UK public warms to road pricing as fuel duty replacement considered

Almost four in 10 back road pricing to replace fuel duty and other taxes as people switch to electric cars

Road pricing is seen as a fairer possible system to raise revenue than fuel duty and motoring taxes, thinktank research has found.

The switch to electric cars means almost £30bn in fuel duty raised annually for the Treasury will need to be replaced, but politicians have shied away from introducing road pricing as an alternative.

Polling for the Social Market Foundation, however, suggests that the conventional political wisdom that voters are opposed to road pricing no longer holds true. Its research found that almost four in 10 people (38%) back road pricing to replace fuel duty and other taxes, with just over a quarter opposed (26%).

The rest were open to persuasion, the SMF said, and shared a strong public perception that fuel duty was a heavier burden than other taxes.

Fuel duty is 58p per litre of petrol or diesel in the UK. The rate has been frozen by successive Conservative chancellors for more than a decade after becoming a politically sensitive issue after protests.

The government has banned the sale of new petrol and diesel vehicles from 2030, making reform of taxes an urgent question for the Treasury.

Last month, sales of battery electric cars reached a record 33,000, about 15% of all new vehicles sold in the UK in September, including almost 7,000 Tesla Model 3s. But they remain a small fraction, however: between 1% and 2% of all cars on UK roads.

The SMF – whose research was conducted before the recent fuel crisis, when shortages of fuel at the pumps contributed to accelerating demand for electric cars – said the comparative openness to road pricing should encourage moves to find a new approach.

The research director, Scott Corfe, said: “For too long politicians have thought of reforming motoring taxes as grasping the nettle, fearful that a backlash from drivers will hit them at the polls.

“In reality, the public want to see a better, fairer system of how the UK taxes drivers. Our research shows that road pricing, often perceived as politically poisonous, is seen as a preferential option compared to our existing tax regime.”

Only a few toll roads exist in Britain, while the London congestion charge has not yet been replicated elsewhere since its introduction more than 20 years ago. The ultra-low emission zone in London expands to cover the areas up to the north and south circular roads on 25 October. Drivers whose vehicles exceed emissions standards must pay a daily charge to drive inside the zone.

Researchers found that the public remained suspicious of – and more opposed to – any system that would charge drivers by tracking their road use via a mobile app or black box.

Thinktanks have for some years urged governments to tackle the issue, while recognising that fuel duty remains the easiest way to tax motoring. The RAC Foundation has proposed a gradual move towards a charge based on distance travelled. The winner of the 2017 Wolfson Prize was a proposal for a pay-per-mile road pricing scheme, with the revenue to be collected via insurers.

The transport select committee will hold a hearing into road pricing next week, in time for Rishi Sunak’s budget on 27 October.


Gwyn Topham

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Pay-per-mile road tax plan wins £250,000 Wolfson economics prize
Prizewinner Gergely Raccuja, 27, aims to scrap vehicle tax and fuel duty to help fund road repairs with more eco-friendly scheme collected by insurers

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

13, Jul, 2017 @9:00 PM

Article image
Treasury backs electric cars but makes limited moves on diesel
Funds set aside for national charging network and technological research, but lack of scrappage scheme disappoints

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

22, Nov, 2017 @5:30 PM

Article image
Treasury will need to plug gap in tax as drivers switch to electric cars
About 65% of the pump cost of petrol and diesel goes to fund public spending. As this falls, alternative sources of revenue will be needed

Phillip Inman

26, Jul, 2017 @4:54 PM

Article image
Road pricing could offset loss of fuel duty from electric cars
Rishi Sunak looking at how to recoup lost revenues after ban on new petrol and diesel cars potentially from 2030

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

16, Nov, 2020 @7:53 PM

Article image
Fuel duty U-turn highlights need for full service of motoring policy | David Powell
David Powell: Ministers must encourage the use of smarter cars and make public transport and cycling realistic alternatives to driving

David Powell

27, Jun, 2012 @2:42 PM

Article image
Fuel duty freeze in 2014 will save motorists 20p a litre – George Osborne
Chancellor highlights cancellation of a 2p rise on fuel duty as motorists welcome move, but train fares will rise with inflation

Gwyn Topham, transport correspondent

05, Dec, 2013 @5:31 PM

Article image
'E-highways' could slash UK road freight emissions, says study
System of overhead cables and adapted lorries could pay for itself within 15 years

Jasper Jolly

27, Jul, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
Jaguar Land Rover to cut production at Halewood
UK’s biggest carmaker blames faltering sales on Brexit vote and tax curbs on diesel fuel

Gwyn Topham

22, Jan, 2018 @5:18 PM

Article image
Oil prices could spiral higher in the coming months, says IEA
Further rises would not only hit motorists but chancellor’s hopes of raising fuel duty

Adam Vaughan

13, Sep, 2018 @12:51 PM

Article image
UK car industry pushes for scrappage scheme to help buy new petrol and diesel vehicles
Exclusive: lobby wants £1.5bn scheme to jump-start sector despite clean fuel pledges

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

03, Jun, 2020 @6:00 AM