Sunak searches for Tory compromise over onshore windfarm U-turn

PM is stuck between two wings of party and at risk of Commons defeat on pro-renewables amendment

Rishi Sunak is scrambling to find a compromise on permitting onshore wind amid a growing backbench Conservative rebellion, though No 10 remains fearful of a backlash from MPs who oppose windfarms.

The U-turn on backing onshore wind projects would directly contradict a pledge by Sunak during his leadership campaign but Downing Street has sought to frame it as government policy.

The government all but confirmed on Monday that restrictions on onshore wind would be changed in the face of the rebellion, but the row has left Sunak squeezed between two wings of the party – with a growing number of MPs also using the levelling up bill to try to put the brakes on development.

Labour is also tabling a new beefed-up amendment on onshore wind, highlighting the limitations of the Conservative rebel amendment, which has been drafted by the former cabinet minister Simon Clarke and backed by Boris Johnson and Liz Truss.

The Guardian understands that the former chief whip Wendy Morton has signed the amendment, bringing the total number of potential rebels to 34 – which would evaporate Sunak’s majority.

The full Labour amendment, tabled on Monday night and seen by the Guardian, would remove the onerous planning restrictions that effectively ban new onshore wind in England but also require local authorities to proactively identify opportunities for renewables, including onshore wind generation.

Labour will back Clarke’s amendment – putting Sunak at risk of Commons defeat – but said it was not enough to ensure real growth of onshore wind.

Matthew Pennycook, the shadow housing minister, said: “Rishi Sunak is now being dragged into an inevitable U-turn by his backbenchers and, while it’s better than nothing, the Clarke amendment still leaves Britain hobbled in the race for renewables.

“Because, while ending the ban, it imposes a uniquely restrictive planning regime for onshore wind that risks blocking sensible schemes, keeping bills high, and missing out on the next generation of high-skilled jobs. Under this government, we’re forced to move only at the pace of the slowest Tory backbencher.”

Clarke is understood to have told Conservative backbenchers that his amendment was also a “community consent” safeguard against a future Labour government, which would be likely to make it easier for local authorities to build windfarms.

“His argument is, either we do it or Labour do it in future, without this lock,” one supportive MP said.

On Monday, the business and energy secretary, Grant Shapps, said there would be more onshore wind projects “where communities are in favour of it”, which would mean the end of a de facto block on such projects since 2014 under planning rules.

Shapps told Sky News: “We already have quite a lot of onshore wind. There will be more, over time, particularly where communities are in favour of it. That is, I think, the key test of onshore wind: is it of benefit to communities locally? That has always been the principle for us, for quite some time now.”

Pushed again on whether this was an enforced change of stance, Shapps said: “No, it’s exactly what we’ve said all along. Rishi Sunak said the other week that where onshore happens, it needs to have local agreement.”

Shapps said incorrectly that Sunak had “always” argued that onshore wind could happen with local consent, adding: “To present it as some sort of massive gulf is completely untrue.”

No 10 pulled a planned vote on the bill this week in the face of the rebellion on housing targets – which is separately putting the government under pressure. The added problem of Clarke’s amendment means the bill is likely to be further delayed.

Labour’s amendment, which the Conservative rebels are unlikely to back, has been drafted with the Green Alliance and the Town and Country Planning Association, who have also put forward suggestions to Clarke about gaps in his amendment.

Chris Venables, the head of politics at Green Alliance, said of Clarke’s amendment: “It’s not perfect as it is a campaigning amendment. The second part needs to put in place measures that ensure the planning system does genuinely shift it forward.”

A new poll on Monday from the thinktank Compassion in Politics found 72% of Conservative voters supported the building of more windfarms. Overall when asked which source of energy they would prefer to see boosted in the UK, three-quarters said they would support onshore wind.


Jessica Elgot, Peter Walker and Helena Horton

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sunak set to end ban on new onshore windfarms in face of Tory rebellion
Deal reached that paves way for communities in England to authorise projects without unanimous support

Aubrey Allegretti and Helena Horton

06, Dec, 2022 @7:31 PM

Article image
Johnson and Truss join rebels against Sunak keeping new onshore wind ban
About 20 Conservative MPs want to end longstanding de facto block on new wind farms in England

Peter Walker and Jessica Elgot

24, Nov, 2022 @7:13 PM

Article image
Former Tory chair joins rebellion over Sunak’s onshore windfarm ban
Jake Berry is latest senior MP to urge prime minister to amend de facto block on new projects in England

Pippa Crerar Political editor

27, Nov, 2022 @1:33 PM

Article image
Labour would ditch Tory ban on new onshore windfarms, says Starmer
Exclusive: Leader says easing planning curbs would be part of its plan to tap economic potential of wind power

Pippa Crerar Political editor

10, Nov, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Sunak accused of ‘economic illiteracy’ over pledge to block onshore windfarms
Tory leadership candidate’s ‘energy sovereignty strategy’ also attacked for lack of focus on climate crisis

Peter Walker Political correspondent

20, Jul, 2022 @10:51 AM

Article image
U-turn on onshore windfarms likely after Tory rebellion
Culture secretary says potential ‘tweaks’ to levelling up bill will be considered because to MPs’ concerns

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

29, Nov, 2022 @10:35 AM

Article image
Planning rules for new onshore windfarms likely to be eased in UK
Wind could be more productive way than fracking to boost electricity supplies and bring down prices

Rowena Mason Deputy political editor

23, Sep, 2022 @12:25 PM

Article image
Tory plan to limit onshore windfarms will raise energy bills, engineers warn
Royal Academy of Engineering report shows replacing onshore turbines with offshore wind would add extra cost to bills

Damian Carrington

10, Apr, 2014 @5:00 AM

Article image
Conservatives to promise ban on new onshore windfarms
Manifesto will focus on solar power and offshore wind instead in attempt to show Cameron is not abandoning green agenda

Nicholas Watt, chief political correspondent

04, Apr, 2014 @6:16 PM

Article image
Sunak’s stop-start policies harming UK green investment, says net zero tsar
Exclusive: Lack of confidence in ‘inconsistent’ government is huge barrier to investors, finds Chris Skidmore

Helena Horton and Fiona Harvey

12, Jan, 2023 @4:32 PM