China accuses US of double standards over satellite strike

US navy fires missile from Pacific Ocean warship to destroy failed satellite amid claims the Pentagon is militarising space

China today accused Washington of double standards after the US navy fired a missile to destroy a failed satellite 150 miles above the Pacific.

Beijing - which was criticised by the US and others when it shot down one of its own satellites last year - turned the tables on the Bush administration after the satellite was shot down today.

"The United States, the world's top space power, has often accused other countries of vigorously developing military space technology," the People's Daily, the ruling Communist party's newspaper, said.

"But faced with the Chinese-Russian proposal to restrict space armaments, it runs in fear from what it claimed to love."

Earlier this month, Russia and China proposed a treaty to ban weapons in space and the use or threat of force against satellites and other spacecraft.

Washington rejected the proposal as unworkable, saying it favoured confidence-building efforts, US reports said.

At a regular news conference, the Chinese foreign ministry spokesman, Liu Jianchao, said: "The Chinese side is continuing to closely follow the US action, which may influence the security of outer space and may harm other countries."

US defence officials said they were confident that a missile, fired from the USS Lake Erie, had hit its target, destroying a tank of toxic fuel on the satellite, which failed soon after being launched in 2006.

Video footage released by the Pentagon showed a fireball when the missile struck the satellite, indicating that the fuel tank - containing hydrazine - had exploded.

"All indications are that it was a successful intercept," General James Cartwright said. The official added that it could take another 24-48 hours to know for certain whether the tank had been destroyed.

The missile was fired at 3.26am GMT, despite earlier reports that the operation would be postponed because of bad weather in the Pacific.

The modified tactical standard missile 3 (SM-3) hit the satellite at an altitude of 150 miles (247km) while it was travelling at approximately 17,000mph.

Two other ships, the USS Decatur and the USS Russell, were close by, and part of the task force, run by the Army Space and Missile Defence Command in Colorado Springs. If the initial shot had missed the satellite, they could have provided back up missiles.

Pentagon officials insisted the operation was necessary to prevent possible deaths following the satellite's re-entry into the earth's atmosphere. The craft, a spy satellite, was carrying around 450kg of toxic hydrazine fuel.

The successful launch proved that the US navy's Aegis anti-missile radar system could be quickly adapted to shoot down satellites.

When China shot down a defunct weather satellite last January, there were protests from western governments.

In the aftermath of the exercise, Gordon Johndroe, a White House spokesman, said: "The US believes China's development and testing of such weapons is inconsistent with the spirit of cooperation that both countries aspire to in the civil space area.

"We and other countries have expressed our concern regarding this action to the Chinese."

Downing Street also expressed its concern at the time, condemning what it said was a "lack of consultation".

The Chinese action was also criticised because of the millions of pieces of orbiting space junk, created by the satellite's destruction, which could damage other satellites or the space shuttle while in orbit.

However, space junk should not be a problem from today's space shot though. Because of the satellite's relatively low altitude, debris began re-entering the atmosphere almost straight away, the US defence department said.

Most debris should re-enter the atmosphere within 48 hours, and the remaining pieces will leave orbit within 40 days.

Scientists and groups opposed to the militarisation of space backed China's criticism of the US exercise.

Professor Michio Kaku, the distinguished physicist and author of Physics of the Impossible, said: "With a certain amount of justification, the Chinese claim there is a double standard … this latest move can be seen as provocative, since the US has refused to renegotiate and strengthen the 1987 outer space treaty.

"What is needed is a comprehensive ban on the militarisation of outer space … arming the heavens will only put us one step closer to a disastrous war in space that no one can win."


James Randerson in Washington and Mark Tran

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
US ‘very concerned’ despite China denials over hypersonic missile
Disarmament ambassador casts doubt on ability to defend against technology after reports of test

Vincent Ni, Julian Borger in Washington and agencies

18, Oct, 2021 @4:08 PM

Article image
China 'successfully tests missile interceptor'
Chinese state media announces it has tested new technology to intercept missiles in flight as US reports detecting collision

Tania Branigan in Beijing and agencies

12, Jan, 2010 @7:50 AM

Iran satellite launch raises tension, says David Miliband

Foreign secretary expresses concern over state's claim to have broken into the global space race

Ewen MacAskill in Washington, Robert Tait and Julian Borger

04, Feb, 2009 @12:01 AM

Article image
China says anti-missile test not ‘aimed at any country’ despite rising tensions
Ballistic missile interception system trial follows North Korean tests and deployment of US THAAD system in South Korea

Vincent Ni and agencies

20, Jun, 2022 @3:57 PM

Article image
China denies hacking the Pentagon
Newspaper report says People's Liberation Army broke into computers and stole files.

Mark Tran

04, Sep, 2007 @10:14 AM

Google defiant over censorship in China

Internet giant steps into realm of politics with debate on freedom of speech.

David Smith, technology correspondent

29, Oct, 2006 @1:07 AM

Article image
China hits back over US claims of satellite hacking

Foreign ministry spokesman accuses US commission of ulterior motives over claim that government satellites were targeted. By Tania Branigan and Josh Halliday

Tania Branigan in Beijing and Josh Halliday

31, Oct, 2011 @2:08 PM

China forced to face its critics over internet censorship

David Smith in Athens at the UN conference on the internet, where The Observer's campaign was the centre of attention.

David Smith

05, Nov, 2006 @3:59 PM

Article image
China accuses US of human rights double standards
Beijing report says Washington demands internet freedom overseas while imposing harsh restrictions at home

Tania Branigan in Beijing

11, Apr, 2011 @1:47 PM

Google blazes a trail with China rift | Jonathan Fenby
Jonathan Fenby: Google's Eric Schmidt had dinner with Hillary Clinton last week, which hints at the new power politics behind today's story

Jonathan Fenby

13, Jan, 2010 @3:00 PM