U-turns, dodging scrutiny: does Liz Truss share Boris Johnson’s bad habits?

Analysis: Truss has shown a Johnson-like tendency to rush into new policies and be vague or inaccurate with facts

It is perhaps fair to say Tory MPs have mixed feelings about ousting Boris Johnson. The parliamentary party moved decisively against him, only to then spend weeks lamenting the departure of a man who won them an 80-seat majority. Now some fear they are about to replace him with Johnson Mark 2 – but one who shares only his negative characteristics.

While Liz Truss has improved as a campaigner since the leadership race began, not even her diehard fans would put her on a par with Johnson, whose unlikely fusion of baffled bonhomie, deflection through humour and big-state populism helped bring victory in 2019.

Truss’s appeal to Tory members is based on a very different combination of low-tax orthodoxy and the promise of a “straight-talking Yorkshirewoman” who knows precisely what she wants. Her approach to the job would undoubtedly be very different, with former colleagues of the foreign secretary agreeing she is ferociously hard-working and disciplined.

But the longer the contest has gone on, the more observers have noted tendencies within Team Truss to replicate defining elements of Johnson’s No 10, particularly a rush for new policies, often borrowed from others or made up on the hoof, which then need to be amended or ditched amid loud denials of a U-turn.

Truss plays pool during a visit to a youth facility in Chelmsford this week
Truss plays pool during a visit to a youth facility in Chelmsford this week. Photograph: Getty Images

In part this is a factor of a leadership race in which candidates must court a small number of notably right-leaning Tory party members while not overly boxing themselves in, policy-wise, for the moment they enter Downing Street.

Hence the confusing scenes this week as Truss insisted that help with soaring energy bills would be based on tax cuts, while her allies quietly stressed that other help could be forthcoming, and her campaign team sought to vehemently deny any contradiction between the two competing narratives.

A more striking example came the week before, when Truss hastily dropped a loudly touted plan to save £11bn a year with a “war on Whitehall waste”, copied from a proposal by the rightwing TaxPayers’ Alliance, in which the bulk of the savings would have come from capping or reducing public sector pay outside London and the south-east.

This was particularly reminiscent of the latter, embattled period of Johnson’s premiership, where seemingly half-baked policies such as a return to imperial measurements were paraded in the press, largely derided and then forgotten.

In a more alarming facsimile of Johnson’s operation, Truss’s campaign tried to cover up the manoeuvre by falsely blaming the media for “wilful misrepresentation” of a plan that had openly stated its intention in a press release.

While Johnson is a former newspaper columnist who likes to claim comradeship with journalists, his No 10 operation has misled reporters several times, with his allies regularly castigating a supposedly biased media. At a hustings event this week, Truss mimicked this part of the Johnson playbook, saying journalists were trying to “talk our country down”.

Truss has also shown a Johnson-like tendency to be vague or even inaccurate with facts to suit her political purposes, not least her regularly told and much-debunked backstory about how the comprehensive she attended in Leeds was a failing school.

At another hustings event this week, in Cheltenham on Thursday, Truss repeated concerns about disproportionate numbers of women being jailed for not paying the TV licence fee, something factchecking groups have said does not seem to be supported by the evidence.

Another similarity has come in Truss’s avoidance of over-close scrutiny during the contest. Johnson dodged a BBC grilling by Andrew Neil, endured by his rivals, while Truss has refused the corporation’s offer of an interview with Nick Robinson, unlike Rishi Sunak, her opponent.

Of course, as any Labour members who voted for Keir Starmer based on pledges to follow a broadly Corbynite policy platform will know, leadership races and heading a party, let alone the country, are different things. But Truss’s rivals, at least, argue there is a sense of continuity.

“She truly is the heir to BoJo,” one Sunak-supporting source said. “Her team cut and paste policy, put something out in black and white, claim it’s been misinterpreted, and get Brandon [Lewis, a key ally of Johnson and now Truss] out to poop-scoop the next day.”


Peter Walker and Jessica Elgot

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Boris Johnson ducks comeback questions as he seeks to mark out legacy
Prime minister urges people to have ‘hope’ cost of living crisis will ease as he uses final week in office to highlight achievements

Aubrey Allegretti Political correspondent and Pippa Crerar Political editor

30, Aug, 2022 @3:14 PM

Article image
In Liz we Trust? Boris Johnson has made it harder for Britain to do so
Lack of faith in the office of prime minister will be among the most difficult problems the next incumbent will face

Pippa Crerar Political editor

02, Sep, 2022 @3:17 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson’s would-be successors quietly prepare their bids
Analysis: As parliament heads for recess, one MP says contenders ‘are working away in the background’

Aubrey Allegretti

11, Feb, 2022 @5:00 PM

Article image
Downing Street criticised for media absence after energy price cap rise
Labour attacks ‘dereliction of duty’ as TV and radio presenters call on members of government to respond

Matthew Weaver

26, Aug, 2022 @10:40 AM

Article image
Boasts and bitterness: how Boris Johnson’s bid to return as PM fell apart
Supporters taken aback by decision not to stand after scramble to build campaign

Rowena Mason and Aubrey Allegretti

24, Oct, 2022 @5:26 PM

Article image
Glum Sunak supporters hold out for gamechanging gaffe from Truss
With Tory members seeming to tolerate a series of missteps, the frontrunner is on course for No 10 – barring a ‘spectacular foul-up’

Rowena Mason Deputy political editor

20, Aug, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Truss has discredited high-octane, free-market economics – perhaps for ever
Trussonomics, and Brexitism, have proven the dangers of trying to turn rightwing ideology into reality

Jonathan Freedland

20, Oct, 2022 @3:54 PM

Article image
All in a day’s debacle: 24 hours that undid Liz Truss
Despite the departure of her home secretary, the PM could probably have clung on, but then came the extraordinary unforced errors

Peter Walker, Jessica Elgot and Aubrey Allegretti

20, Oct, 2022 @5:50 PM

Article image
How Liz Truss became leader of the Conservative party – a timeline
The former Lib Dem will be named as the new UK prime minister after meeting the Queen

Ben Quinn

05, Sep, 2022 @11:44 AM

Article image
Truss and Sunak woo Tory members with lukewarm stance on climate
Analysis: Neither Tory leadership hopeful seems to want to appear tough on tackling the climate emergency

Rowena Mason Deputy political editor

12, Aug, 2022 @6:05 PM