Head of UK lobbying watchdog calls for tougher disclosure rules

Exclusive: Harry Rich says transparency would be easier if lobbyists reveal which ministers they speak to

The head of the UK’s lobbying watchdog has called for tougher disclosure rules to show which ministers have been solicited, as well as a review of exemptions made use of by David Cameron and Philip Hammond.

Harry Rich, who is in charge of the register of consultant lobbyists and their clients, said it would “significantly assist transparency” if lobbyists were asked to reveal which ministers and permanent secretaries they had spoken to – as well as when, how and what about.

He also told the Guardian that it would “definitely enhance transparency” if contact between consultant lobbyists and special advisers was brought under the regime. “The more transparency there is, the more the aims of the legislation are being upheld,” he said.

Rich is making suggestions for more transparent lobbying declarations in a submission to parliament’s public administration and constitutional affairs committee (Pacac) in his first public intervention on the subject since taking the job in 2018.

In the submission, he suggests declarations include which minister or permanent secretary was lobbied, dates of the communications, medium of communication – whether by meeting, letter or email, phone, text – and topics of communication. “The fact that the targets of lobbying activity are not identified on the register feels like a significant gap,” it says.

At the moment, Rich’s staff enforce compliance partly by having to spend time cross-checking between information provided to them by lobbyists and incomplete, patchy information that appears on the government’s records of ministerial meetings.

“It is quite tricky to do given the thinness of the information but also the difference in the two lots of information,” he said. “My interest has to be principally the register and it’s based on my four years of experience in the job and knowing it would make compliance a lot easier. As far as ministerial published data is confirmed, that is not part of my remit. But I can say that if that data was more timely, more full and more complete, that would make compliance work from my side a lot easier.”

The Guardian recently revealed huge and inexplicable differences in ministerial meetings disclosed by different departments, with Liz Truss declaring just two meetings as foreign secretary in a three-month period, compared with 51 by the Welsh secretary.

Rich also suggested that ministers could look again at the exemptions that allow lobbyists not to register under the current system, although changes could require primary legislation.

The role of registrar of consultant lobbyists was created by legislation in 2014 to shine a light on the activities of lobbying. The watchdog recently provisionally found that former Conservative MP Owen Paterson broke transparency rules by failing to register as a lobbyist for Randox, a healthcare firm. Paterson could face a fine of £7,500 but he has an opportunity to appeal.

However, a series of loopholes has allowed senior politicians lobbying on behalf of companies to argue successfully that they are not covered by the legislation. Those not caught by the act include any person or company not VAT registered, therefore foreign firms, any in-house lobbyists and anyone for whom lobbying is “incidental” to their main business are not covered.

“You can do quite a lot of lobbying work for £85,00 and more significantly it exempts foreign businesses from registration under the act,” Rich said.

Both the in-house exemption and the “incidental” exemption were used successfully by former prime minister David Cameron to argue that his lobbying activity for Greensill was not covered by the legislation. Philip Hammond, a former chancellor, was also able to use the incidental exemption to argue that he had not engaged in consultant lobbying activity for OakNorth Bank.

Had the incidental exemption not applied, Hammond’s email to Charles Roxburgh, second permanent secretary at the Treasury, to promote software developed by OakNorth would have been an act of consultant lobbying and therefore a registrable communication.

On the incidental exemption, Rich’s submission said “the policy intention and the meaning of this provision are unclear and it is the most contentious, vague and problematic drafting in the legislation”.

He added: “I have no particular views on the policy intention. But nobody actually knows what it was meant to do and should do. I think whichever direction it goes in it would be helpful if it was clear what was intended.”

He said he believed the office of the registrar was doing its job “well and within the confines of the law in front of us”, having achieved an increase in the number of businesses registered as consultant lobbyists from about 150 to 194 in the last year.

A Cabinet Office spokesperson said: “We have committed to undertaking post-legislative scrutiny of the Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Act 2014 which governs the consultant lobbying regime.

“We will provide a response to the Pacac call for evidence in due course.”


Rowena Mason Whitehall editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Labour dismisses Tory claim of ‘robust’ lobbying rules
‘Cosy relationship’ between government and lobbyists ‘stinks of sleaze’, says Rachel Reeves

Andrew Sparrow Political correspondent

18, Apr, 2021 @2:05 PM

Article image
Greensill lobbying scandal: the full list of inquiries
David Cameron and Rishi Sunak could give evidence as slew of investigations ordered into failed supply chain firm

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor and Peter Walker

16, Apr, 2021 @12:12 PM

Article image
David Cameron breaks 30-day silence over lobbying for Greensill
Ex-PM says he acted within rules but admits there are ‘important lessons’ to be learned

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

11, Apr, 2021 @5:46 PM

Article image
What is the Greensill lobbying scandal and who is involved?
From an Australian financier to David Cameron, here are the key elements in the controversy so far

Peter Walker Political correspondent

14, Apr, 2021 @2:34 PM

Article image
UK ministers may face five-year lobbying ban after leaving office
Anti-corruption watchdog demands overhaul in wake of David Cameron Greensill scandal

Rajeev Syal

14, Jun, 2021 @12:29 PM

Article image
How David Cameron got caught up in a classic lobbying scandal
The Greensill Capital affair is the exact type of lobbying row that the ex-PM warned about and vowed to eradicate

Rupert Neate Wealth correspondent

31, Mar, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on lobbying: say yes to tougher rules | Editorial
Editorial: Public trust is damaged when a former PM and ministers are caught up in a cronyism scandal, and must be repaired


14, Jun, 2021 @6:11 PM

Article image
Greensill review calls for lobbying transparency and new code of conduct
Report launched in response to David Cameron’s lobbying suggests ministers curb supply chain finance

Kalyeena Makortoff Banking correspondent

16, Sep, 2021 @7:23 PM

Article image
Role call: the former ministers who found private sector jobs
The Greensill affair shows how some of David Cameron’s appointees have been among the most enthusiastic corporate jobseekers. Here’s the list...

Rob Davies and Georgina Quach

16, Apr, 2021 @3:15 PM

Article image
NHS England chair faces demands to explain role in Greensill lobbying
Calls for clarity about Lord Prior’s involvement with Greensill as former PM David Cameron is under fire

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

18, Apr, 2021 @7:21 PM