Liz Truss admits cutting 45p tax rate was ‘perhaps a bridge too far’

Former PM insists, however, that it is unfair to blame actions she took in office for rising mortgage rates

Liz Truss has admitted cutting the 45p tax rate was “perhaps a bridge too far” but said it was not fair to blame her mini-budget on rising mortgage rates.

The former prime minister said she did not regret her time in No 10, and that she hoped to stay in the political arena making the case for low taxes and growth within the Conservative party.

In an interview with the Spectator, Truss said she did not believe rising mortgage rates were the result of actions she took as prime minister. “I don’t think it’s fair to blame interest rises on what we did,” she said. “I think that’s unfair. On the UK factors, I believe there were other factors apart from the mini-budget.”

Truss said she had decided to make a series of interventions because she did not see anyone high profile in the party making the same arguments. The Sunday Telegraph published a 4,000 word essay she wrote justifying her choices as prime minister and she is expected to also speak at a conference in Japan on the UK’s role in standing up to China.

“I would be more than delighted to have other people go out there and make the case,” she told the Spectator. “But the fact is there aren’t enough people making the case, full stop. And I believe that I’ve learnt a lot in my time in government, I understand what some of the pitfalls are, I’ve been through the mill on this.

“I definitely want to be part of promoting a pro-growth agenda. I definitely want to carry on as an MP. I’m positive about the future of Britain and I’m positive about the future of the Conservative party. I think we need to start building more of a strong intellectual base. But I’m not desperate to get back into No 10, no.”

Truss said she had been right to cut taxes for the wealthiest as a way of signalling a new direction for the British economy, but that the Conservative party had failed to make the case historically, which meant she came up against too much opposition.

“I think economically it was absolutely the right thing to do … perhaps I underestimated the political impact it had,” she said.

“We could all think different things with hindsight, and perhaps it was a bridge too far, but I’m not convinced that it was a magic bullet, that everything would have been fine if we hadn’t done that, because I thought it was quite significant that after there were more market wobbles and we reversed the 45p tax decision relatively soon, we were essentially forced to reverse the position on corporation tax.

“Was I trying to fatten the pig on market day? Maybe. There’s a long history of failing to make the case, and that’s what I’m thinking now. I’m thinking: how can we make that argument?”

Truss suggested she might have survived the turmoil or made different decisions in office had she been warned about the vulnerability of UK pension funds and liability-driven investments. But she rejected the suggestion that the sacking of the Treasury permanent secretary, Sir Tom Scholar, was the reason she did not receive the fullest advice.

“People said ‘why aren’t you communicating?’ But the fact is we didn’t know about the issue. We didn’t necessarily understand the issue, and that is a difficult position to be in as PM and chancellor,” she said.

“What we didn’t understand is the fragility caused by these liability-driven investments – and essentially what it meant was that small movements or rapid movements in the market could result in cash calls happening and essentially a chain reaction.

“I didn’t know the existence of LDIs, which turned out to be the main problem the following week … Our assumption was that we’d worked out these plans with Treasury officials. That, if there had been a major problem, it would have been flagged to us, yes.”

On whether Scholar’s sacking was part of the issue, she said: “I’m sure we’re not saying that there’s only one person at the Treasury who knows what’s going on. That doesn’t seem credible to me.”


Jessica Elgot

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Tories pile pressure on Truss and Kwarteng to reverse tax-cutting plan
MPs say financial measures have been disaster for Conservative party as pound tumbles again

Pippa Crerar Political editor

28, Sep, 2022 @1:29 PM

Article image
Liz Truss abandons plan to scrap 45p top rate of income tax amid Tory revolt
Government makes U-turn over proposal to abolish top-rate tax cut after growing backlash over mini-budget

Peter Walker and Virginia Harrison

03, Oct, 2022 @8:18 AM

Article image
Michael Gove tells Liz Truss that cutting tax for highest earners is wrong – as it happened
Latest updates: Michael Gove says Truss should abandon plan to scrap 45% top rate of tax as large crowds protest in Birmingham

Andrew Sparrow

02, Oct, 2022 @6:32 PM

Article image
Truss poised to plunge UK economy into ‘inflation spiral’, says Sunak
Truss cannot deliver £50bn tax cuts and support packages without pushing debt to dangerous levels, says Tory leadership rival

Tobi Thomas and Rowena Mason

22, Aug, 2022 @7:50 AM

Article image
Tax U-turn wins Truss some time but damage to credibility remains
PM said she was prepared to make unpopular decisions – but then buckled, so now she will be seen as both unpopular and wrong

Pippa Crerar Political editor

03, Oct, 2022 @6:18 PM

Article image
Truss says she has ‘right plan’ on economy and will not change course
In series of local BBC interviews, prime minister says she is prepared to make difficult decisions

Peter Walker and Pippa Crerar

29, Sep, 2022 @12:13 PM

Article image
Rishi Sunak attacks Truss tax cut plan after big interest rate rise
Chancellor Nadhim Zahawi said to be on holiday as Bank of England adds to dire economic outlook

Heather Stewart, Aubrey Allegretti and Jessica Elgot

04, Aug, 2022 @3:07 PM

Article image
Truss has discredited high-octane, free-market economics – perhaps for ever
Trussonomics, and Brexitism, have proven the dangers of trying to turn rightwing ideology into reality

Jonathan Freedland

20, Oct, 2022 @3:54 PM

Article image
Liz Truss says she didn’t get ‘realistic chance’ to enact tax-cutting agenda
Former PM writes that ‘powerful economic establishment’ and lack of party support contributed to her downfall

Tom Ambrose and Nadeem Badshah

04, Feb, 2023 @10:31 PM

Article image
Hunt rips up almost all of mini-budget and scales back energy help
New chancellor scraps virtually all tax cuts, leaving PM Liz Truss humiliated and imperilled

Peter Walker Political correspondent

17, Oct, 2022 @12:09 PM