Winterbourne View scandal prompts new care guidelines

Report warns that care sector risks slipping back into institutional culture typified by Victorian asylum system

Ministers will on Monday order a programme of action intended to remove up to 1,500 people with learning disabilities and autism from private hospitals such as the Winterbourne View unit where a regime of abuse and humiliation was exposed.

Health chiefs will be told to review urgently the cases of all people placed in so-called "assessment and treatment" units and to deliver a "rapid reduction" in their numbers by planning more appropriate care and support.

The move comes as a report warns that the care sector risks slipping back into an institutional culture typified by the Victorian asylum system. It says strict, custodial practices are making a return in some modern care homes that are struggling with the effects of spending cuts.

Lord Best, a leading housing and care expert and president of the Local Government Association, said: "Unless organisations are vigilant, the older institutional culture can re-emerge anywhere."

The crackdown on use of assessment and treatment units will come in the government's final report on the scandal at Winterbourne View, near Bristol, where secret filming revealed routine physical abuse of patients by staff. Six former care workers at the unit have been jailed and five others given suspended sentences.

Although Winterbourne View has been closed by its operator, Castlebeck, and checks on similar units have raised no comparable concerns, ministers have agreed that the model of care is probably unsuitable for most of the people placed in them.

Assessment and treatment units are supposed to offer short-term care for people whose behaviour is seen as "challenging" and difficult to manage in the community. But evidence suggests patients are being left in the units for years on end – in one case, 17 years – at costs revealed in the Winterbourne View affair to be £3,500 a week.

The action plan will give local care commissioners two years to move people out of the units, ideally to other forms of accommodation in their home areas, unless there is a demonstrable clinical and time-limited case for them to remain.

To keep faith with the government's commitment to localism, the plan will fall short of instructing commissioners to stop using the units, as demanded by pressure groups, but most such groups have signed up to a concordat of support for the programme.

Other measures will include new guidance on use of physical restraint strictly as a last resort in care homes and hospitals; provision for planning from childhood of the care and support needs of people with challenging behaviour; and enhanced powers for regulators to intervene in cases like Winterbourne View and, potentially, to hold directors of private care companies personally to account.

The warning on a drift back to institutionalism in the care sector comes in a report commissioned by Family Mosaic, a leading London housing association and provider of care and support, after it found abuse and poor practice in what it says was a small minority of its own services.

In two shared housing schemes, there were strict times set for getting up, eating and going to bed. In one scheme, access to the toilets was controlled by staff. In another, a woman who kept taking off her clothes had been dressed back-to-front to stop her doing so.

The report warns that, elsewhere, staffing cuts caused by reduced fees paid to care providers are causing residents to be left alone for hours at a time and are fostering excessive reliance on use of drugs and on physical restraint, "often for minor perceived misdemeanours".

Brendan Sarsfield, Family Mosaic's chief executive, said: "We would argue that if providers don't believe this has ever happened in their services, it just may be that they haven't looked hard enough."


David Brindle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Winterbourne View scandal prompts 'fitness' tests for hospital owners
Corporate owners of private units for NHS-funded patients with learning disabilities to face closer scrutiny after abuse revealed

Randeep Ramesh, socials affairs editor

10, Dec, 2012 @5:30 PM

Article image
Southern Cross and Winterbourne View have tested public tolerance to destruction | Polly Toynbee

Polly Toynbee: The care homes scandal shows just what happens when financiers are free to make a profit out of the most vulnerable

Polly Toynbee

03, Jun, 2011 @6:00 PM

Bristol care home: a failure on every level | Jim Mansell
Jim Mansell: The Bristol scandal isn't just about wicked staff, but about social services wanting a quick fix for difficult cases

Jim Mansell

01, Jun, 2011 @7:30 PM

Article image
Seven years on from Winterbourne View, why has nothing changed? | Saba Salman
Learning disabled people are still at risk of being abused and dying unnecessarily in institutions. This is unacceptable

Saba Salman

30, May, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Panorama care home investigation prompts government inspections

Spot checks to be carried out at 150 residential centres after BBC programme uncovered systematic abuse

Polly Curtis, Patrick Butler and Simon Bowers

01, Jun, 2011 @8:03 PM

Article image
Winterbourne View: when values take a back seat in social care
We must encourage a culture where people are confident to report their concerns, says Steve Scown

Steve Scown

12, Dec, 2012 @8:30 AM

Article image
Castlebeck, the comeback | David Brindle
David Brindle: Last year's Winterbourne View abuse scandal wrecked the private care group's reputation, but a business turnaround specialist it brought in reckons things have changed

David Brindle

23, Oct, 2012 @3:59 PM

Article image
Government questions Andrew Dilnot's £1.7bn long-term care plan

More consultation needed over price tag of capping care costs and higher asset threshold, says health secretary

David Brindle and Nicholas Watt

04, Jul, 2011 @8:16 PM

Article image
There's a deafening silence of service users in the social care funding consultation

Could it be that their views don't chime with the government's preferred way forward, says Peter Beresford

Peter Beresford

22, Sep, 2011 @10:30 AM

Article image
Handing budgets to the NHS will not save social care from collapse | Bob Hudson
Social care is failing, but as well as proper funding, it desperately needs a new vision

Bob Hudson

31, Jul, 2020 @7:34 AM