UK defence cuts show gulf between ambition and action, says Labour

Ministers challenged over size of army as reduction of 10,000 in troop numbers expected to be announced

Labour has accused the government of presiding over “a gulf between ambitions and actions” before a defence review on Monday expected to confirm a cut of 10,000 in the size of the British army.

The party produced figures suggesting that day-to-day defence spending will be cut by 2.4% in real terms over the course of the parliament, masked by a £16.5bn boost to the capital budget announced last November.

John Healey, the shadow defence secretary, questioned whether the planned cuts would allow the government to meet its stated goal to deploy the British military more widely “in all corners of the globe”.

“Further army cuts could seriously limit our forces’ capacity simultaneously to deploy overseas, support allies and maintain strong national defences and resilience,” Healey said. “There’s a gulf between the government’s ambitions and its actions, which is set to grow with this new review.”

The Ministry of Defence is due to publish a paper on the size and shape of the armed forces for the next five years on Monday, with ministers already emphasising that the military will be the “right size” to meet the threat.

Ben Wallace, the defence secretary, refused to deny that a planned cut in the army’s target size from 82,000 to about 72,500 soldiers was in the works when pressed on Sky News’s Sophy Ridge on Sunday.

“What I will be doing is making sure we have an armed forces that is the right size to meet the threat and the right size to meet the government’s ambition of having a global Britain that uphold values and support its allies,” the minister said.

After Brexit, ministers want Britain’s defence posture to expand, increasing its presence in the Indo-Pacific region around China, reversing a decision made by the Wilson government in 1968 to withdraw British forces from “east of Suez”. They will emphasise that, with the help of battlefield drones and communications technology able to track the position of troops on the ground, a smaller, more highly skilled army can have greater “lethality”.

An extra £200m will be given to the Royal Marines as they become a “Future Commando Force”, while the SAS and other special forces will increase in size and the army will create an upgraded Rangers regiment.

But at the Conservative party’s manifesto launch during the election campaign, Boris Johnson struck a different tone when he said there was a “sharp distinction” on defence between him and his then rival, former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn.

“We will not be cutting our armed forces in any form. We will be maintaining the size of our armed forces because we are increasing funding for them,” Johnson told reporters at the event.

What may help the government is that, although the target size for the army will be cut, it partly reflects years of failure to recruit enough to reach it. Last April, at the beginning of the pandemic, the figure was 73,900 although it has since grown to 76,350 in January.

Labour’s calculations, based on figures published in November’s spending review, show that day-to-day defence spending will increase in cash terms from £29.7bn in 2019/20 to £31.5bn in 2021/22 but will then remain essentially flat until 2024/25, with its value in real terms gradually eroded by inflation.

Labour, under its leader Sir Keir Starmer, has been emphasising a commitment to the UK’s national security as it seeks to redefine its image after Corbyn’s four-year leadership.


Dan Sabbagh

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ministry of Defence braced for 'brutal' cuts in security review
MoD has compiled list of options, including marines and amphibious vessels but Trident replacement seen as untouchable

Ewen MacAskill Defence correspondent

24, Nov, 2017 @11:56 PM

Article image
MoD has wasted £13bn since Tories came to power, Labour claims
Labour publishes document highlighting failed procurement projects, overspends and other administrative errors

Dan Sabbagh Defence and security editor

05, Jan, 2022 @11:45 AM

Article image
British army could be overstretched by stepping in during strikes, says Labour
Party also questions whether troops would ‘bail out failing services rather than provide emergency back-up’

Dan Sabbagh Defence and security editor

02, Dec, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Labour says Johnson is breaking election promise with army reorganisation – as it happened
Latest updates: Labour says PM has broken promise not to cut size of the army after restructuring announced

Andrew Sparrow

25, Nov, 2021 @4:52 PM

Article image
Cross-party committee attacks defence cuts
Defence select committee warns Britain's influence will decline unless the armed forces get adequate resources

Richard Norton-Taylor

02, Aug, 2011 @11:05 PM

Article image
British army to get extra £8bn of kit as part of radical shake-up
Defence secretary says Future Soldier programme will reconfigure army to face next-generation threats

Caroline Davies

25, Nov, 2021 @2:31 PM

Article image
Tory revolt could prompt compromise on defence cuts
Liam Fox admits tensions within Conservative party over plans to cut strength of army

Jessica Elgot Political reporter

26, Nov, 2017 @9:02 PM

Article image
Defence secretary denies British army is scrapping tanks
Ben Wallace says older equipment will be shelved, but upgraded vehicles will remain part of armed forces

Guardian staff and agency

12, Sep, 2020 @9:17 AM

Article image
UK defence minister faces call for inquiry into 2012 killing of Kenyan woman
Inquest in Kenya in 2019 concluded that Agnes Wanjiru, 21, ‘was murdered by British soldiers’

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

24, Oct, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Ministry of Defence spent £290m on consultants last year

Exclusive: MoD criticised for failing to look in-house for technical expertise while pressing ahead with 60,000 job cuts

Nick Hopkins

20, Feb, 2012 @12:20 PM