Keir Starmer lacks a close gang of MPs to defend him – just like Theresa May

Analysis: resentment about the power of Starmer’s aides has been growing among MPs for months

Though it is not a comparison he would welcome, Keir Starmer shares some leadership qualities with Theresa May.

The Labour leader was seen as a safe choice – and not a tribalist – after the party suffered a huge existential ruction. He has no close gang of supportive MPs and is professional, not clubbable. And he pledged to reach out across the divide.

But as May discovered with her Conservative backbenchers, not having a gang of loyalists among your MPs can be a problem. MPs can get out on the media round to defend you – aides cannot.

When Starmer met his closest allies this weekend to work out how to salvage his authority from the wreckage of a power battle with his deputy, Angela Rayner, the cast list left some feeling nervous.

There were no MPs in the room – not even Starmer’s chief whip, Nick Brown, who later became one of the high-profile casualties of the reshuffle.

Instead, Starmer took his counsel mainly from his advisers – Jenny Chapman, his powerful political secretary, his longtime political adviser Chris Ward, his chief of staff Morgan McSweeney, the party’s director of communications, Ben Nunn and Starmer’s policy director, Claire Ainsley. The other influential political player was Charlie Falconer, the shadow attorney general and veteran of the Tony Blair years.

One big name not in the room, but who has been on the lips of many on the left of the party, is the former New Labour spinner Peter Mandelson – the subject of wild speculation over how much influence he has on Starmer’s operation.

Mandelson himself took to the parliamentary Labour party WhatsApp group to try to impose some party discipline on Saturday, saying reshuffles were “horribly difficult things to do and not helped by 24/7 social media – why don’t we all wait and give Keir the space and time to lead and then judge it in the round?”

That remark set tongues wagging about why the Labour peer was undertaking party management on behalf of the leader’s office – whether he was freelancing or otherwise.

Starmer inspires deep and abiding loyalty from those who have worked closely with him. Chapman, the former MP for Darlington until she lost her seat in 2019, was his junior in the shadow Brexit team and once said she would occupy his office until he stood for leader.

Nunn and Ward have worked for Starmer for years, two of his most trusted advisers who helped him plot some of Labour’s boldest parliamentary moves over Brexit.

Resentment about the power of Starmer’s aides – particularly Chapman – has been growing for many months. MPs blamed her for the decision to make Paul Williams the Hartlepool byelection candidate despite his remainer credentials in the pro-Brexit constituency. Labour humiliatingly lost the seat last week.

Shadow cabinet ministers say Starmer even keeps some distance from them, naming only Rachel Reeves – newly promoted to shadow chancellor in the reshuffle – as one who has his ear.

One shadow cabinet minister recalled a diary meeting where there was a scheduled catchup with Starmer – but they arrived to find only Chapman. And on the backbenches, MPs who have not been promoted claim that Chapman is given full power over those rewarded with frontbench jobs – though paranoia may have a part to play.

Another MP said that Starmer himself was not paranoid about leadership challenges or “tall poppies” with ambition, and said that concern came from others in his team. The MP then joked that perhaps they had been right to worry.

Starmer is fiercely protective of his staff, and much of the anger briefed out about Rayner’s conduct over the weekend centred on allegations that she had demanded changes to the leader’s office. An ally of Rayner said they would not discuss her views on party staff, but said the briefing against her had been an attempt to “make her look unreasonable”.


Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Keir Starmer sets out case for 'radical Labour government'
Exclusive: shadow Brexit secretary calls for end to infighting and return to being a ‘broad church’ party

Zoe Williams and Heather Stewart

18, Dec, 2019 @7:11 AM

Article image
Keir Starmer: Brexit deal unlikely to pass without confirmatory poll
Shadow Brexit secretary also warns Labour risks losing its remain voters

Jessica Elgot Chief political correspondent

12, May, 2019 @5:30 PM

Article image
Keir Starmer essay sets Labour on course for centre ground
Pamphlet for the Fabian Society emphasises values of work, society and partnership with private sector

Heather Stewart and Jessica Elgot

22, Sep, 2021 @9:30 PM

Article image
Nervy Keir Starmer offers alternative to tiers of a clown | John Crace
The Labour leader’s message to Boris Johnson was the closest thing to leadership the country has seen in months

John Crace

13, Oct, 2020 @7:18 PM

Article image
Budget 2021: Keir Starmer backs delay in raising corporation tax
Labour leader says party would have put NHS and social care ‘front and centre’ of budget

Jessica Elgot

03, Mar, 2021 @3:47 PM

Article image
Keir Starmer clashed with Corbyn on Brexit 'to brink of resignation'
Shadow Brexit secretary said to have shown outrage at ‘ambush’ with customs union paper earlier this year

Heather Stewart Political editor

18, Sep, 2018 @4:35 PM

Article image
Keir Starmer under pressure to back plans for corporation tax rise
Labour leader has faced backlash after saying he would oppose any new tax on business in budget

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

24, Feb, 2021 @7:54 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson trying to ‘take down’ standards watchdog, Keir Starmer says
Prime minister is leading the Tories ‘through the sewers and the stench lingers,’ Labour leader says

Rowena Mason, Aubrey Allegretti and Peter Walker

08, Nov, 2021 @8:10 PM

Article image
Poll of Labour members suggests Keir Starmer is first choice
Exclusive: shadow Brexit secretary early frontrunner to succeed Jeremy Corbyn

Kate Proctor Political correspondent

01, Jan, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
Keir Starmer hails Kim Leadbeater as the future of Labour
Party leader contrasts new Batley and Spen MP with Boris Johnson, ‘who basks in his own dishonesty’

Peter Walker and Maya Wolfe-Robinson

02, Jul, 2021 @4:30 PM