Lost city of Atlantis rises again to fuel a dangerous myth

Millions have watched Netflix hit Ancient Apocalypse, which is just the latest interpretation of an enduring tale. But in its appeal to ‘race science’ it’s more than merely controversial

For a story that was first told 2,300 years ago, the myth of Atlantis has demonstrated a remarkable persistence over the millennia. Originally outlined by Plato, the tale of the rise of a great, ancient civilisation followed by its cataclysmic destruction has since generated myriad interpretations.

Many versions have been intriguing and entertaining – but none have been as controversial as its most recent outing in the Netflix series Ancient Apocalypse.

Presented by the author Graham Hancock, the programme argues that a once sophisticated culture was destroyed by floods triggered by a giant comet which crashed on Earth, a disaster that inspired the legend of Atlantis, it is claimed.

According to Hancock, survivors of the calamity spread round the world – which was then populated by simple hunter-gatherers – bringing them science, technology, agriculture and monumental architecture. We owe everything to these near godlike individuals, it is claimed.

For good measure, Hancock – who has been promoting these ideas in his books for decades – argues that archaeologists have deliberately covered up this catastrophic vision of civilisation’s spread and accuses mainstream academia of its “extremely defensive, arrogant and patronising” attitudes.

These stark claims have helped the series reach the top of viewing lists on both sides of the Atlantic, to the chagrin of archaeologists who, for their part, have denounced Ancient Apocalypse on the grounds that it provides little evidence to support its grandiose claims and for promoting conspiracy theories dressed up as science.

Flint Dibble, an archaeologist at Cardiff University, described Hancock’s basic thesis as “flawed thinking”. Archaeologists don’t hate him, as he claims. “It is simply that we strongly believe he is wrong,” says Dibble in an article in The Conversation last week.

The confrontation is intriguing and raises many issues of which the most basic is the simple question: why has the story of Atlantis – compared with other ancient myths – maintained its popularity for so long? What is the essential attraction of the tale?

For answers we only have to look at the works of Tolkien, CS Lewis, HP Lovecraft, Conan Doyle, Brecht and a host of science fiction writers who have all found the myth an irresistible inspiration.

As to the suggested location of this lost civilisation, these have ranged from the Sahara to the Antarctic and countless places in between.

The theories of Graham Hancock, presenter of the Netflix series Ancient Apocalypse, have been criticised by archaeologists.
The theories of Graham Hancock, presenter of the Netflix series Ancient Apocalypse, have been criticised by archaeologists. Photograph: Netflix

Nor is Hancock the first to suggest the destruction of a once great civilisation led to the flowering of culture elsewhere. In 1882, the maverick US congressman and popular writer Ignatius Donnelly published Atlantis: The Antediluvian World which argued that a highly complex, sophisticated culture had been wiped out by a flood 10,000 years ago and claimed that its survivors had spread round the world teaching the rest of humanity the secrets of farming and architecture. Sounds familiar.

Then there were the Nazis. Many swore by the idea that a white Nordic superior race – people of “the purest blood” – had come from Atlantis. As a result, Himmler set up an SS unit, the Ahnenerbe – or Bureau of Ancestral Heritage – in 1935 to find out where people from Atlantis had ended up after the deluge had destroyed their homeland.

And that, in part, explains why the myth of an ancient, lost civilisation is so useful. It is a basic tale of a rise and fall that can be corralled and exploited for all sorts of causes. Plato meant his tale to be an allegory. Atlantis was destroyed by the gods who had grown angry with the hubris displayed by its inhabitants and so destroyed it. Don’t get too big for your boots, in other words.

But Hancock – who describes himself as a journalist presumably to avoid being called a pseudo-scientist – takes the story to a new controversial level in suggesting that survivors of such a deluge were the instigators of the great works of other civilisations, from Egypt to Mexico and Turkey to Indonesia. As Dibble states, such claims reinforce white supremacist ideas. “They strip indigenous people of their rich heritage and instead give credit to aliens or white people.” In short, the series promotes ideas of “race science” that are outdated and long since debunked.

As to the likely site of the original Atlantis, the serious money goes on the destruction of the Greek island of Santorini and its impact on Crete and puts the blame on volcanic eruptions – not errant comets, as Hancock argues.

In addition, while Ancient Apocalypse suggests that destruction happened 12,000 years ago, most proponents of the alternative view believe it occurred around 1630BC when the island of Santorini exploded in one of the most violent volcanic events in human history.

Fourteen cubic miles of rock were hurled into the atmosphere, triggering huge tsunamis and a hail of ash that would have destroyed the Minoan civilisation which then flourished on Crete.

It was this cataclysm that was remembered more than 1,000 years later in Plato’s time. He attributed it to a civilisation that he called Atlantis, little knowing how his brief description of a lost culture would resonate so strongly – and often controversially – through the ages.

Contributor

Robin McKie Science Editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Winona Ryder: from teen rebel to screen mum
As the 80s star of Beetlejuice and Heathers returns with a plum role on Netflix, we chart her troubled career

Sarah Hughes

18, Jun, 2016 @11:04 PM

Article image
House of cards? Why the world is falling out of love with Netflix
After years of growth, the streaming giant revealed a shock fall in subscribers. But is it really downhill from here?

Vanessa Thorpe

23, Apr, 2022 @2:21 PM

Article image
How Millie Bobby Brown used her superpowers
The Stranger Things star is still in her teens, but has moved beyond new kid on the block to be a Hollywood power broker

Vanessa Thorpe

28, Mar, 2021 @9:30 AM

Article image
Michael Jordan was years ahead of his game. The Last Dance showed that he still is
The docuseries that enthralled millions isn’t just about sport, but the pursuit of perfection. And at its heart is a superstar who still retains his mystery

Bryan Armen Graham

24, May, 2020 @7:12 AM

Article image
From stand-in stars to tech titans: The Observer’s faces to watch in 2022
We look at who will be making headlines this year, in both a positive and negative light

Toby Helm, Robin McKie, Vanessa Thorpe, Simon Tisdall, Barry Glendenning, Suzanne Wrack, Priya Elan, Ian Tucker, Wendy Ide and Barbara Ellen

02, Jan, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Sitting comfortably? Top TV treats to raise your spirits in 2021
It’s in with the old and the new, as broadcasters and streaming platforms serve up a slew of fresh dramas, favourite series, comedy hits and debuts

Sarah Hughes

03, Jan, 2021 @8:45 AM

Article image
Untrained blind student lands starring role in Netflix second world war epic
Disability rights groups applaud casting of Aria Mia Loberti in All the Light We Cannot See

Dalya Alberge

26, Dec, 2021 @8:30 AM

Article image
The farmer’s boy and the ship of gold: uncovering the treasures of Sutton Hoo
The story of the 1939 amateur dig in Suffolk that unearthed the richest grave found in Europe is now being retold on screen

Robin McKie

17, Jan, 2021 @10:45 AM

Article image
Tragic, fascinating, brilliant – life of ‘wild child’ Zelda Fitzgerald revisited
Two films and a TV series out soon portray the life of the jazz-age writer and wife of F Scott Fitzgerald

Sarah Hughes

29, Oct, 2016 @11:04 PM

Article image
‘True, apart from the made-up bits’: why people are lining up to sue over Netflix portrayals
Forget the fun disclaimers, individuals unhappy about their characters in shows like Inventing Anna head to the courts

Vanessa Thorpe

04, Sep, 2022 @1:00 PM