Minister apologises after woman in coma was told to find work

Sheila Holt was contacted by the Department for Work and Pensions who invited her to attend 'intensive job-focused activity'

A government minister has apologised after it emerged that a Whitehall department sent letters to a woman demanding she make an effort to find work even though she was in a coma.

The minister for disabled people, Mike Penning, said he apologised "unreservedly" to the family of Sheila Holt after he was challenged in the Commons.

"It's about time politicians did stand up and apologise when things went wrong. It clearly has gone wrong and the family have every right to be aggrieved and I hope she makes a full recovery, as much as she can," said Penning.

Holt, who has suffered from physical and mental health problems, was contacted by the Department for Work and Pensions, which invited her to attend "intensive job-focused activity", according to her MP Simon Danczuk. She fell into a coma in December last year and the government and its contractor were informed, the Labour MP told the Commons.

During his speech, Danczuk read from a letter sent to the Holt family, who live in Rochdale in Greater Manchester. "It said, 'Dear Ms Holt, you are now approaching the end of the first stage of your intensive job focused activity. We hope that all the activity or training intervention completed so far has not only supported you to achieve your aspirations but has moved you closer to the job market.

"'You will shortly enter the second stage of your intensive job-focused activity. Sessions and workshops may vary depending on the centre you attend'."

He said the letter was dated 30 January. Danczuk added: "I should inform the House that members of Sheila's family repeatedly informed the DWP and Seetec (a contractor carrying out work capability assessments) about this fact that she wasn't well but they continued to get harassed by those organisations."

He added that Holt has suffered from severe bipolar disorder since childhood. "She has not been in employment since she was 16 years old. However she was pushed into the Work Programme before Christmas and she was finding it extremely difficult.

"She was also concerned about the fact around the increases in the council tax benefit that she had to pay. On 17 December she was sectioned under the Mental Health Act because she was struggling to cope.

"Whilst in hospital she had a heart attack and that's caused her to be in a coma since then. We are now at the end of February. I can report to the House that Sheila is stable, she is still in the coma."

He added: "Let's make this important point – before the election when the prime minister toured the TV studios he often talked about 'Broken Britain'. Well I have to say that if this is the prime minister's idea of fixing broken Britain, hounding disabled people who suffer from mental breakdowns, harassing their distressed relatives, then I prefer the broken Britain that existed before."

Speaking after the exchange, Holt's father Ken, 74, said the government's welfare to work scheme was to blame for the severity of his daughter's condition.

The retired labourer said the stress of the threat of having her benefits stopped left Sheila clinging to life after she was hospitalised. He said her last job was 27 years ago but that Seetec wrote to her and she was forced to go on a job-seeking course for eight days.

After each day she became more and more agitated until she "cracked" her father said, and was hospitalised following a "manic episode".

"If they had left her alone she would not be in this condition. They were threatening her with cuts and she needs the benefits."

"I just believe it's all wrong, you should be chasing the people who are fit, get them to work, not them that are not fit. It's outrageous," he said.

Ken said he visited his daughter in hospital daily and that she has suffered "very, very serious brain damage" following a heart attack.

"It's a matter of life and death," he said. "She may not survive, that's how bad it is. All she can do is open her eyes and she shows she's in a lot of pain," he said.


Kevin Rawlinson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Halt universal credit or rough sleepers will double, says Burnham
Greater Manchester mayor says officials from across public sector including NHS believe rollout should be stopped

Josh Halliday North of England correspondent

06, Oct, 2017 @2:14 PM

Article image
Young mothers evicted from London hostel may be rehoused 200 miles away

Newham council says cuts and welfare reform mean it might have to look outside borough to rehouse 29 single mothers

Patrick Butler, social policy editor

14, Oct, 2013 @2:29 PM

Article image
The everyday struggle to find work | Michael White
Michael White: Never mind Mr Fred Goodwin, millions are struggling to even make a living

Michael White

01, Feb, 2012 @12:33 PM

Article image
UK housing crisis deepens as benefit claimants priced out by high rents
Benefit freeze is making London and Manchester increasingly unaffordable

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

07, Jul, 2019 @12:53 PM

Only 3.5% of people referred to Work Programme find long-term jobs
None of welfare-to-work scheme's 18 contractors reached target of getting 5.5% of clients a job for at least six months

Randeep Ramesh, social affairs editor

27, Nov, 2012 @11:58 AM

Article image
Welfare to work project in crisis, Lib Dem minister warns Chris Grayling
Nick Harvey's leaked letter highlights concerns over funding and fears that private sector will 'cherry pick' charities

Patrick Wintour and Nicholas Watt

26, Feb, 2012 @9:53 PM

Article image
DWP told woman she was not ill enough for benefit on day she died
Dawn Amos was sent letter about attendance allowance on day her husband agreed to switch off her life support machine

Aisha Gani

07, Jan, 2016 @8:42 PM

Get ready for work: what woman who needs constant care was told

Ruth Anim has learning difficulties, a heart problem and epilepsy. A work capability test by Atos said she should prepare for a job

Amelia Gentleman

03, Oct, 2012 @5:38 PM

Article image
More jobseekers told to do unpaid work or face possible loss of benefits
Mandatory work activity requires jobseekers to work unpaid for up to 30 hours a week or risk losing their benefits

Shiv Malik and James Ball

12, Jun, 2012 @6:14 PM

Article image
Labour attacks work programme 'chaos' after forecasts revised

Government almost halves number of people expected to use scheme, raising fears of job losses among welfare-to-work staff

Nicholas Watt, chief political correspondent

15, Jul, 2012 @2:00 PM