Sue Gray report: five unanswered questions about No 10 parties

Outstanding issues include event in Downing Street flat and Boris Johnson’s seeming lack of awareness

After almost six months of media reports, a police investigation and a two-part civil service inquiry, Downing Street hopes Sue Gray’s report has closed the book on the saga of lockdown-breaking parties in No 10. But Gray’s 60 pages of findings leave several questions unanswered:

Why did Gray not investigate the Downing Street flat event?

This is, more specifically, two questions. The first is what happened on the evening of 13 November 2020, after the departure of key aides Dominic Cummings and Lee Cain, when Boris Johnson, his wife, Carrie, and others decamped to the Downing Street flat, where food and alcohol was consumed. No 10 says this was a work meeting, others argue it was clearly a party. The full truth is not known.

That leads to the second issue: why Gray chose not to look into the flat gathering. In her report, she said this was because, first, the Metropolitan police examined it, and then, it was “not appropriate or proportionate” for her to investigate further. This does not seem to make sense given Gray did look into other events investigated by the Met, prompting concerns Downing Street may have leant on her.

How did Johnson not know what was happening?

This is less of a question for Gray than one that necessarily follows from her report. As well as the extent of lockdown socialising – 15 events on eight dates – there is also the issue of the scale and premeditation. For the “bring your own booze” garden party on 20 May 2020, organised by Johnson’s then principal private secretary, Martin Reynolds, invitations were sent to about 200 staff. Johnson turned up to that and was present at seven other events detailed in the report. The prime minister’s defence that he either did not see what was happening, or else attended but did not think it was a social event, feels implausible.

Sign up to First Edition, our free daily newsletter – every weekday morning at 7am BST

How did Johnson get away with one fine?

This was a question already raised at the end of the Met police inquiry last week, when Johnson received a fixed-penalty notice for the gathering on his birthday in June 2020, but not for other events he attended, for which others were penalised. But Gray’s report, with its pages of detail about drunken staff, spilled wine, karaoke machines and inebriated scuffles, sets out a wider context of apparent mass illegality. The Met agreed, issuing 126 penalty notices. How Johnson escaped with one remains a mystery.

How much leeway did Gray have in compiling her report?

While the inquiry was repeatedly billed by ministers as independent, Gray is a Cabinet Office civil servant ultimately managed by Simon Case, the cabinet secretary, among those named in the report, and then Johnson. As well as the implicit pressure on her to pull punches, questions remain about a meeting No 10 arranged between Johnson and Gray earlier this month, and whether pressure from Downing Street led to any scrutiny of the flat party being dropped.

How is Martin Reynolds still in a job?

The man now known to the nation as “Party Marty” is no longer principal private secretary. He works at the Foreign Office and is reported to be in line to become ambassador to Saudi Arabia – a place where organising “bring your own booze” parties would bring extra challenges. This is, however, a man mentioned 24 times in Gray’s report, who exchanged repeated messages about organising social gatherings despite warnings from other staff, remarking after one that we “seem to have got away” with it. It is fair to say that in most other settings, disciplinary proceedings would be well under way.


Peter Walker Political correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sue Gray report: full breakdown of findings about No 10 parties
Detailed summary of civil servant’s report into lockdown-breaching parties in and around Downing Street

Peter Walker Political correspondent

25, May, 2022 @12:08 PM

Article image
Sue Gray prepares to publish final Downing St lockdown parties report
Deadline passes for individuals named in findings to object as mixed accounts emerge of Gray’s meeting with Boris Johnson

Heather Stewart Political editor

22, May, 2022 @9:06 AM

Article image
Why is Sue Gray report on No 10 parties taking so long?
Boris Johnson’s premiership hangs on civil servant’s findings but contents remain a mystery

Aubrey Allegretti Political correspondent

27, Jan, 2022 @12:58 PM

Article image
Questions still to be answered after release of Sue Gray report
Analysis: who was responsible for the failures of judgment, and is the ‘work event’ excuse considered plausible?

Jessica Elgot

31, Jan, 2022 @5:04 PM

Article image
‘Disgraceful’: voters in key byelection seats respond to Sue Gray report
Partygate revelations greeted with anger in Wakefield and in Tiverton and Honiton, where Tories face election tests

Josh Halliday and Steven Morris

25, May, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Dominic Raab refuses to confirm full publication of Sue Gray partygate report
Deputy PM promises ‘full transparency’ but says it is for Boris Johnson to decide how much detail is released to the public

Peter Walker and Heather Stewart

23, Jan, 2022 @6:41 PM

Article image
Minister disputes claims No 10 pushed Sue Gray to dilute Partygate report
Brandon Lewis ‘confident’ investigation was independent and she was not lobbied to alter details

Aubrey Allegretti

29, May, 2022 @11:03 AM

Article image
‘In the balance’: divided Tories weigh up PM’s position before Sue Gray report
Rival camps attempt to shore up support in crunch hours before senior civil servant delivers findings on alleged No 10 parties

Aubrey Allegretti Political correspondent

25, Jan, 2022 @8:23 PM

Article image
Joe Lycett says Sue Gray report stunt motivated by anger over friend’s death
Comedian tweeting fake version of civil servant’s ‘partygate’ report purportedly caused panic in No 10

Caroline Davies

28, Jan, 2022 @5:44 PM

Article image
Sue Gray report to be completed by end of May at earliest, sources say
Senior civil servant expected to be critical of Boris Johnson when findings about Westminster lockdown parties are published

Aubrey Allegretti and Rowena Mason

26, Apr, 2022 @5:00 AM