Vegetarian women more likely to fracture hips in later life, study shows

Research suggests some vegetarians may not get sufficient nutrients for good bone and muscle health

Women who are vegetarian are more likely to experience hip fractures in later life than those who frequently eat meat, a UK study has found.

Researchers analysed health and diet records from more than 26,000 women and found that over a roughly 22-year period, vegetarians were a third more likely to break a hip than those who regularly ate meat.

The reasons for the greater risk are unclear but researchers suspect some vegetarians may not get sufficient nutrients for good bone and muscle health, leaving them prone to falls and fractures.

“The message for vegetarians is don’t give up your diet, because it is healthy for other things and environmentally friendly, but do take care to plan well and don’t miss out on nutrients that you exclude when you don’t eat meat or fish,” said Dr James Webster, a researcher at the University of Leeds.

Vegetarian diets are often considered healthier than meat-containing diets and they can reduce the risk of diabetes, obesity, heart disease and certain cancers. But the study published in BMC Medicine highlights the importance of a balanced diet whatever people eat.

“It’s likely that vegetarians, for one reason or another, and potentially because of lower intakes of important nutrients, have weaker bones and lower muscle mass and both of those things predispose people to hip fractures,” Webster said.

About 90% of hip fractures are linked to falls, which are more common in older people, who tend to be more frail and have weaker bones. But fractures can often drive further frailty, which increases the risk of more falls and worse frailty.

The researchers suspect vegetarians are more likely to be underweight than meat eaters, and that beyond having weaker bones and muscles may also have less fat, which can act as a cushion when people fall.

Given the findings, Webster said vegetarians may want to consider eating fortified cereals with added iron and B12 for bone health, and to ensure they are getting enough protein, through foods such as nuts, legumes and beans.

The researchers drew on data from the UK Women’s Cohort Study, which is tracking women over time to assess links between diet and health. Records for 26,318 women aged 35 to 69 revealed that 822, or 3%, had hip fractures in a roughly 22-year period. About 28% of the women were vegetarians and 1% were vegans.

The researchers compared the rate of hip fractures in vegetarians, pescatarians – those who eat fish but not meat – and occasional meat eaters with frequent meat easters. The frequent meat eaters ate meat at least five times a week.

Webster said more work was needed to see if vegetarian men had a similarly greater risk of hip fractures. Previous work suggests vegetarian men and women have poorer bone health on average when compared with meat-eaters “but risk of hip fracture in male vegetarians still remains unclear”, he said.

Eating less meat is one of the most important lifestyle changes people can make to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Research from Leeds University last year found that non-vegetarian diets created 59% more emissions than vegetarian ones.

Sign up to First Edition, our free daily newsletter – every weekday morning at 7am BST

In work published in 2020, Dr Tammy Tong, a senior nutritional epidemiologist, and others at the University of Oxford, found that compared with meat eaters, vegetarians had a 25% greater risk of hip fractures, with the risk even high for vegans at 31%.

Vegetarians in the Leeds study had a lower body mass index (BMI) than regular-meat eaters, lower protein intake and lower vitamin D intake, “all of which are potential risk factors for hip fracture,” she said.

“Vegetarians should pay particular attention to maintaining a healthy body weight, and making sure that they have an adequate intake of protein and other nutrients important for bone health, including calcium and vitamin D.”


Ian Sample Science editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Vegetarians less likely to develop cancer than meat eaters, says study

Scientists find striking difference in risk of disease in blood but acknowledge more research is needed

Karen McVeigh

30, Jun, 2009 @11:05 PM

Article image
Plant-based diet can cut bowel cancer risk in men by 22%, says study
Researchers find no such link for women, suggesting connection between diet and bowel cancer is clearer for men

Andrew Gregory Health editor

29, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Man’s severe migraines ‘completely eliminated’ on plant-based diet
Migraines disappeared after man started diet that included lots of dark-green leafy vegetables, study shows

Andrew Gregory Health editor

18, Nov, 2021 @11:30 PM

Article image
Why we fell for clean eating
The long read: The oh-so-Instagrammable food movement has been thoroughly debunked – but it shows no signs of going away. The real question is why we were so desperate to believe it

Bee Wilson

11, Aug, 2017 @5:00 AM

Article image
How dieting will get personal – and much more effective
Project analysing people’s gut bacteria and determining which foods cause a spike in their blood sugar levels is paving the way for tailor-made diets

Saleyha Ahsan

28, Jan, 2016 @11:00 AM

Article image
Greggs, guilt and glucose: what I've learned from a life of dieting
I’ve spent decades trying every fad and detox, looking for the magic formula for weight loss

Zoe Williams

04, Jan, 2020 @1:00 PM

Article image
Scientists study link between unhealthy pregnancy diet and ADHD
Experts examine how a diet high in fat and sugar could alter baby’s DNA in a way that might cause behavioural problems

Haroon Siddique

18, Aug, 2016 @4:01 AM

Article image
Scientists buzz Simon Cowell for promoting pseudoscience

Sense About Science publishes its annual review of celebrities' misleading claims, including Cowell's intravenous vitamins

Alok Jha, science correspondent

28, Dec, 2011 @7:30 AM

Article image
Messages about reducing sugar intake unclear, say campaigners
New WHO guidelines must be translated into something meaningful to consumers, says director of Action on Sugar

Sarah Boseley, health editor

06, Mar, 2014 @8:53 PM

Article image
Mediterranean diet 'cuts strokes and heart attacks in at-risk groups'

Research shows diet can reduce risk for people who smoke, have type 2 diabetes or exhibit other unhealthy characteristics

Denis Campbell, health correspondent

25, Feb, 2013 @8:01 PM