Early intervention can curb youth violence – locking young people up won’t | Letters

Letter: My hope is that politicians can get away from the retributive justice that has defined Britain’s response to youth crime since the murder of my son, Jimmy, in 2008

There is a belief that locking young people up will solve the problem of violence on our streets (Young people with knives who film victims for social media face harsher punishments, 6 October, theguardian.com), but that hasn’t worked and it’s not a deterrent.

We understand consequences when we have time to think rationally and logically. However, when you’re young, hot-headed, and lashing out, you’re not thinking rationally and logically.

My hope is that politicians and the public can get away from the kneejerk reaction of mandatory minimum sentences and retributive justice that has defined Britain’s response to youth crime since the murder of my son, Jimmy, in 2008. I’m not against prison. Actions have consequences and there’s no denying that; however, it’s clear that the current system is not working. Young people are killing each other at an increasing rate in London, and we owe it to them to stop this.

Through the work of our charity, For Jimmy (forjimmy.org), we take the time to look at the deeper issues that are rooted in early childhood. We will only achieve safer and more cohesive communities by working together and understanding the root causes of the issues we are seeking to rectify. This involves early intervention, education and engagement with young people and their communities. If we want to stop young people from killing each other on our streets, then we need to understand why they are so readily resorting to violence; not simply locking them up and throwing away the key.
Barry Mizen

I read with horror of the plan to increase the numbers of military cadet units in schools (Report, 8 October). In a country where incidents of violence are increasing, is teaching children to use lethal weapons and imagine scenarios where they are attacking and killing other human beings likely to reduce them?

The defence secretary Michael Fallon, centre, is shown the parts of a gun as a young cadet looks on.
The defence secretary Michael Fallon, centre, is shown the parts of a gun as a young cadet looks on. Photograph: Corporal Paul Shaw ABIPP/MoD Cro/PA

If the aim is to instil discipline and teamwork, why not introduce civilian rescue cadet training, where young people can learn to save lives through firefighting, earthquake rescue, lifeguarding, flood rescue, mountain rescue and first aid, and become capable of helping in natural and manmade disasters not only here but in other parts of the world too?

These skills are equally exciting to learn. If it is thought important to have uniform, drill and inspections, these could be easily incorporated. Let us teach the next generation to respect life and that taking it is not a game.
Patricia Pulham
Waldron, East Sussex

• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Rising youth crime reflects wider societal problems | Letters
Letters: Catherine West MP calls on a special fund for children at risk of school exclusion, while Steve Phaure says community responses are the best way to protect young people at risk. Plus letters from Don Macdonald and Norma Hornby


03, Apr, 2019 @5:40 PM

Article image
Our shameful policy of locking up young people | Letters
Letters: Frances Crook of the Howard League for Penal Reform says we should be closing down our youth prison system, not expanding it; David Scott says England and Wales stand virtually alone in the EU in the use of child life sentences


22, Nov, 2017 @6:44 PM

Article image
Joining the rich and powerful scrum at Rugby won’t help young offenders | Letters
Letters: Pouring resources into one area of inequality will not tackle underlying issues


19, Sep, 2017 @5:45 PM

Youth crime: Greedy, rude adults 'fuelling teen violence'

Parents must help tackle the behaviour of their teenagers, government expert says

Polly Curtis, education editor

11, Jul, 2008 @7:58 AM

Home Office launches advice booklet telling parents how to spot signs of gang involvement

Home Office launches booklet telling parents how to spot signs of gang involvement

Alan Travis and Helen Carter

01, Sep, 2008 @11:01 PM

Birmingham police explore gang motivation in latest spree of violence

Gang retaliation may be at heart of latest spate of shootings and stabbings in Birmingham

Audrey Gillan

01, Sep, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Temi Mwale: ‘The murder of my childhood friend changed everything’
The award-winning social entrepreneur on how the fatal shooting in 2012 spurred her to set up a project to reduce youth violence

Mattha Busby

27, Nov, 2018 @1:00 PM

Article image
As gang violence rises again, drug legislation is screaming out for reform | Deborah Orr
Murder rates among UK teenagers dropped sharply a few years ago, but lately have started to spike again. There can be no doubt that the illegal drugs trade fuels gang violence – and that sensible reform could save lives. Now is the time

Deborah Orr

15, Jan, 2016 @5:11 PM

Letters: Youth justice policy
Letters: The plans to abolish the Youth Justice Board were right in principle, but flawed in practice. Now the decision to retain it risks a return to the status quo ante that did not work

27, Nov, 2011 @9:00 PM

Article image
Youth Justice Board’s record under scrutiny | Letters
Letters: A body truly championing children would not watch in silence – it would speak up, and loudly


22, May, 2016 @6:49 PM