We need to build houses on a third more land, says planning minister

A house with a garden is a moral right, argues Nick Boles, though modern homes are 'pig ugly'

A third more of the country needs to be developed and a halt has to be made to the construction of "pig ugly" modern housing, the planning minister, Nick Boles, has warned. The remarks will alarm defenders of the British countryside, but Boles insists this expansion is quite possible without building on protected greenbelt land.

Housing has now been identified across the government as possibly the single quickest route to boosting growth, as well as one of the greatest failures in policy for the past 20 years.

The government has announced successive ideas to boost housebuilding, but many of them are long term, or are being held back by complex financing rules. Some cabinet ministers are fighting for an increase in capital investment dedicated to housebuilding in the autumn statement next week.

Boles, seen as a social moderniser in the Tory party, has recently admitted that the government needs to focus rigidly on hard-edged economic issues.

On BBC2's Newsnight, he says the "right to a home with a little bit of ground around it to bring your family up in" is a basic moral right on a par with a right to education. "We're going to protect the greenbelt but if people want to have housing for their kids they have got to accept we need to build more on some open land. In the UK and England at the moment we've got about 9% of land developed. All we need to do is build on another 2-3% of land and we'll have solved a housing problem."

Boles goes on: "The built environment can be more beautiful than nature and we shouldn't obsess about the fact that the only landscapes that are beautiful are open – sometimes buildings are better.

He says: "I think everyone has the right to live somewhere that is not just affordable but that is beautiful and has some green space nearby." He calls this "a basic moral right, like healthcare and education. There's a right to a home with a little bit of ground around it to bring your family up in."

The problem has been modern housing, which he says is pig ugly. "Land is expensive but to some extent [developers] are just lazy. They didn't talk to local people or get involved enough. But also it's just bloody expensive to build because land is expensive."

Addressing so-called nimbys, Boles says: "It's my job to make the arguments to these people [people who oppose development] that if they carry on writing letters their kids are never going to get a place with a garden to bring up their grandkids. I accept we haven't been able to persuade them. I think it would be easier if we could persuade them that the new development would be beautiful."

Successive planning and housing ministers have called on developers to build more imaginatively, but with little success.

Boles, once a passionate advocate of localism as head of the Policy Exchange thinktank, is now presiding over a shift to a more centralised scheme by allowing developers to appeal to an unelected planning inspectorate if they believe local authorities are requiring them to insert too many affordable homes in their development plans. Legislation will be passed in 2013. In addition, the government is taking powers to fast-track thousands of big residential applications. Developers will be able to opt for their schemes to be put to the planning inspectorate instead of the local authority.

The inspectorate is also being given powers to awards costs against local authorities which wrongly turn down a development, even if the developer has made no appeal for costs.

Local authority planning departments will also be put in special measures if they are seen to be taking too long to make decisions or are subject to too many appeals.

Once the power has been passed to the planning inspectorate, and away from a local authority probably for as long as a year, there will be no appeal against a decision of the inspectorate.


Patrick Wintour, political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A wholesale power grab: how the UK government is handing housing over to private developers
The new housing and planning bill is a raft of dangerous measures that will increase inequality and solely benefit the private sector

Oliver Wainwright

05, Jan, 2016 @1:12 PM

Article image
Anger at Cannes property fair where councils rub shoulders with oligarchs

Protesters accuse local authorities at week-long MIPIM of being 'in pockets of investors' and 'selling off' Britain's cities

Oliver Wainwright in Cannes

14, Mar, 2014 @2:00 PM

Article image
Flat block owners to get right to add floors with no permission needed
Ministry’s move to allow two storeys to be added to blocks aims to boost homeownership

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

12, Mar, 2020 @7:40 PM

Article image
Mayor to subsidise 'naked' homes solution to London housing crisis
Sadiq Khan adds weight to scheme to construct spartan apartments that will sell for up to 40% less than usual new-builds

Robert Booth

24, Apr, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Planning applications in England fall to record low in housing blow
Experts say developers deterred by changes to planning system brought in by successive Tory governments

Kiran Stacey Political correspondent

01, Apr, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Homes sweet homes: a brick by brick breakdown of housing manifestos
Labour wants to end homelessness. The Tories promise cheap land for councils to build on. And the Lib Dems would give planning power to the people. So which party should you bet your house on?

Oliver Wainwright

31, May, 2017 @2:06 PM

Article image
Build your own Adjaye: starchitects design catalogue homes
Want a home designed by a top architect on an affordable budget? Entrepreneurs Cube Haus may be moving in on your neighbourhood, with the help of David Adjaye and more

Oliver Wainwright

05, May, 2018 @9:37 AM

Article image
Coalition minister wants to give land to young to build own homes
Planning minister Nick Boles puts case for self-build scheme to help meet needs of 'Generation Rent'

Patrick Wintour, political editor

22, Nov, 2013 @10:00 PM

Article image
The Tories' new design guide backs tiny, unliveable, backward-looking homes
The new advisory panel on contemporary housing favours quaint buildings with a cottagey feel – and their guide makes no mention of space standards that could make the homes of the future generous or liveable

Oliver Wainwright

02, Apr, 2015 @10:03 AM

Article image
Out of the box: councils try innovative projects to provide social housing
Constrained by government and with a lack of funding, local authorities are becoming developers to tackle the homes crisis

Oliver Wainwright

10, Feb, 2017 @3:55 PM