Hunt should have gone further in NHS reforms, says Mid Staffs victim's father

Health secretary shied away from legal duty of candour, says Frank Robinson, whose son was misdiagnosed: 'I feel let down'

Jeremy Hunt's announcement did not go far enough, said Frank Robinson, whose 20-year-old son died after being misdiagnosed by A&E staff at Stafford hospital in 2006.

"I feel it could have gone further, particularly with the legal duty of candour, which he shied away from [Francis recommended that the duty of candour should apply to all NHS staff individually but this was rejected Hunt] … we were kept in the dark as to what had happened. Had there been that legal duty, that would not have happened."

John Moore-Robinson was discharged after a cycling accident, but died of a ruptured spleen the following day. The hospital did not disclose documents to an inquest the following year and it was only in 2008 that the family found out there were other documents relating to the hospital's own inquiry into the incident that had not been revealed.

As to the proposed charge of "wilful neglect" for organisations and individuals, Robinson said: "I think that it is going to be very hard to implement and police. The duty of candour could have included that, but this is just going to water down the duty of candour. I feel a little let down by it all. It has been a very expensive exercise." Robinson said a second inquest into his son's death is to take place in Leicestershire next year.

A couple who were misled by another NHS hospital over the care of their stillborn baby also thought Hunt should have gone further though he had taken "a step in the right direction".

The health ombudsman, Dame Julie Mellor, was scathing last year about the way that the trust running Leighton hospital, Crewe, had behaved over the death of their son in 2009, accusing the management of making "highly misleading" statements and finding it guilty of maladministration.

The father, known as Mr D, told the Guardian on Tuesday: "We would have liked to have seen a duty of candour on all individuals within the NHS. I would have liked to have seen that backed up by the law as well – a criminal offence to collude, to cover up." However, the actions taken by Hunt were "a recognition this corrosive culture exists out there".


James Meikle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Shut understaffed NHS wards, says lawyer who exposed Mid Staffs scandal
Robert Francis QC calls for minimum safe staffing levels at hospitals and a duty for all NHS workers to report mistakes

Denis Campbell, health correspondent

08, Oct, 2013 @6:01 PM

Article image
Hospitals could have to pay for errors that kill or cause injury, says Hunt

Moves proposed to make NHS a 'beacon of care' following Mid Staffs hospital scandal include giving patients named consultant

Denis Campbell

19, Nov, 2013 @8:52 PM

Article image
Jeremy Hunt: NHS 'coasting' culture kills patients

Health secretary launches attack on hospitals that endanger patients' lives by meeting targets but not striving hard enough

Denis Campbell and Alexandra Topping

08, Mar, 2013 @11:31 AM

Article image
Jeremy Hunt plans disclosure drive to reduce medical errors

A fifth of NHS trusts in England have been rated as having poor disclosure performance in a new assessment

Denis Campbell and Patrick Wintour

23, Jun, 2014 @11:01 PM

Article image
Jeremy Hunt: NHS 'mediocrity' could create another Mid Staffs scandal
Health secretary's renewed attack on NHS warns that the 'weeds of failure grow more quickly in a garden of mediocrity'

Denis Campbell

08, Mar, 2013 @5:30 PM

Article image
Mid Staffs report: Jeremy Hunt must put patient safety before politics | Peter Walsh
Peter Walsh: If the government ignores the recommendations of the Francis report it will be a betrayal of patients and the NHS

Peter Walsh

31, Jan, 2013 @6:15 PM

Article image
CQC report says hospital care has not improved since Mid Staffs scandal

Regulator's review says patients more likely to suffer poor care as avoidable emergency admissions of older people increase

Haroon Siddique

21, Nov, 2013 @6:05 PM

Article image
Jeremy Hunt's response to Mid Staffs report is just beginning
Pretending to have finalised a view on so much in so short a time would not have yielded practical and beneficial reform

Denis Campbell, health correspondent

26, Mar, 2013 @8:20 PM

Article image
Mid-Staffs A&E closure: Sir Brian Jarman career profile
Background of the man who calculated the Mid-Staffs figures and created the hospital standardised mortality ratio

Randeep Ramesh

28, Jul, 2013 @7:31 PM

Article image
Final report into Mid Staffs scandal likely to prove devastating for NHS
Leading figures in the health service, regulators and government will face severe criticism over deaths at Stafford hospital

Denis Campbell, health correspondent

30, Jan, 2013 @9:00 PM