Cern experiment hints at new force of nature

Experts reveal ‘cautious excitement’ over unstable particles that fail to decay as standard model suggests

Scientists at the Large Hadron Collider near Geneva have spotted an unusual signal in their data that may be the first hint of a new kind of physics.

The LHCb collaboration, one of four main teams at the LHC, analysed 10 years of data on how unstable particles called B mesons, created momentarily in the vast machine, decayed into more familiar matter such as electrons.

The mathematical framework that underpins scientists’ understanding of the subatomic world, known as the standard model of particle physics, firmly maintains that the particles should break down into products that include electrons at exactly the same rate as they do into products that include a heavier cousin of the electron, a particle called a muon.

But results released by Cern on Tuesday suggest that something unusual is happening. The B mesons are not decaying in the way the model says they should: instead of producing electrons and muons at the same rate, nature appears to favour the route that ends with electrons.

“We would expect this particle to decay into the final state containing electrons and the final state containing muons at the same rate as each other,” said Prof Chris Parkes, an experimental particle physicist at the University of Manchester and spokesperson for the LHCb collaboration. “What we have is an intriguing hint that maybe these two processes don’t happen at the same rate, but it’s not conclusive.”

In physics parlance, the result has a significance of 3.1 sigma, meaning the chance of it being a fluke is about one in 1,000. While that may sound convincing evidence, particle physicists tend not to claim a new discovery until a result reaches a significance of five sigma, where the chance of it being a statistical quirk are reduced to one in a few million.

“It’s an intriguing hint, but we have seen sigmas come and go before. It happens surprisingly frequently,” Parkes said.

The standard model of particle physics describes the particles and forces that govern the subatomic world. Constructed over the past half century, it defines how elementary particles called quarks build protons and neutrons inside atomic nuclei, and how these, usually combined with electrons, make up all known matter. The model also explains three of the four fundamental forces of nature: electromagnetism; the strong force, which holds atomic nuclei together; and the weak force which causes nuclear reactions in the sun.

But the standard model does not describe everything. It does not explain the fourth force, gravity, and perhaps more strikingly, says nothing about the 95% of the universe that physicists believe is not constructed from normal matter.

Much of the cosmos, they believe, consists of dark energy, a force that appears to be driving the expansion of the universe, and dark matter, a mysterious substance that seems to hold the cosmic web of matter in place like an invisible skeleton.

“If it turns out, with extra analysis of additional processes, that we were able to confirm this, it would be extremely exciting,” Parkes said. It would mean there is something wrong with the standard model and that we require something extra in our fundamental theory of particle physics to explain how this would happen.”

Despite the uncertainties over this particular result, Parkes said when combined with other results on B mesons, the case for something unusual happening became more convincing.

“I would say there is cautious excitement. We’re intrigued because not only is this result quite significant, it fits the pattern of some previous results from LHCb and other experiments worldwide,” he said.

Ben Allanach, a professor of theoretical physics at the University of Cambridge, agrees that taken together with other findings, the latest LHCb result is exciting. “I really think this will turn into something,” he said.

If the result turns out to be true, it could be explained by so-far hypothetical particles called Z primes or leptoquarks that bring new forces to bear on other particles.

“There could be a new quantum force that makes the B mesons break up into muons at the wrong rate. It’s sticking them together and stopping them decaying into muons at the rate we’d expect,” Allanach said. “This force could help explain the peculiar pattern of different matter particles’ masses.”

B mesons contain elementary particles called beauty quarks, also know as bottom quarks.

Scientists will collect more data from the LHC and other experiments around the world, such as Belle II in Japan, in the hope of confirming what is happening.


Ian Sample Science editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Large Hadron Collider to restart and hunt for a fifth force of nature
Latest run is expected to scrutinise findings from last year that may turn into another blockbuster discovery

Hannah Devlin Science correspondent

21, Apr, 2022 @2:59 PM

Article image
Cern scientists suspect glimpse of Higgs boson

Unusual data bumps detected by two teams at Large Hadron Collider thought to be glimpse of elusive source of particle mass

Ian Sample, Science correspondent

22, Jul, 2011 @7:09 PM

Article image
Cern gears up for more discoveries 10 years after ‘God particle’ find
With the Higgs boson already in the bag, the Large Hadron Collider begins another period of data collection

Nicola Davis Science correspondent

04, Jul, 2022 @3:35 PM

Article image
Excitement grows as Large Hadron Collider hints at new particle
Blips in data are common, but scientists are hoping that brief flashes of light spotted inside the LHC might be the first glimpse of a new era of physics

Ian Sample Science editor

18, Mar, 2016 @12:04 PM

Article image
Cern restarts Large Hadron Collider with mission to make scientific history
Now physicists hope particle accelerator will explain dark matter, gravity and antimatter

Ian Sample Science editor

05, Apr, 2015 @7:48 PM

Article image
Cern poised to back plan for €20bn successor to Large Hadron Collider
Proposed 100km circular tunnel would be four times as big and six times as powerful as LHC

Hannah Devlin Science correspondent

19, Jun, 2020 @6:01 AM

Article image
A day of xenon collisions at CERN
On Friday, the Large Hadron Collider at CERN had a day of smashing xenon nuclei together, a departure from its usual diet of protons or lead

Jon Butterworth

15, Oct, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
One year on from the Higgs boson find, has physics hit the buffers?

Despite the success of the Large Hadron Collider, evidence for the follow-up theory – supersymmetry – has proved elusive

Alok Jha, science correspondent

06, Aug, 2013 @9:26 PM

Article image
UK scientists on collision course over £1bn research cuts
Officials fear planned 25% cuts could jeopardise Britain's involvement in the Large Hadron Collider at Cern

Alok Jha and Ian Sample

26, Aug, 2010 @5:45 PM

Article image
Higgs boson was just a start for Cern's atom smasher – other mysteries await

The Large Hadron Collider will shut down for an overhaul in preparation for exploring questions of dark matter, extra dimensions and other universes

Ian Sample

01, Jan, 2013 @6:57 PM