Large Hadron Collider to restart and hunt for a fifth force of nature

Latest run is expected to scrutinise findings from last year that may turn into another blockbuster discovery

The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) will restart on Friday after a three-year hiatus and is expected to resolve a scientific cliffhanger on whether a mysterious anomaly could point to the existence of a fifth fundamental force of nature.

The tantalising findings reported last year have reignited hopes that the 20 mile-long collider could deliver a second blockbuster discovery, more than a decade after the Higgs boson.

Dr Mitesh Patel, a particle physicist at Imperial College London whose team was responsible for last year’s research, said: “We are going into this run with more optimism that there could be a revolution coming. Fingers crossed.”

So far, everything discovered at the LHC – including the Higgs – has fallen in line with the so-called standard model. This has been the guiding theory of particle physics since the 1970s but is known to be incomplete because it fails to explain some of the deepest mysteries in physics, such as the nature of dark matter.

However, data collected in the LHCb experiment, one of four huge particle detectors at Cern in Switzerland, appeared to show particles behaving in a way that could not be explained by the standard model.

The experiment looked at the decay of particles called beauty quarks, which are predicted to decay at an equal rate into electrons and their heavier cousins, muons. However, the beauty quarks appeared to be turning into muons 15% less often, suggesting that an unknown factor – potentially a new force – was tipping the scales. Two of the top candidates include hypothetical force-carrying particles called leptoquarks or Z primes.

“The stakes are extremely high,” Patel said. “If we confirm this, it will be a revolution of the kind we’ve not seen – certainly in my lifetime. You don’t want to mess it up.”

Before the LHC was switched off for an upgrade in 2018, the team collected enough data to suggest the odds were roughly a thousand to one of the result happening by chance. But the gold standard for particle physics is a more stringent one in 3.5m level of confidence, meaning more data is needed before a discovery can be declared. There is also a lingering possibility that some unknown experimental glitch could explain the findings.

“When you show this result to particle physicists, the first instinct is, ‘You guys have screwed up’ rather than it’s a new force of nature,” said Patel. “Us physicists like to be beyond sure and out the other side.”

In the past year, anticipation has been heightened by further intriguing hints of physics beyond the standard model seen in other experiments, including recent unexplained findings from Fermilab in the US.

“There seem to be a collection of loose threads now,” said Prof Jon Butterworth of University College London, who works on the LHC’s Atlas experiment. “It’s made me begin to think that there might be something out there within reach of this run or the next one.”

If the LHC fails to reveal new science beyond the standard model, Butterworth said, this would not represent a failure but would leave the field “in a bit of a quandary” about where to look next.

The third run, expected to last until 2026, follows an upgrade that has included the installation of additional powerful magnets designed to squeeze the protons inside the collider into finer, denser beams. This will increase the collision rate of particles inside the accelerator, meaning scientists will be able to observe rarer events with greater precision.

Ashutosh Kotwal, an experimental particle physicist at Duke University in the US and co-leader of a research group at LHC’s Atlas experiment, said: “The potential for discovering new ideas is still so large. It’s worth noting that the data that we’ve collected so far is only one 10th of the total that we are planning. It’s too early to lose heart.”


Hannah Devlin Science correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Large Hadron Collider becomes world's most powerful particle accelerator

In the early hours of this morning the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at Cern accelerated beams of particles to higher energies than any achieved before

Ian Sample, science correspondent

30, Nov, 2009 @1:05 PM

Article image
Second chance for Large Hadron Collider to deliver universe's secrets

One year after £30m meltdown, scientists watch anxiously as 'God Machine' starts work again under Swiss mountain

Robin McKie, Geneva

01, Nov, 2009 @12:06 AM

Article image
£720m Large Hadron Collider upgrade 'could upend particle physics'
Collider will be far more sensitive to anomalies that could lead to entirely new theories of the universe

Ian Sample

15, Jun, 2018 @10:33 AM

Article image
Excitement grows as Large Hadron Collider hints at new particle
Blips in data are common, but scientists are hoping that brief flashes of light spotted inside the LHC might be the first glimpse of a new era of physics

Ian Sample Science editor

18, Mar, 2016 @12:04 PM

Article image
Large Hadron Collider warms up for final drive to catch a Higgs boson

As the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) prepares to restart, physicists are optimistic it will detect hints of the Higgs this year

Ian Sample, science correspondent

28, Feb, 2011 @7:30 AM

Article image
Large Hadron Collider comes to life
Scientists at Cern, the European particle physics laboratory near Geneva, switch on their giant particle collider

10, Sep, 2008 @4:18 PM

Article image
Large Hadron Collider – Live!

The waiting is over. The world's largest, most powerful particle accelerator goes into action this morning. The hunt for new particles, forces and dimensions starts here.

Ian Sample

30, Mar, 2010 @6:34 AM

Article image
Large Hadron Collider on paws after creature chews through wiring
LHC expected to be out of action for a week while transformer connections are replaced following visit from hungry fouine

Ian Sample Science editor

29, Apr, 2016 @7:14 PM

Fear and the Large Hadron Collider | Euclides Montes
Euclides Montes: From as far back as discovery of fire, science has made us anxious. We must harness fear's power, not be consumed by it

Euclides Montes

19, Nov, 2009 @6:30 PM

Article image
Cern restarts Large Hadron Collider with mission to make scientific history
Now physicists hope particle accelerator will explain dark matter, gravity and antimatter

Ian Sample Science editor

05, Apr, 2015 @7:48 PM