GPs working longer hours won’t ease the pressure on the NHS | Letters

Letters: Appointments at 7.45pm on Saturday or 8am on Sunday may suit those in work but they are not the people arriving at A&E departments

Re your readers’ stories of the NHS (‘He stayed on that trolley in A&E for the next 12 hours’, 14 January), the government is putting out a spew of misinformation to cover the 2% reduction, as a percentage of GDP, it has imposed on funding of the NHS since 2010. The people on trolleys waiting for a bed are not the worried well who are accused of blocking up A&E departments. They are people who have already been assessed as needing beds. These beds are full not just because people cannot be moved out of hospital but because the number of hospital beds has been steadily reduced over the last 20 or more years, so that the UK now has 2.8 beds per 1,000 of population, compared with 8.6 in Germany and 6.2 in France. The forthcoming sustainability and transformation plans propose further cuts.

The government prefers to blame “bed blocking” because people are remaining in hospital “unnecessarily”. But people who are fit for medical discharge are waiting for social care packages and there has been a £4.6bn cut in social care funding since 2010. What is happening is an inevitable result of the deliberate and cavalier reductions in local government funding since 2010. The motion in parliament last Thursday, calling for extra funding for social care now and a new funding settlement for health and social care in the March budget, was rejected. Conservative MPs who have deplored the situation in their local press voted with the government. How do these MPs justify their refusal to vote to fund social care properly?

Care costs money. Whenever we in Save Our Hospital Services ask if people will pay more income tax to ensure the NHS is properly funded, there is an overwhelming “yes” in response. There is also huge anger among the public at what is being done to health and social care. The government will reap what it sows.
Ruth Funnell
Save Our Hospital Services

• The illogicality of the prime minister’s response is breathtaking (Stay open seven days a week, May tells GPs, 14 January). Anyone who has been responsible for helping someone in their 80s or 90s get to the doctor will know that what is needed is a decent choice of appointments between about 10am and 5pm. Spreading appointments over extended hours will make these much harder to get, so leading to increasing numbers presenting at A&E.

It is blindingly obvious that taking the same number of doctors’ appointments and spreading them more thinly is no solution. Appointments at 7.45pm on Saturday or 8am on Sunday may suit those in work but they are not, by and large, the people arriving at A&E departments.
Jenny Boehm

• The GPs have quite rightly pointed out that seven-day appointments will not work. However, it may be time for some patients to make more of an effort. To avoid an appointment interfering with my working day I can join the queue for our practice’s open access 8am surgery Monday to Friday. If I get there for 7.40am, I can be back on the street by 8.15am and get on with the rest of the day. If patients reckon that GP appointments clash with going to work, then going sick or booking half a day’s holiday may be appropriate options. If your healthcare matters to you, you have no need to slide into consumer mode.
Geoff Reid

• Is the Jeremy Hunt who stated that “We need to have an honest discussion about the purpose of A&E departments” (Hunt ditches target as A&E crisis deepens, 10 January) the same Jeremy Hunt who took his own child to A&E with a minor illness because he didn’t want to wait for a GP appointment?
Dr Clive Richards

• I am pleased that Theresa May and Jeremy Hunt are challenging the entitled approach of the medical profession. Our GPs earn double what their French counterparts do. If the BMA had not ruthlessly exploited the public esteem for doctors to access salaries and pensions beyond the dreams of other citizens, there could be many more GPs with the same personnel budget. The NHS cannot just consume our entire public expenditure – we do need to do other things with these resources.

Medical professionals need to understand that in the 21st century they are not the only people with education and skills, and that they must adjust their expectations to allow the NHS to live within its means. The public need to take the stars from their eyes and look hard at value for money in NHS spending. Aneurin Bevan said he had to stuff the mouths of doctors with gold to form the NHS – this is still true today. At last we have a government prepared to argue for realism and fairness, to allow our national spending priorities to come more into balance.
Name and address supplied

• Amid all the debate about the current crises in NHS A&E departments, the role of employer policies has attracted little attention. The growth of zero-hours contracts and the so-called gig economy means many workers have uncertain working hours. In such circumstances, committing to GP appointments is potentially problematic. Walk-in A&E departments offer an obvious way of avoiding this difficulty.

Meanwhile, a significant proportion of the workforce faces the prospect of losing pay when absent for medical reasons as a consequence of the poor nature and coverage of occupational sick pay schemes. Once again, the 24-hour nature of A&E offers a means of avoiding this problem.
Professor Phil James
Middlesex University

• Tucked away in the bottom right-hand corner of page 4 (Rates pain for hospitals, 12 January) is news that astonishes me. I had no idea that the NHS has to pay business rates. The estimated annual sum is £377m. More disturbing, however, is the news that private providers such as Nuffield Health enjoy an 80% rebate because they are registered as charities. Private providers enjoy a rebate as charities, while the NHS is classed as a business. Verily, “For he that hath, to him shall be given: and he that hath not, from him shall be taken even that which he hath” (Mark 4:25).
Joseph Cocker
Leominster, Herefordshire

• I volunteer at a nursery school. This term the theme is “people who help us”, and in a corner a hospital has been created, complete with pictures of bones, a reception desk, waiting area and bed. The children have tiny uniforms and medical equipment. The staff and I decided that for complete authenticity we need a “waiting time approximately 5 hours” sign, and make all the children wait outside in the corridor.
Jean Austin
Crawley, West Sussex

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Why longer GP surgery hours aren't the answer to the burden on A&E | Simon Atkins
Simon Atkins: We've tried extended surgery hours before. It's not GPs but government cuts that are to blame for ballooning emergency admissions

Simon Atkins

01, Oct, 2013 @4:05 PM

Article image
GPs should do more to take pressure off A&E departments, says May
Prime minister wants surgeries to offer a seven-day service, but is accused of trying to scapegoat family doctors for chaos in NHS hospitals

Heather Stewart and Denis Campbell

13, Jan, 2017 @11:56 PM

Letters: GPs and out-of-hours care procurement
Letters: We are concerned that a system where some patients are treated and others are not – as proposed by the chair of the Royal College of GPs – will not work, and will also be unfair and potentially discriminatory

05, Jun, 2013 @8:00 PM

Article image
Jeremy Hunt orders same-day GP appointments to ease A&E burden

Health secretary outlines long- and short-term measures to address growing strain on accident and emergency wards

Randeep Ramesh, social affairs editor

10, Sep, 2013 @3:50 PM

Article image
GPs sceptical about new contract designed to reduce A&E pressure
GPs get fewer targets and more responsibility for over-75s but question practical effect as spend on general practice declines

Randeep Ramesh and Haroon Siddique

15, Nov, 2013 @3:16 PM

Article image
Cut red tape for returning GPs to help ease A&E burden, says doctors' chief
New Royal College of GPs chair is lobbying ministers to make it easier for female doctors to re-enter NHS after having children

Denis Campbell, health correspondent

12, Nov, 2013 @7:02 PM

Article image
An NHS under unsustainable pressure deserves a serious debate | Letters
Letters: Doctors want to do more, but they can only do that if they are given the resources, facilities and the staff to do so

15, Jan, 2015 @7:30 PM

Article image
George Osborne’s cuts could create an unsafe NHS | Letters
Letters: As it is near-impossible to find such year-on-year efficiency savings, NHS trusts will be pushed to a deficit of £2.2bn this year to avoid compromising patient care through cuts


27, Nov, 2015 @6:58 PM

Article image
The future of the NHS and social care – for better or worse | Letters
Letters: Although people are allowed to respond to glossy consultation documents, they wonder whether anyone is really listening


25, Nov, 2016 @6:08 PM

Article image
Letters: GPs and the out-of-hours care crisis
Letters: Isn't it time GPs recognised that they are providing an essential service, not doing us a favour?

26, May, 2013 @8:00 PM