all new developments. There are currently over 8,000 households on the waiting list for affordable housing in the area, and more than 2,400 living in temporary accommodation.

The borough estimates it needs an extra 15,000 affordable homes by 2033. The case is set to go before a public inquiry starting on Tuesday, but the project appears likely to go ahead after the council withdrew its opposition on Saturday.

Sainsbury’s says the “maximum reasonable” amount of affordable housing it can include is 14 one- and two-bedroom flats, a dozen three-bedroom units and a single four-bedroom property. It estimates making a 20% profit selling off the private flats, according to planning documents. At current local prices that could exceed £40m.

It has described it as “a financially challenging project”, partly because of lost revenues to its retail operation when it closes its existing store for construction. It has also agreed to pay Redbridge £11.4m in community infrastructure levy, although this cannot be used to fund affordable housing.

But Meenakshi Sharma, co-founder of Ilford NOISE, a local residents group, said the amount of affordable housing being offered was “ridiculous and insulting”.

“People can’t believe it is 4% especially with all the publicity about the need for affordable housing,” she said. “And yet this still carries on. They don’t take any notice whatsoever. There’s a big housing need in the area. There are lots of people in temporary accommodation and lots of overcrowding.”

It is the latest in a series of high-profile battles over the financial viability of private housing schemes in the capital with councils seeking to maximise the number of cheaper homes in developments and developers seeking to minimise them. Previous disputes have centred on central London sites where developers have argued that the high cost of land limits their ability to subsidise affordable housing, but the row over the Ilford site suggests the issue is spreading to the outer London suburbs.

Affordable in this case means rents capped at 60% of market rates. Sainsbury’s is increasingly moving into housebuilding, using the space above its stores for housing. The Ilford project is its largest yet, but it has also built 650 homes around a store in Nine Elms and 500 homes above a store in Fulham, both in London.

Redbridge had originally rejected the application because of the lack of affordable housing and was planning to oppose it at the public inquiry, but it has now reversed its position and accepted the 4% offer.

On Friday, a spokeswoman for Redbridge told the Guardian: “We declined the application because of the huge gap between the borough’s expectations on affordable housing in new developments, and the proposals we were given. The capital is critically short of housing, especially affordable housing and we need to increase the stock in the borough.”

But on Saturday it told the planning inspector it was withdrawing its opposition and would not resist Sainsbury’s appeal against its original refusal.

In a letter to the planning inspectorate, the head of planning, Joanne Woodward, said it had agreed common ground on the financial viability of the project and a planning deal, although without any increase in the affordable housing included in the development.

“The council will attend on the first day of the inquiry to explain how the position it has now adopted has been reached,” she said.

Sainsbury’s said: “Our plans will help kick-start Ilford’s future regeneration by driving growth and job creation, as well as provide a broad mix of housing for local people. We look forward to the outcome of the appeal. We have agreed with the council to review the provision at certain points throughout the development, and if we can increase the number of affordable homes we will.”

Contributor

Robert Booth

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Supermarket and care staff in London could get key worker access to housing
Sadiq Khan will consult on move to ‘recognise sacrifice’ of workers in pandemic, if re-elected

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

18, Apr, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
London mayor sets 35% affordable homes target in deal with developers
Sadiq Khan’s decision appears to cast doubt on election vow that 50% of new housing in capital would be ‘genuinely affordable’

Robert Booth

29, Nov, 2016 @12:01 AM

Article image
Sadiq Khan: London needs to build 66,000 new homes a year, up from 29,000
Exclusive: Mayor says developers must stop focusing on luxury penthouses and that 65% of new homes in the capital should be affordable

Robert Booth

27, Oct, 2017 @5:00 AM

Article image
Luxury Kensington complex will have just five affordable homes
Borough where 14 Grenfell families remain in hotels backs plan for retirement complex including £12m houses

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

12, Dec, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Sajid Javid faces battle over 4% affordable homes in Sainsbury's scheme
Housing secretary approved 700-home development in Ilford which has 50% affordable housing policy

Robert Booth

23, Mar, 2018 @5:54 PM

Article image
London faces surge in rough sleepers as coronavirus funding runs out in June
Sadiq Khan says without extra cash homeless people staying in hotels during pandemic could return to streets

Amelia Gentleman

26, May, 2020 @12:26 PM

Article image
Sadiq Khan condemns foreign investors' use of London homes as 'gold bricks'
Mayor condemns capital’s housing policy for being ‘obsessed by numbers rather than building the right sorts of homes’

Robert Booth

25, May, 2016 @4:10 PM

Article image
Mayor to subsidise 'naked' homes solution to London housing crisis
Sadiq Khan adds weight to scheme to construct spartan apartments that will sell for up to 40% less than usual new-builds

Robert Booth

24, Apr, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Sadiq Khan promises 40,000 new London council homes if he wins third term
Mayor says May election will be ‘closest ever’ and says the contest is ‘once in a generation’ chance to tackle city’s housing crisis

Daniel Boffey Chief reporter

18, Mar, 2024 @6:00 AM

Article image
Holloway prison to be turned into affordable housing
Former women’s prison in north London was sold to Peabody housing association

Clea Skopeliti

08, Mar, 2019 @5:39 PM