Will defining Starmerism put Labour back in No 10? | Letters

John Rowe is sick of Labour being honest and defeated, John Airs refers to Keir Starmer’s 10 pledges, Carolyn Kirton likes that fact that he eschews the cheap and empty drama of Johnsonian bluff, while John Shanahan suggests the Labour leader looks elsewhere for inspiration

Prof Alan Finlayson has a different memory of recent Labour history to mine when he writes that the party urgently needs to define Starmerism (The era-defining question facing Labour: is there such a thing as Starmerism?, 9 September). What Keir Starmer has so far successfully done is demonstrate a level of competence, trustworthiness and honesty that is in stark contrast with Boris Johnson’s meandering outbursts.

I don’t agree that Labour leaders do best in elections when they demonstrate a strong vision for the country – in fact, recent elections suggest the opposite. Neil Kinnock and Jeremy Corbyn were clear about their radical policies, Harold Wilson and Tony Blair much less so. Blair’s 1997 landslide was achieved mainly because he presented an image of someone the public could trust to steady the ship after the chaos of John Major’s declining government.

While I’d love to believe that Starmer supports most of the policies put forward by Corbyn and his team, that isn’t the position of most people I know. If I were Labour leader, I’d be inclined to say as little as possible about policies in the run-up to the next election; then in my first week in office I’d announce a wide range of plans relating to taxation, proportional representation, the benefits system and universal credit, a rental cap, and renationalisation of water and the railways. If Labour didn’t have an outright majority, I’d challenge the smaller parties to oppose any of those measures.

If this sound devious, well, I’m sick of Labour being honest and defeated. Till our chance comes again, Starmer needs to continue to concentrate on demonstrating the incompetence, corruption and dishonesty that is utterly rife in our current government.
John Rowe
Rochdale, Greater Manchester

• In his search for Starmerism, Alan Finlayson could have looked at the 10 pledges Starmer made in his bid for leadership of the party. He might have found there “a better future than the overheating dystopia that we feel in our bones is already here”. Pledge 5 calls for “Common ownership: Public services should be in public hands, not making profits for shareholders. Support common ownership of rail, mail, energy and water; end outsourcing in our NHS, local government and justice system.”

That looks to me like a clear rejection of neoliberalism, the overheating dystopia that we have suffered under for over 40 years. That has to be Labour’s future, does it not?
John Airs

• Has Alan Finlayson already forgotten the repeated failures and lack of vision of Corbynism? I recall them only too well. Far from being “risk averse”, Starmer eschews the cheap and empty drama of Johnsonian bluff and blunder.
Carolyn Kirton

• Do we really need a Starmerism? Before Thatcher, two Labour prime ministers succeeded in introducing the NHS, social security, equal pay legislation, the abolition of capital punishment and the decriminalisation of homosexuality, and avoided becoming entangled in an illegal US war. Between them, they achieved all this without the need to define Attleeism or Wilsonism.

If Thatcherism and Blairism are arguments for creating Starmerism, I suggest the Labour leader looks elsewhere for inspiration in defining the Labour party’s future direction and purpose.
John Shanahan

• Join the conversation – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Why Labour must heed the clamour for change
Letters: Keir Starmer should be bolder in setting out Labour’s vision for power, says David Reed. Plus letters from Les Bright and Howard B Broughton

16, May, 2023 @3:39 PM

Article image
Unconventional wisdom on Labour ‘heartlands’ | Letters
Letters: Ian Wrigglesworth discusses the awkward fact that there is a substantial Tory vote in the north, Roger Backhouse advocates Old Lefties for Labour to win back the pensioner vote, Robert Leach says Labour should take a tip from the late former MP Jack Dunnett, and Dr Alyson Hall Yandoli proposes a new way of testing the leadership hopefuls


13, Jan, 2020 @5:42 PM

Article image
Which Labour leader do Tories fear most? | Letters
Letters: Jeremy Beecham says the fact that Conservatives are vehemently attacking Keir Starmer is telling. Donald Roy says it is not the case that only true Corbyn candidates were rewarded with volunteers and resources


31, Jan, 2020 @5:25 PM

Article image
How Labour can make itself electable again | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to a piece by Martin Kettle in which he says the party needs to take time for judgments to settle about its descent into the electoral abyss


05, Jan, 2020 @5:39 PM

Article image
Keir Starmer’s Labour lacks the coherence it needs to win elections | Letters
Letters: Mike Freedman is concerned that there is no vision enabling us to understand what the country will look like after a period of Labour rule, while Peter Walker says Starmer and his allies need to build on the momentum Labour achieved leading up to 2017. Plus letters from Des Senior and Barbara Gray


11, Apr, 2021 @3:49 PM

Article image
Should Labour try to win back ‘red wall’ voters? | Letters
Letters: Steve Smart warns Labour against simply trying to win back its traditional supporters in the old heartlands, Roy Boffy says these voters will be lost for ever unless the party seriously reappraises its parlous position, and Ron Glatter thinks the ‘northern problem’ is in danger of being overstated. Plus Derrick Cameron on Corbyn as a leader and Starmer as a manager


16, Dec, 2020 @6:15 PM

Article image
How to fight the Tories’ electoral dominance | Letters
Letters: Labour must aim for broad appeal with moderate, centre-left policies, says John Mills. However, David Cockayne argues that all opposition parties need to work together for a fairer voting system, while Ken Richardson hopes that people won’t get conned by the rightwing press again


18, Jan, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
The risks and rewards of Keir Starmer's long game | Letters
Letters: Alastair Tinto and Bernie Evans are frustrated with the Labour leader’s hesitancy and reluctance to leave the centre ground, while Toby Wood welcomes Starmer’s cautious approach to policymaking. Plus letters from Eddie Dougall and Alison McIntosh


19, Feb, 2021 @4:49 PM

Article image
A year on, Keir Starmer’s grand vision is still in question | Letters
Letters: Dr Anthony Isaacs thinks the Labour leader must unite the party and restore the whip to Jeremy Corbyn, but Bruce Sawford has lost hope


05, Apr, 2021 @4:04 PM

Article image
Why Labour’s message still isn’t getting through | Letters
Letters: Labour must do more to win over voters, says Dr Jamie Gough. Keir Starmer’s lack of leadership experience is part of the problem, according to Keith Flett. Plus letters from Hugh Legge and Roy Boffy


09, Aug, 2020 @4:57 PM