Gene editing ‘would allow us to create hardier farm breeds’

The biotechnology is comparable to traditional breeding methods and vital to create livestock resistant to disease, droughts and heatwaves, says group

Leading UK researchers, vets and farmers have urged ministers to free livestock science of unnecessary legal curbs as the country prepares, post-Brexit, to ease gene-editing rules. Such a move would allow the creation of new breeds of animals resistant to disease, heat and drought, they argue.

The government is expected to propose easing gene-editing restrictions in the near future to enable the creation of new generations of crops. However, the group – which has written to the environment secretary, George Eustice – worries there is less interest in using the technology to create new breeds of pigs, cows and poultry.

“It is every bit as important that we use the enormous power of gene editing to create breeds of animals that are resistant to disease, droughts and heatwaves as it is to fashion new crop varieties,” said Professor Bruce Whitelaw of Edinburgh’s Roslin Institute. “This is particularly important as global warming intensifies and we strive to ensure we are protected against future outbreaks of zoonotic diseases.”

The value of gene editing in this latter field is shown by work carried out at Roslin and Imperial College London, where scientists have identified a gene that may confer resistance to influenza. “We can now think about using gene editing to create breeds resistant to avian and swine flu, and so curb outbreaks on farms, while also reducing the risk of triggering future pandemics in humans,” added Whitelaw, one of the letter’s signatories.

Other recent developments in the gene editing of livestock include the creation of pigs that can fight off a disease known as porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV), which is devastating pig herds globally. “Using gene editing this way has enormous power to save billions of pounds and to stop animal suffering,” said Whitelaw.

Earlier, the creation of new strains of plants or animals in the laboratory involved the transfer of entire genes or groups of genes from one species to another and was known as genetic modification. The EU strictly regulates GM technology.

More recent techniques of gene editing involve making slight changes to existing genes in a plant or animal and are considered to be as safe as traditional plant breeding techniques. The European court of justice nevertheless controversially ruled in 2018 that gene editing was essentially the same as genetic modification and should be subject to tight rules.

“Gene-editing research in the UK has been hampered by the unnecessary and unscientific regulatory barriers we have inherited from the EU,” said Professor Helen Sang, also of the Roslin Institute and a signatory of the letter. “This leaves us lagging behind the approach taken in other parts of the world, such as Japan, Australia, Argentina, Brazil and Canada.”

Britain is expected to throw off these legislative shackles with an announcement soon from the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. However, a report by the Taskforce on Innovation, Growth and Regulatory Reform earlier this year advised the government to press ahead with regulatory reform of gene editing of plants and crops but was more cautious about its use on livestock.

Such an emphasis would represent a lost opportunity, said Professor Lord Trees, an expert in vaccine parasitology and another signatory to the letter. “The UK’s strength in genome sequencing, together with our preservation of rare breeds and genetic diversity offers great potential.

“This could have a very significant impact in reducing antimicrobial and antiparasitic drug usage and help overcome the challenges of resistance to chemical treatment, as well as the problem of environmental contamination with drug residues.”

Many green groups remain opposed to the creation of new, gene-edited breeds of pigs, cows and poultry, arguing that they will only worsen the intensification of factory farming.

“Some people just don’t like the idea of genetically altering animals,” said Whitelaw. “But we have been doing that for thousands of years, and have turned wolves into chihuahuas and no one seems to mind.”


Robin McKie Science and environment editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
US gene-editing ruling delights plant scientists
Ruling paves way for creation of new genetically altered crops

Robin McKie Science editor

07, Apr, 2018 @11:05 PM

Article image
US moves to sell gene-edited mushrooms fuel doubts over British ban on GM imports
Approval for modified crops in America adds to confusion in UK on new-tech foodstuffs

Robin McKie

23, Apr, 2016 @11:05 PM

Article image
Lords seek to allow gene-editing in UK 'to produce healthy, hardier crops'
Changes could herald gluten-free wheat and disease-resistant fruit and vegetables

Robin McKie Science Editor

14, Jun, 2020 @7:11 AM

Article image
The Observer view on Europe’s ban on gene-editing crops | Observer editorial
This absurd ruling restricts highly targeted plant breeding but allows random changes caused by carcinogenic chemicals

Observer editorial

29, Jul, 2018 @4:59 AM

Article image
Top biologists debate ban on gene-editing
Washington biology summit to consider ban on controversial technology

Robin McKie

28, Nov, 2015 @9:51 PM

Article image
Gene editing: don’t bet the farm on this pig in a poke | Letters
Letters: Using genetic engineering to eradicate livestock diseases will have hidden costs for human and animal health, warns Dr Julia Wright


22, Mar, 2018 @6:17 PM

Article image
Gene therapy offers hope for treatment of sickle cell anaemia
Scientists to begin trials for treatment to overcome inherited disease that affects 300,000 newborn babies a year

Robin McKie

01, Oct, 2016 @9:15 PM

Article image
Gene editing will just perpetuate disastrous factory farming | Letters
Instead of trying to cosh nature into submission, our farmers should be improving the health of the soil and the diversity of their crops and animals

03, Oct, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
We need to use gene editing wisely but also embrace its vast potential | Mary Warnock
A new survey reveals Britons are keen to understand the possibilities offered by the groundbreaking science but also concerned it is properly regulated

Mary Warnock

11, Mar, 2018 @6:03 AM

Article image
Gene editing of crops and livestock may soon be permitted in England
Government has launched consultation to change current strict EU rules

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

07, Jan, 2021 @6:00 AM