MPs should not bring babies into Commons, says cross-party review

The review into the rules was ordered by Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle in November

MPs should not be allowed to bring babies into the House of Commons chamber during debates, a cross-party review has recommended after mounting “confusion” about the rules.

The procedure committee report was ordered amid an outcry over Labour backbencher Stella Creasy being told she could no longer bring her newborn son while making statements or asking questions in parliament.

The group ruled that MPs should not bring babies into the chamber or nearby Westminster Hall if they wanted to “observe, initiate, speak or intervene in proceedings”.

Sign up to First Edition, our free daily newsletter – every weekday morning at 7am BST

But they said there should be a “degree of de-facto discretion” that “should be exercised sparingly”. Creasy said this was not enough and railed at the “antiquated” rule remaining in place.

The committee did, however, back the extension of proxy voting for “serious long-term illness”.

The review into the rules was ordered by Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle in November after Creasy was told she could no longer bring her son Pip, then three months old, with her into the chamber.

The mother of two, who represents Walthamstow in London, hoped the review would allow “parenting and politics to mix”.

Creasy was shocked when the Commons authorities emailed her rules prohibiting bringing children to debates after she took Pip into Westminster Hall.

MPs described the boy as “as good as gold” during the debate.

But the committee’s report said it was a “longstanding practice” underpinned by previous rulings that “babies should not be present” during debates and question times.

They noted there had been “several occasions” when MPs had brought babies into debates “without disruption”, but this had “contributed to some confusion and a gap” between the practice and the rules.

Many MPs were supportive of Ms Creasy, with deputy prime minister Dominic Raab saying he had “a lot of sympathy” for her and that he would not be distracted by a baby. But Tory backbencher Alicia Kearns argued the chamber was “no place” for a baby.

Creasy said that she was “not surprised” by the recommendation because the committee “didn’t speak to a single person outside parliament despite many of us encouraging them to do so”.

“They don’t recognise who is put off parliament by its antiquated rules and approach to women who have children and the need to modernise,” she added.

“They are not alone in working like this – in the last year we’ve seen no progress on parliament having any form of adequate maternity or paternity policy in place, and no progress from IPSA [the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority] on providing proper maternity or paternity funding either.

“Change will only come when we start listening to those outside the status quo.”


Aubrey Allegretti

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Stella Creasy: MPs' standards authority does not recognise maternity leave
Expectant Labour MP reveals previous miscarriages and says she is forced to ‘choose between being a mum and MP’

Jessica Elgot

17, Jun, 2019 @5:17 PM

Article image
Speaker announces review on bringing babies into Commons
Stella Creasy asked for clarification after she was reprimanded for having infant son with her in parliament

Jessica Elgot, Peter Walker and Alexandra Topping

24, Nov, 2021 @1:07 PM

Article image
Allowing babies in the Commons would humanise it | Letters
Letters: Rachel Phipps says we need to create a society where mothers with babies are welcomed not excluded. Plus letters from Martin Cooper and Jack Winter


30, Jun, 2022 @4:46 PM

Article image
Stella Creasy launches campaign to get more mothers into politics
Walthamstow MP says she is ‘heartbroken’ by lack of support from Labour over calls for maternity cover

Rowena Mason

31, Oct, 2021 @1:19 PM

Article image
Stella Creasy on her lonely maternity cover battle: ‘Women should be able to have kids and do politics’
The Labour politician is used to fighting battles – but can she win her latest: convincing her colleagues to back proper maternity cover for fellow members?

Gaby Hinsliff

30, Oct, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
MPs pass 'long overdue' bill for ministers' paid maternity leave
Government says it will bring forward more protections amid accusations of double standards

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

11, Feb, 2021 @6:17 PM

Article image
Stella Creasy criticises ‘absurdity’ of parliament’s approach to new mothers
Labour MPs comments come after Sir Lindsay Hoyle said it was up to chair of each debate to decide if MPs could bring in babies

Tom Ambrose and Rowena Mason

28, Dec, 2021 @3:29 PM

Article image
Senior Tories rally in support of pregnant MP Stella Creasy
Walthamstow MP says she had to ‘beg’ for help as there is no maternity leave in parliament

Peter Walker and Jessica Elgot

18, Jun, 2019 @12:38 PM

Article image
Stella Creasy surprised after reprimand for bringing infant into Commons
Walthamstow MP seeks parliamentary rule clarification having previously sat with her son without censure

Peter Walker Political correspondent

24, Nov, 2021 @10:20 AM

Article image
Labour MP Stella Creasy threatens legal action over maternity leave for top ministers
Exclusive: Stella Creasy threatens action against plans to give cabinet ministers more rights

Jessica Elgot and Alexandra Topping

10, Feb, 2021 @8:30 PM