Dinosaur cleared of cannibalism

The victim of the slur is the earliest well-known dinosaur, the slender biped Coelophysis bauri, which gained notoriety in the 1950s as a cannibal content to feed even on its own young.

Fossil hunters have unearthed what they believe to be the oldest example of defamation of character amid a collection of bones dating back 210m years. The victim of the slur is the earliest well-known dinosaur, the slender biped Coelophysis bauri, which gained notoriety in the 1950s as a cannibal content to feed even on its own young.

The dinosaur's dietary behaviour emerged when paleontologists working in Ghost Ranch, New Mexico, uncovered an enormous bonebed containing the skeletons of hundreds of Coelophysis. Some appeared to have remnants of their own kind in their stomach regions.

The tale has become one of the most widely covered from prehistory and has been perpetuated in children's books and museum exhibitions. At the Natural History Museum in London, the Dino Jaws display shows a Coelophysis tucking into a juvenile shortly after it has clambered from an egg.

But in research published today, paleontologists at the American Museum of Natural History in New York claim the Coelophysis has been badly wronged. They re-examined the fossils found in New Mexico and concluded that although Coelophysis was a meat eater, there was no evidence it was a cannibal after all.

Two skeletons in particular cleared the Coelophysis' name. One, a near complete adult lying on its left side, was previously believed to have a leg bone from its own species in its stomach. But the latest study in Biology Letters shows the size of the leg and the positioning of the adult makes it almost certain the adult merely died on top of the limb rather than ingested it.

A second adult skeleton added further evidence of Coelophysis' good character. Bones confirmed to be inside the dinosaur's stomach were analysed and found to be from an entirely different species, with bone details indistinguishable from those of early crocodilians.

"Coelophysis is held up as the foremost example of cannibalistic behaviour in dinosaurs, but our work suggests that isn't true," said Sterling Nesbitt who led the study.

Because there is little other evidence that dinosaurs engaged in cannibalism, the researchers conclude it may have been extremely rare or non-existent.

The discovery will not only require a more sympathetic update of the dinosaur's behaviour in textbooks. It is causing ripples through the world of museums. "We've got a Coelophysis eating one of its own at our museum, so we'll be looking at changing that pretty soon," said Mr Nesbitt.

Contributor

Ian Sample

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Dinosaur footprints found on Skye
Tracks of meat-eating dinosaurs found on Scottish island, shedding light on behaviours during Middle Jurassic period

Nicola Davis

03, Apr, 2018 @5:00 AM

Dinosaur discoveries
More recent fossil finds around the world

Holly Bentley

17, Sep, 2009 @9:43 PM

Fossil reveals a caring, sharing dinosaur

The monstrous image of the dinosaurs needs a more touchy-feely makeover after US researchers found convincing evidence that at least some of the king reptiles cared for their young and even dug burrows to hide from predators.

James Randerson, science correspondent

21, Mar, 2007 @12:02 AM

Bird-like lungs key to size of dinosaurs
Bird-like lungs could have helped the biggest dinosaurs reach their astonishing size, say scientists.

Alok Jha

27, Oct, 2005 @12:50 AM

Article image
T rex's ancestor revealed

Say hello to the daddy of the most fearsome dinosaur known to exist. The fossil of this three-metre-long Guanlong wucaii (which translates as "crowned dragon of the five coloured rocks") was found in the Junggar basin in north-west China and represents the earliest tyrannosaur known to exist.

Alok Jha

09, Feb, 2006 @12:01 AM

Article image
Allosaurus dinosaur suspected to be scavenging cannibal
Dinosaur-on-dinosaur dining habit revealed by scrutiny of fossil bones from Colorado site

Nicola Davis

27, May, 2020 @6:00 PM

Article image
Misty the dinosaur sold in UK auction
Diplodocus skeleton discovered in Wyoming by palaeontologist's sons snapped up for £400,000

Sam Jones and agency

27, Nov, 2013 @5:42 PM

Article image
Dinosaur skeleton discovered under Surrey brick factory
Near-complete fossilised skeleton of 132m-year-old creature, believed to be an Iguanodon, has been taken to special laboratory for further investigation

Nicola Davis

04, Jul, 2017 @12:10 PM

European giant unearthed

A giant fossilised dinosaur discovered in Spain may be the biggest land animal ever found on European soil.

James Randerson, science correspondent

22, Dec, 2006 @1:29 AM

Article image
Welsh dinosaur bones confirmed as new Jurassic species
Named Dracoraptor hanigani, meaning ‘dragon robber’, the dog-sized meat-eating predator is ‘the best dinosaur fossil Wales has ever had’

Ian Sample Science editor

20, Jan, 2016 @7:00 PM