Metal-detecting versus real archaeology| Letter

Christopher Sparey-Green responds to an article on ‘when metal detectorists go rogue’

Archaeology is not metal-detecting – the discovery of objects is not the aim, however “valuable” an item or hoard may appear to be (Stealing Britain’s history: when metal detectorists go rogue, 2 June).

The use of the term “treasure” in the name of English and Welsh legislation is highly misleading, only fostering views such as that of the National Council for Metal Detecting that a find is akin to “opening a Christmas present”.

As a professional archaeologist, I approve of the antiquities systems in Ireland and Scotland, and would advocate that the use of an electronic device to detect lost metal should be licensed.

Important metal finds only come to life when discovered in the context of rare sites such as the bronze age village at Must Farm, Cambridge – our “prehistoric Pompeii”. Metal finds can be significant, but do not need to be held in the hand – my most significant recent discovery was from the pages of an academic journal, describing a substantial nail in an unusual context, an object which links to a historical source and could indicate the existence of a totally new site type in Britain. That requires more research in the museum store and a thorough site survey – the stuff of real archaeology.
Christopher Sparey-Green


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Bawdy monks and the Cerne Abbas giant | Letters
Letters: Alice Raw of the University of Oxford and Richard North of University College London respond to research suggesting that the chalk hill figure in Dorset dates from Anglo-Saxon times


16, May, 2021 @5:17 PM

Article image
Country diary: our soil seethes with history | Country diary
Welburn and Crambeck, North Yorkshire: As I pick out the stones and weeds, I think about the life you can see and the life you can’t

Amy-Jane Beer

25, Apr, 2020 @4:30 AM

Article image
Archaeology A-level is now ancient history | Letters
Letters: The loss of archaeology as an A-level subject is a blow to the UK’s education, arts and heritage sectors


17, Oct, 2016 @6:10 PM

Article image
Coins make a solid case for the existence of Emperor Sponsian | Letter
Letter: Our hypothesis that the ‘fake’ Roman emperor was in fact real is based on a wealth of evidence, writes Prof Paul Pearson

27, Nov, 2022 @6:18 PM

Article image
Planning the future of a prehistoric find | Letters
Letters: The discovery of a neolithic ring of shafts near Stonehenge should not rule out a proposed new tunnel, writes Mike Pitts, while Phil Coughlin says the site will keep archaeologists busy for years to come


25, Jun, 2020 @4:08 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Neanderthals: we were not alone | Editorial
Editorial: The first human contact with another intelligent species is a staple of science fiction, but we now know it happened 40,000 years ago


25, Feb, 2018 @6:15 PM

Article image
Christmas wish for Conservatives to lead by example | Letters
Letters: The leadership should have small celebrations at home, writes Frances Davies. And Keith Flett sheds light on the last time MPs sat on Christmas Day


13, Dec, 2020 @5:53 PM

Article image
Beware of historical mythconceptions | Letters
Letters: Columbus did not ‘discover’ the Americas, but nor did the Vikings, the Welsh, or even St Brendan, says Dr Patrick O’Sullivan. Plus Clive Goodhead argues that Yorkshireman Sir George Cayley is the first true ‘father of aviation’


19, Jan, 2018 @4:53 PM

Article image
Black lives we really should remember | Letters
Letters: The first black family in Coronation Street appeared back in 1963, writes Tom May, while Joe Smith highlights the role played by Africans in 19th-century exploration


05, May, 2019 @4:32 PM

Article image
Fantastic beasts, but where to find them? | Letters
Brief letters: Neanderthals | Royal family | Unicorn shortage | Grace Dent | Crosswords


21, Feb, 2021 @6:00 PM