De-extinction plan may go the way of the dodo | Letter

Dodo historian Anthony Cheke responds to scientists’ plans to bring the creature back to life, and wonders whether it is possible to create a safe habitat in which the birds could thrive

As a historian of the dodo and its island habitat, the Jurassic Park-style plan to “de-extinct” it, long discussed in theory, came as no surprise (Gene editing company hopes to bring dodo ‘back to life’, 31 January). Much as I respect Beth Shapiro’s skill with ancient DNA, first seen with dodos in research seminars here in Oxford in the late 1990s, I am sceptical as to how this will work.

First, the dodo was over twice the size of the next nearest pigeon, the crowned pigeons (Goura species) of New Guinea, and its growing chick thus far too big for the pigeon eggs proposed for its incubation – whereas mammoths and elephants are similar in size, so embryo transfers there might well work.

Second, while it is laudable to propose rewilding the dodo in its native Mauritius, where does the team think is suitable nowadays? The principal causes of the dodo’s extinction – predatory wild pigs and monkeys – still have the run of the remaining native forests. And dodos, largely frugivorous, would need enough forest to follow the fruiting of different tree species through the seasons to survive.

The only prospect would be on the offshore islet where the last confirmed dodos were seen (and eaten) by shipwrecked sailors in 1662, Ile d’Ambre. This 140 hectare island in the fringing lagoon is a government-owned nature reserve, currently being partly restored to natural forest, and we know it is large enough to have supported dodos in the past.

However, for their survival today, it would need a much more proactive restoration. Funding for the de-extinction project would have to include the recreation of an adequate safe habitat into which revived birds could be released – has this been factored in?
Anthony Cheke
Co-author, Lost Land of the Dodo

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Facts about our ecological crisis are incontrovertible. We must take action | Letters
Letters: Humans cannot continue to violate the fundamental laws of nature or science with impunity, say 94 signatories including Dr Alison Green and Molly Scott Cato MEP


26, Oct, 2018 @2:56 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on extinction: time to rebel | Editorial
Editorial: A million plant and animal species are under threat. Humans are largely to blame – but we will pay the cost too


07, May, 2019 @5:48 PM

Article image
Life cycle of the mysterious and long-dead dodo revealed by bone study
From egg-laying to moulting, a new bone analysis has unpicked the biology of the long-extinct bird

Nicola Davis

24, Aug, 2017 @1:11 PM

Article image
Country diary: a young wood pigeon learns a life lesson
Sandy, Bedfordshire: The hapless bird was one step away from being as dead as a dodo. It was time to teach it to be more wary

Derek Niemann

14, Oct, 2020 @4:30 AM

Article image
Life in the old bird yet: study of dodo bones yields new biological insights
It’s easy to think that dusty old bones have nothing left to offer, but a new study of dodo bones has given us a glimpse into a long-dead world

Hanneke Meijer

13, Sep, 2017 @8:00 AM

Article image
The facts of extinction and the need to act | Letters
Letters: The evidence of wildlife decline can be seen on our own doorsteps, writes Pat Twidale, while Sarah Flavell wonders what it will take for us to wake up from our complacency


14, Sep, 2020 @4:02 PM

Article image
Country diary: the first farmers did not go in for squared-off plots
Chew Valley, Somerset: These unruly fields are what we call ‘ancient countryside’ and its pattern may go back to neolithic times

Dawn Lawrence

12, Mar, 2018 @8:14 AM

Article image
Country diary: Is this the last ring ouzel in southern England?
West Dartmoor, Devon: I feared this day might come – the dwindling numbers of this mountain blackbird have come down to a lone male

Charlie Elder

07, Jun, 2021 @4:30 AM

Article image
Firm raises $15m to bring back woolly mammoth from extinction
Scientists set initial sights on creating elephant-mammoth hybrid, with first calves expected in six years

Ian Sample Science editor

13, Sep, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
Scientists picking over ice age bones discover vultures once soared in Australia’s skies
Cryptogyps lacertosus was similar in size to a wedge-tailed eagle but anatomical differences suggest it was a scavenger rather than a hunter

Donna Lu

19, Jul, 2022 @5:30 PM