Keir Starmer’s Labour lacks the coherence it needs to win elections | Letters

Mike Freedman is concerned that there is no vision enabling us to understand what the country will look like after a period of Labour rule, while Peter Walker says Starmer and his allies need to build on the momentum Labour achieved leading up to 2017. Plus letters from Des Senior and Barbara Gray

Andy Beckett is right (If Keir Starmer wants to ‘rethink Britain’, he’ll need some bigger ideas, 8 April), but there is a missing link in his thinking as well as that of the party and its leader. Without a clear strategic framework within which to situate big ideas, policy initiatives and election manifestos, there is a dangerous void that will serve to confuse not just the electorate but members, activists and affiliates such as trades unions. Currently, there is little or no coherence or linkage between the various policies being advocated.

The result is that there is no vision enabling us to understand what the country will look like after a period of Labour rule. For example, what will the nature and direction of our education provision and lifelong learning commitment be like? What can we expect the nature, structure and rewards of employment to be? What reforms will there be to people’s incomes and the benefits system, and how will they be linked to taxation and pensions?

There are dozens of such questions around our future, and they all need to be linked together to form one coherent whole. Only then can Starmer’s exhortation in the Observer “to rethink what Britain can be” and Beckett’s sense of big ideas result in a relevant, powerful and easy-to-communicate strategic vision that can be achieved, leading to the power for we which crave.
Mike Freedman
Former parliamentary candidate and personal assistant to Tom Sawyer, then Labour’s general secretary

• Andy Beckett is right to suggest that Keir Starmer needs to change. Unfortunately, Starmer’s insistence that Labour has changed is clearly having little traction with the electorate as we approach the likelihood of a humiliating defeat in Hartlepool. Currently Labour is around eight points behind the Tories on 35%.

The 2019 election was a devastating defeat for Labour. Responsibility for that result must be shared not just by the then leaders (including Starmer) but also by the parliamentary Labour party, who had spent the previous four years telling the world that Labour was racist, antisemitic and led by the “loony left”. What Starmer should be aiming to achieve is at least is 40% in the polls, a figure last achieved by Jeremy Corbyn in the 2017 election. That figure was not enough to win, but it was a higher share of the vote than Labour had achieved in the three previous general elections.

By isolating Labour’s members from any say in policy, the current leader has seen a haemorrhaging of members from the 485,000 in 2019. The result is paralysis of Labour’s resilient campaign base. Starmer and his allies need to build on the momentum Labour achieved leading up to 2017, not eradicate that event from history.
Peter Walker
Wimbledon, London

• Re Polly Toynbee’s article (Sleaze fells Tory governments – and that should be a gift to Keir Starmer, 6 April), the problem here isn’t Starmer, or even that the public don’t know about the sleaze or expect the austerity. It’s that they don’t appear to care. And that really is worrying.
Des Senior
Aylesbeare, Devon

• Get Labour elected? Dominic Cummings is pretty good at campaigns and three-word slogans. How about the Labour party employing him for the next election? After all, he has no moral compass and a grudge against the Tory government.
Barbara Gray
Coldstream, Scottish Borders

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication.


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A year on, Keir Starmer’s grand vision is still in question | Letters
Letters: Dr Anthony Isaacs thinks the Labour leader must unite the party and restore the whip to Jeremy Corbyn, but Bruce Sawford has lost hope


05, Apr, 2021 @4:04 PM

Article image
The risks and rewards of Keir Starmer's long game | Letters
Letters: Alastair Tinto and Bernie Evans are frustrated with the Labour leader’s hesitancy and reluctance to leave the centre ground, while Toby Wood welcomes Starmer’s cautious approach to policymaking. Plus letters from Eddie Dougall and Alison McIntosh


19, Feb, 2021 @4:49 PM

Article image
Unconventional wisdom on Labour ‘heartlands’ | Letters
Letters: Ian Wrigglesworth discusses the awkward fact that there is a substantial Tory vote in the north, Roger Backhouse advocates Old Lefties for Labour to win back the pensioner vote, Robert Leach says Labour should take a tip from the late former MP Jack Dunnett, and Dr Alyson Hall Yandoli proposes a new way of testing the leadership hopefuls


13, Jan, 2020 @5:42 PM

Article image
Which Labour leader do Tories fear most? | Letters
Letters: Jeremy Beecham says the fact that Conservatives are vehemently attacking Keir Starmer is telling. Donald Roy says it is not the case that only true Corbyn candidates were rewarded with volunteers and resources


31, Jan, 2020 @5:25 PM

Article image
Will defining Starmerism put Labour back in No 10? | Letters
Letters: John Rowe is sick of Labour being honest and defeated, John Airs refers to Keir Starmer’s 10 pledges, Carolyn Kirton likes that fact that he eschews the cheap and empty drama of Johnsonian bluff, while John Shanahan suggests the Labour leader looks elsewhere for inspiration


11, Sep, 2020 @4:03 PM

Article image
How Labour can make itself electable again | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to a piece by Martin Kettle in which he says the party needs to take time for judgments to settle about its descent into the electoral abyss


05, Jan, 2020 @5:39 PM

Article image
Keir Starmer’s tepid policies are alienating Labour’s core supporters | Letters
Letters: Labour may be sowing the seeds of its own destruction, writes Dr Peter Mangan, while Jacqueline Mackenzie says she has become politically homeless. Plus letters from John Bourn and Ted Shrecker


03, Aug, 2022 @5:12 PM

Article image
Keir Starmer’s change of tune on Jeremy Corbyn | Letters
Letters: Former Labour MP Chris Mullin deprecates the way the party’s current leader has treated his predecessor

27, Feb, 2023 @5:54 PM

Article image
Where’s the anger over these dodgy Tory deals? | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to a piece by Jonathan Freedland in which he addresses Boris Johnson’s cronyism and the wasting of taxpayers’ money


10, Aug, 2020 @4:37 PM

Article image
I shave, therefore I am | Brief letters
Brief letters: Dominic Cummings | Woke culture | Philosophers and beards | Procrastination


17, Feb, 2020 @5:56 PM