UK must accept border on Irish Sea is inevitable, says ex-WTO chief

Pascal Lamy says row is solvable if PM stops using emotional Brexit politics to solve ‘technical problem’

Boris Johnson’s row with the EU over Northern Ireland’s Brexit arrangements is “absolutely solvable” but only if the UK accepts that a border is inevitable, the former head of the World Trade Organization has said.

But Pascal Lamy said the prime minister could only achieve a breakthrough if he stopped mixing “oil and vinegar” and throwing emotional Brexit politics on to what he said was essentially a technical problem.

Lamy said he did not understand the UK’s strategy, which risked a trade war with the EU, but added that it was unlikely to come to this as the “cost-benefit ratio” was “ridiculous”.

If matters did deteriorate and the EU retaliated with sanctions, the bloc would win as those with greatest capacity for trade generally did, Lamy said.

His comments, in an interview with the Guardian, came after the British foreign secretary, Liz Truss, threatened new laws to allow the UK to change some of the Northern Ireland protocol. The UK government has come under pressure from the Democratic Unionist party and the Traditional Unionist Voice, both of whom campaigned on an anti-protocol ticket in the recent Northern Ireland assembly elections.

Lamy, who has followed Brexit closely over the past seven years, and who is now president of the Paris Peace Forum, a French non-profit organisation, after leaving the WTO in 2013, said demands to remove the border in the Irish Sea completely would never deliver a breakthrough.

“I don’t understand exactly what they [the UK] are after,” he said. “If it is no border it won’t work. You cannot leave the EU and not have a border. That’s just having your cake and eating it.

“So there is a question mark as to what exactly is the problem on the UK side. If it is ‘we don’t want a border’ then it is like saying: ‘We don’t want Brexit.’ Then this is unsolvable.”

Lamy continued: “The UK government has this capacity to mix problems and to cook a political soup.

“These are oil and vinegar issues between emotion and technicalities. Emotion is extremely high because Boris Johnson keeps beating the drum to say Brexit is a great thing. He has to increase the sound of the drum to say Brexit is a great thing all the time.”

If the UK admitted a border was the direct consequence of Brexit, then a solution could be found, Lamy said.

There could be a dynamic solution for Northern Ireland, he suggested. This would involve a “thin border” with few checks on trade across the Irish Sea while the UK remained aligned to EU standards. This would become a “thick border” if the UK wanted to diverge from those standards, Lamy added.

This solution would require equivalence in standards with the EU and has already been rejected by the UK as unacceptable because it would compromise the country’s control of its own laws.

Lamy said this went to the core issue of borders between nations and always involve tradeoffs.

“The UK are torn between their political position, which is they want to have the capacity to diverge [on standards], and the technical consequence of that, which is a thicker border,” he said.

The only way to solve the issue was to “dial down the emotion” and “let the technicians find the solution that allows both sides to find a midway between a thick and a thin border”.

Given the border between the UK and the EU was not negotiable, the UK’s best shot at a solution was to “play for time, as you can’t play with money”, Lamy said.

Solutions included trusted trader schemes that would would “transport the border up the value chain” and light-touch checks at ports.

“Customs officers only have a limited amount of time in the day. It’s about finding a compromise between ensuring control on one side and trade to flow on the other,” Lamy said.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

He played down the UK’s threat to legislate to “disapply” some of the protocol if the EU did not concede to Johnson’s demands, saying he found it difficult to believe the UK and the EU would end up in a trade war.

“If there was one, the EU would win as generally the one that has the largest trade capacity prevails,” Lamy said.

With war in the Ukraine and Sweden and Finland making the momentous decisions to join Nato, Brexit was an “irritant” to EU leaders, he added.

Contributor

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Business chief calls on PM to save north-east from Brexit damage
James Ramsbotham, CEO of North East England Chamber of Commerce, says letter sent to Boris Johnson remains unanswered

Phillip Inman

08, Aug, 2021 @11:01 PM

Article image
Northern Ireland manufacturers say Brexit protocol least of worries – survey
Top concern is labour shortages as 28% of manufacturers say trade with EU has increased

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

14, Jan, 2022 @9:21 AM

Article image
Dover health authority says inland border facility will be ‘open door for disease’
Sevington site was never designed to handle volume of imports envisaged by post-Brexit changes due in April, port’s health chief warns

Jack Simpson

27, Mar, 2024 @6:41 PM

Article image
Brexit will not save troubled steel industry, says trade body
UK Steel’s director general warns leaving EU will not give steel greater trading opportunities

Rob Davies

26, May, 2019 @2:02 PM

Article image
Brussels nearing impasse with May over Irish border proposal
Plan to use technology and trusted trader scheme to avoid hard border not accepted by UK

Daniel Boffey in Brussels

17, Sep, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Technology cannot make post-Brexit Irish border frictionless, says academic
Analysis of various Brexit outcomes concludes some check and stops will be necessary

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

07, Mar, 2018 @2:34 PM

Article image
UK accused of 'magical thinking' over Brexit plan for Irish border
Britain’s call for ‘flexible solutions’ as it pursues goal of avoiding border posts with Ireland leaves EU officials rolling their eyes

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

25, Aug, 2017 @6:03 PM

Article image
Britons buying from EU websites hit with £100 customs bills
Parcel firms demanding payment before delivering items ordered from European websites since Brexit

Miles Brignall

21, Jan, 2021 @12:54 PM

Article image
Brexit: Varadkar and May to work on plan for frictionless Irish border
Leaders of Ireland and UK seek deal that does not need Northern Ireland to be in single market

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

12, Feb, 2018 @7:31 PM

Article image
One upshot of Brexit Johnson didn’t foresee: bringing the Irish closer
Trade between Northern Ireland and the Republic has soared this year, while life for British exporters looks set to get grimmer

22, Aug, 2021 @6:00 AM