Levelling-up grants don’t make up for cuts to regional funding | Letters

Jim Bamford says mainstream funding needs to be rebalanced; plus letters from John Marriott, Joanna Christina and Les Bright

Government spending overall is planned to be £1,182bn in 2022-23. The levelling up expenditure announced last week was just £2.1bn – less than 0.2% of that (Editorial, 18 January). It is the way that the other 99.8% is spent that has created the gross regional imbalance that so disfigures Britain’s economy. Mainstream funding has depressed the north – and other areas outside London, such as the West Country – and it is that mainstream funding that needs to be rebalanced if levelling up is ever to become real.

A good place to start would be with bus services, on which the government is overseeing terminal decline outside London just when the cost of living and climate crises demand a “London solution” (ie public control and ownership) for the whole country. And judicious spending could solve the perpetual chaos on the north’s railways, so frequently reported but rarely with solutions offered.
Jim Bamford

• I spent 30 years on various local councils, including eight years on a police authority. Over that period we seemed to spend a great deal of time and, in usually appointing consultants, a great deal of money in bidding for extra cash from central government. Rarely were we successful.

The present, back-of-a-fag-packet idea of levelling up is another example of Westminster politicians thinking they know best, tossing the odd bone from the banqueting table for the dogs below to scrap over.

Like Northern Ireland, Wales and Scotland, where the process has already begun, England needs a proper devolving of real power over taxation and decision-making to its regions, coupled with the establishment of regional assemblies. A “national parliament” in Westminster can deal with matters such as foreign affairs, defence, immigration, currency etc. Welcome to a federal UK.
John Marriott
North Hykeham, Lincolnshire

• One of the benefits of lockdown was the sudden global access via Zoom to London-based events and discussions from which we residents of the north of England are usually excluded. Sadly, now that the Covid threat has “passed”, this manifestation of levelling up has been unequalled down.
Joanna Christina
Hebden Bridge, West Yorkshire

• Tempting though it is to pore over the list of projects that have succeeded in securing levelling up funds, spotting real or perceived injustices in the process and outcomes, this is just a sideshow. Those who are serious about addressing the decline of communities should challenge the determined policy of undermining local authorities that has led to central government funding of local services being reduced by about 40% over the past dozen years.

Photogenic projects providing opportunities for ministers to cut ribbons or affix plaques are poor substitutes for the cuts that have closed libraries, mothballed leisure centres, left potholes unfilled and reduced care for frail and vulnerable people.
Les Bright

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Want levelling up? Stop running everything from London | Letters
Letters: Nicholas Falk recommends the German model of devolving financial powers to cities and regions. Plus letters from Sushila Dhall and Kim Loader

05, Feb, 2023 @5:30 PM

Article image
We’ve had so many reports on inequality – now act | Letters
Letters: Chris Grover says austerity policies are even more punishing than the workhouse, John Veit-Wilson on social security for everyone, Jack Czauderna on so many reports, Dr David Alderson on why he won’t vote for the Lib Dems, and Paul Nicolson et al on the inequality between renters and landlords or landowners


22, May, 2019 @4:51 PM

Article image
It’s time we got real about ‘levelling up’ | Letters
Letters: Dariel Francis and Glen Reid challenge a letter from Tim Worstall of the Adam Smith Institute about inequality and wealth redistribution


14, Feb, 2020 @5:25 PM

Article image
The proletarianisation of Britain’s middle class and how to reverse it | Letters
Letters: Much of the middle class used to enjoy relative autonomy but now they are treated as automatons, says Pete Dorey, while Roger Brown says the real culprit is financialisation


06, May, 2019 @4:54 PM

Article image
Property, pay and regional power could be the keys to ‘levelling up’ | Letters
Letters: Sheila Preston addresses property prices and pay levels, Roger Read makes a case for regional governance, Peter D Hogg suggests moving Eton College to Hartlepool, while Marilyn Hall hopes to see the end of grammar schools


08, Oct, 2021 @5:17 PM

Article image
HS2’s friends in the north should take a closer look | Letters
Letters: Prof Paul Salveson supports high-speed rail but does not believe the scheme represents value for money, Andrew Pendleton says it will deepen the existing regional divide, while John O’Dwyer thinks it is the wrong business model


24, Mar, 2019 @6:22 PM

Article image
The Southampton perspective on inequality in the UK | Letters
Letters: Adam Wheeler points out that deprivation is not limited to the north, while Geoffrey Wheatcroft thinks the Guardian should return to its Mancunian roots


02, Mar, 2020 @5:32 PM

Article image
The questionable legacy of Theresa May | Letters
Letters: Allegra Madgwick challenges the idea that the prime minister is a feminist champion, Hester Doherty questions how she stood up for domestic abuse victims, and Judy Stober thinks we are too kind. Plus letters from Les Bright, Mark Lewinski, Kip Bennett and Tony Cole


19, Jul, 2019 @4:26 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on levelling up: a serious project meets a deeply unserious PM | Editorial
Editorial: Boris Johnson claims he is spreading wealth beyond London. MPs say he is gambling with taxpayers’ money


08, Jun, 2022 @5:59 PM

Article image
Change taxation to build a better society | Letters
Letters: Readers including Caroline Lucas and Ruth Lister respond to Guardian articles by Owen Jones and Gaby Hinsliff


18, Feb, 2018 @5:20 PM