Why are Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak at odds over net zero plans?

Analysis: PM has a long list of spending plans but chancellor is concerned about borrowing

Publication of the government’s blueprint to hit net zero by 2050 has opened up a rift between Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak over spending.

The chancellor is concerned on many levels about the prime minister’s tendency to believe that “everything is for the best in the best of all possible worlds”, a phrase Voltaire used in his novel Candide to lampoon the optimists of mid-18th-century France. According to Treasury insiders, Johnson is far too sanguine about Britain’s ability to emerge from the pandemic and tackle the climate emergency without meticulous planning and careful management of the public finances.

Sunak used his Conservative party conference speech – which made no mention of the environment or net zero – to warn that excessive government borrowing and “stacking up bills for future generations to pay” was immoral.

What is Johnson asking for?

There is a long list of spending on transition arrangements to reach net zero that Johnson wants to push ahead with and is willing to put on the UK’s credit card if necessary. They range from grants to install low-carbon heat pumps to new nuclear power stations. This is not as reckless as it sounds when interest rates are at rock bottom, and economic theory says there is a huge potential return on investments in a modern infrastructure, especially when they also happen to be green.

What are those investment benefits?

It varies from one industry to the next, but commonly government can expect to get back £1.20 to £1.80 for every £1 spent when it invests in infrastructure. Of course, this multiplier effect only works if the money is invested wisely. The aim is not just to replace out-of-date equipment, buildings and technology, but do it in such a way that the people who use it are more productive without warming the planet.

How does Johnson want to invest in net zero?

Subsidies can create a market for green projects where none existed before, mainly because the upfront costs deter private companies in search of a profit. Once the market is thriving, prices tend to come down and the subsidies can be withdrawn. Later the funds can be deployed elsewhere. Sunak and Johnson agree on the need to provide subsidies and attract private investment but disagree on the amount of government cash that should be on offer and for how long.

Why is Sunak so reticent?

The Treasury is an anxious beast. It may appear arrogant, especially when resisting attempts to devolve financial decision-making away from Westminster. But it is distrustful of other Whitehall departments, which are viewed as spendthrifts lacking the financial discipline to manage complex projects. Green public transport should be the goal of any net zero strategy, but Treasury officials are known to despair of their counterparts in the transport ministry after significant cost overruns on London’s Elizabeth line, also known as Crossrail, and HS2.

Has the Treasury’s culture proved a barrier?

Treasury officials also like to avoid taking risks. Investing in the north of England, the Midlands and the south-west as part of Johnson’s levelling up plans are deemed perilously uncertain when compared with the guaranteed returns to be made in London and the south-east. The same thinking is prevalent when net zero initiatives are considered. Johnson’s record of splashing cash on friends and Conservative business contacts when the pandemic hit, much of which was wasted, has only underscored concerns about the prospect of wasteful spending if No 10 moves too quickly.

Why does Sunak say borrowing is a tax on young people?

Sunak objects to further increases in borrowing, arguing that the extra debt will need to be paid by future generations. It is a common thread running through the speeches of most free-market Conservative MPs and ignores the benefits for future generations of a less polluted, more biodiverse environment supported by green jobs. Young people will not thank today’s policymakers if a refusal to borrow limits the speed of transition.

Does that mean tax rises to fund the transition to net zero?

In a paper on Tuesday to accompany Johnson’s spending plans, Sunak said a rebalancing of the tax system would be necessary once fossil fuels begin to be phased out. Just as it would dent the exchequer if people stopped smoking or drinking alcohol, a reduction in petrol and diesel use will hit fuel duty receipts, currently worth £37bn to the Treasury. Sunak did not say where he was looking to get an alternative source of revenue, but there is no sign he will increase income tax. The road user lobby expect the chancellor to back pay-as-you-drive charges once electric cars dominate the roads.

Contributor

Phillip Inman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK public spending to top £1tn a year, thinktank forecasts
Resolution Foundation says government borrowing will rise to 40% of GDP, surpassing the Tony Blair years

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

24, Feb, 2020 @12:01 AM

Article image
Rishi Sunak and the Treasury need to think big and plan long term
The budget showed how strategic planning and investment loses out to quick fixes. A department for the economy is urgently needed

Larry Elliott

07, Mar, 2021 @11:48 AM

Article image
UK recession fears and rivalries take the shine off Rishi Sunak
The chancellor’s star rose quickly, but now ‘the richest man in the Commons’ is attracting new kinds of attention

Rupert Neate Wealth correspondent

06, Nov, 2020 @1:39 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson refuses to rule out tax rises to fund recovery plans
PM pledges to deliver manifesto pledge of ‘levelling up’ country after Covid-19 crisis

Heather Stewart Political editor Libby Brooks

30, Jun, 2020 @1:01 PM

Article image
What will be in Rishi Sunak's 2021 budget?
Expect measures to help economic recovery but watch out for capital gains tax and other tax rises

Phillip Inman and Richard Partington

27, Feb, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
New UK spending row as Rishi Sunak puts squeeze on public sector salaries
Chancellor to announce pay restraints despite huge boost being unveiled for armed forces

Richard Partington, Heather Stewart and Dan Sabbagh

20, Nov, 2020 @12:01 AM

Article image
New chancellor Rishi Sunak challenged over hedge fund past
Labour questions past City dealings citing former close associate’s participation in tax avoidance scheme

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

14, Feb, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
Johnson and Sunak urge UK pensions to back riskier investments
PM and chancellor aiming to ignite ‘investment big bang’ to fuel post-pandemic economic recovery

Phillip Inman

04, Aug, 2021 @9:30 PM

Article image
Experts sound alarm over PM's pledge to 'level up' UK economy
Boris Johnson would need two full terms as PM to fulfil election vow, says thinktank

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

06, Feb, 2020 @12:01 AM

Article image
Believe the hype – budget 2020 is very important
Chancellor Rishi Sunak needs to satisfy competing audiences, but there is a way he can do it

Larry Elliott

23, Feb, 2020 @10:47 AM