Tough climate policies would be price of coalition, Scottish Greens say

Any power-sharing deal after May election would require SNP to ‘get serious on climate emergency’

The Scottish Greens would demand far tougher climate policies in exchange for agreeing to a coalition deal with the Scottish National party after the May election.

Senior SNP strategists have mooted offering a coalition deal to the Greens as a way of forming a pro-independence “super majority” at Holyrood for the first time since the party won power 14 years ago.

That follows a sustained dip in SNP support in some recent opinion polls, which has dented expectations Nicola Sturgeon will easily win an overall majority at Holyrood on 6 May.

If she fails to win that majority, a formal government deal with the Greens would allow Sturgeon to argue Holyrood had a mandate to demand a second referendum. The Greens have five MSPs and expect to win several more seats in May.

Patrick Harvie, co-leader of the Scottish Greens, told the National newspaper earlier this month he was open to the idea of a formal power-sharing deal, but a Greens spokesman said there had not yet been any contact on that between the two parties.

Any formal deal would be a “non-starter”, he added, unless Sturgeon cancelled the Scottish government’s road-building plans, which include dualling long trunk roads, and dropped support for taxpayer subsidies for North Sea oil and gas extraction and exploration.

“If any party wanted to speak to us they’d have to get serious on the climate emergency. They would have to seriously shift on climate if they were to give us any ministerial posts,” the spokesman said.

Any offer would need to be ratified first by party members, he said. SNP politicians and members could resist a deal that tied the party’s hands: despite running minority governments twice since 2007, the SNP has never entered into formal coalitions.

SNP strategists argue that a coalition government with the Greens could bolster the Scottish government’s credentials before Glasgow hosts the Cop26 global climate talks in November. Sturgeon’s climate policies have come under repeated attack from the Greens for being far too timid.

Sturgeon has shifted away from calling for an early independence referendum after the same polls found falling support, and opposition parties accused her of prioritising constitutional conflict above Covid recovery and domestic policies.

The yes vote hit a record high of 58% at the peak of the Covid pandemic, with more than 20 polls in a row giving independence a majority, as voters endorsed Sturgeon’s leadership during the crisis.

Nicola Sturgeon campaigns for the Scottish parliament elections in her Glasgow Southside constituency
Nicola Sturgeon campaigns for the Scottish parliament elections in her Glasgow Southside constituency. Photograph: Andy Buchanan/PA

But with the success of the UK government’s vaccinations strategy, and the Alex Salmond harassment crisis, it has since dropped. The elections expert Sir John Curtice said the last six polls put yes and no support at 50/50; for the first time in a year, some show a clear lead for no. Others show a minority of voters favour a quick referendum.

Sturgeon’s recent shift towards prioritising the Covid recovery, and suggestions the SNP would delay a referendum for at least two years, has put Scottish Labour under pressure to offer a clear alternative to the SNP at the election.

Anas Sarwar, the new Scottish Labour leader, told reporters on Thursday, as he launched Labour’s campaign, he believed Sturgeon’s pledge to put Covid first was insincere.

“Whilst the Tories and SNP can talk about recovery, they’re both compromised. The Tories can’t deliver a recovery that works for everyone because they would have us go back to the failed system and inbuilt inequalities we had pre-Covid,” he said.

“The SNP will try and talk about recovery, but it’s not credible to say we’re going to come through Covid and straight into a referendum campaign which is going to pull our country further apart.”

Douglas Ross, the Scottish Tory leader, said denying the SNP a majority on 6 May would stop their quest for a second referendum.

“We know from the referendum bill they introduced on Monday that is going to be their top priority, should they be re-elected as a majority. And therefore we have to stop that at all costs,” he said.


Severin Carrell Scotland editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
SNP and Scottish Greens confirm power-sharing deal in historic moment for Greens
Agreement means Greens will be in power for first time in UK with two ministerial roles for party

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

20, Aug, 2021 @1:52 PM

Article image
Deal between Scottish Greens and SNP delayed as deadline looms
Negotiations slow as clock runs down due to wrangling over climate, marine policy and the role of Green ministers

Severin Carrell Scotland editor

11, Aug, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Nicola Sturgeon discusses cooperation deal with Scottish Greens
Move designed to cement pro-independence majority at Holyrood

Severin Carrell Scotland editor

26, May, 2021 @4:15 PM

Article image
Scottish Greens ‘willing to have conversation’ on coalition with SNP
Co-leader says party ‘can make a difference’ as it unveils manifesto with plan for 100,000 new jobs

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

14, Apr, 2021 @1:38 PM

Article image
Could Salmond’s ‘supermajority’ talk harm the Scottish independence cause?
Analysis: Alba says the term just means it wants to ‘maximise the vote’, but some experts say it could confuse voters

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

15, Apr, 2021 @3:36 PM

Article image
Sturgeon on brink of cooperation deal with Scottish Greens
Exclusive: agreement would cement a pro-independence majority at Holyrood and may give Greens ministerial seats

Severin Carrell Scotland editor

03, Aug, 2021 @11:10 AM

Article image
Alex Salmond to demand Alba party included in TV leadership debates
Salmond says party already has ‘significant following’ as Sturgeon accuses him of misleading Scottish voters

Libby Brooks and Matthew Weaver

01, Apr, 2021 @4:18 PM

Article image
Nicola Sturgeon: No 10 cannot stand in the way of independence
Exclusive: first minister seeks mandate for second poll in face of Covid and Alex Salmond’s party

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

11, Apr, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
Scottish election 2021: a visual guide on what to expect
A majority of independence-supporting MSPs in next month’s Holyrood election will give Nicola Sturgeon her mandate to call for a second referendum

Ashley Kirk and Pablo Gutiérrez

15, Apr, 2021 @5:09 PM

Article image
Size doesn’t matter for Scottish economic success. But planning does
Strong institutions, the right mix of human and physical capital, and sound economic management are key

Larry Elliott

02, May, 2021 @10:31 AM