Government admits new Brexit bill 'will break international law'

Brandon Lewis tells MPs internal market bill will ‘clarify’ Northern Ireland protocol

The government has admitted that its plan to reinterpret the special Brexit arrangements for Northern Ireland will break international law.

The Northern Ireland secretary, Brandon Lewis, astonished backbenchers when he told the House of Commons: “Yes, this does break international law in a very specific and limited way. We’re taking the powers to disapply the EU law concept of direct effect … in a certain very tightly defined circumstance.”

In a new internal market bill, the government is expected to unveil plans for domestic powers to govern part of the Northern Ireland protocol, something that has threatened to torpedo Brexit talks that resumed in London on Tuesday.

It reportedly led to the resignation of the UK’s top legal civil servant, Jonathan Jones, on Tuesday morning.

Lewis told the House of Commons that what the UK was doing was not that unusual.

“There are precedents for the UK and, indeed, other countries, needing to consider their international obligations as circumstances change,” he said citing changes in the Finance Act in 2013.

But the admission led to a torrent of criticism, including from the former prime minister Theresa May, who questioned whether Boris Johnson was risking the UK’s international reputation as a trustworthy nation.

“How can the government reassure future international partners that the UK can be trusted to abide by the legal obligations of the agreement itself?” she asked in an exchange with Lewis during an urgent question in the Commons on the latest developments.

The Irish foreign affairs minister, Simon Coveney, said the latest revelations were “gravely concerning”.

Coveney, who was instrumental in the negotiations about the Irish border, said he could not understand why the UK was seeking to create a “safety net” given the Northern Ireland protocol was specifically “designed and empowered to work in all circumstances”.

“It is surely not too much to ask for the UK to implement the withdrawal agreement which it agreed to,” he told the Dáil Éireann, Ireland’s lower house of parliament.

Johnson’s move to try to override part of the Northern Ireland protocol has put Brexit talks at risk but Lewis told MPs the new legislation, which would “clarify” part of the special arrangements on Northern Ireland, was designed as “limited and reasonable steps to create a safety net” in the event that talks collapse.

The shadow Northern Ireland secretary, Louise Haigh, accused the government of using the region as a “political football”.

She also questioned whether the government would be asking ministers to break the ministerial code and vote for the internal market bill, the vehicle for the Brexit changes, due to be tabled in Westminster on Wednesday.

Sir Robert Neill, the Conservative MP for Bromley and Chislehurst and chair of the justice select committee, said “the rule of law is not negotiable” and an international treaty signed by the government should not be breached.

Any breach, or potential breach, of the international legal obligations we have entered into is unacceptable, regardless of whether it’s in a ‘specific’ or ‘limited way’.

Adherence to the rule of law is not negotiable.

— Sir Bob Neill MP (@neill_bob) September 8, 2020

Claire Hanna, the SDLP MP for Belfast South, implored Lewis not to “use the threat of a border in Northern Ireland” as a “cat’s paw in this or any other negotiation”.

The DUP North Antrim MP, Ian Paisley, accused the government of having a “tin-foil spine” in failing to stand up to its critics, while his colleague Sammy Wilson, one of the most vocal critics of the Brexit deal, said: “We still don’t know the depth and breadth” of the checks in Northern Ireland.

The president of the Law Society of England and Wales, Simon Davis, said: “The rule of law is not negotiable.

“Our commitment to the rule of law is key to attracting international business to the UK and to maintaining faith in our justice system.”

Government sources claimed the move would not breach the ministerial code because the obligation on ministers to comply with international law was removed from the guidance in 2015 by David Cameron.

However legal experts, including David Anderson, a member of the House of Lords EU security and justice sub-committee, said the code still mandated that ministers uphold international law after a court of appeal ruling in 2018 concluded ministers had an “overarching” duty to do so.

The Ministerial Code still mandates compliance with international law, despite a change to its wording, as the Court of Appeal confirmed in 2018:

— David Anderson (@bricksilk) September 8, 2020

Lewis urged the critics to wait until Wednesday to see what was in the bill.

“I think it would be wholly wrong for the UK government not to take the approach to ensure that there is a safety net should [Brexit talks’] fail, to ensure that in January businesses and people know they’ve got the contents of a structure in place to deliver on our promises.”

He said the bill was designed to deliver the government’s promise that Northern Ireland traders would have “unfettered access” to Great British markets.

However he batted away a question from Hilary Benn, the chair of the Brexit select committee, who demanded to know if, as expected under the protocol, businesses from Great Britain would have to fill in paperwork, including entry summary declarations, if sending goods to Northern Ireland.

That, said Lewis, was being discussed by the specialised EU-UK committee set up under the withdrawal agreement.


Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Angela Merkel admits collapse of Brexit talks cannot be ruled out
Chancellor’s comments made to German finance chiefs as UK-EU negotiations face deadlock

Daniel Boffey in Brussels and Pippa Crerar

04, Sep, 2018 @7:56 PM

Article image
Brexit bill criticised as 'eye-watering' breach of international law
Downing Street defends bill after outcry from Brussels, legal experts and some Tory MPs

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

09, Sep, 2020 @5:08 PM

Article image
Theresa May says 'reckless' Brexit bill risks UK's reputation
Ex-PM says internal market bill could lead to a united Ireland and undermine trust in UK

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

21, Sep, 2020 @6:43 PM

Article image
EU looks to Northern Ireland-only backstop to break Brexit impasse
EU trade commissioner says he believes ‘penny is finally dropping’ for Boris Johnson

Daniel Boffey in Brussels

10, Sep, 2019 @12:49 PM

Article image
Brexit: UK government pledges £355m to cushion Northern Ireland businesses
Support package unveiled to help firms with bureaucracy of moving goods across Irish Sea

Rory Carroll Ireland correspondent

07, Aug, 2020 @9:55 AM

Article image
Loyalists urge Irish government to stop ‘Brit-bashing’ on Brexit
UVF leaders say warning of attacks in event of hard Brexit could strain north-south ties

Henry McDonald in Belfast and Rory Carroll in Dublin

30, Oct, 2018 @1:50 PM

Article image
Brexit: Johnson seeks to calm MPs before next showdown over bill
Intervention by PM raises expectations of a deal with backbenchers over legislation

Jessica Elgot and Peter Walker

15, Sep, 2020 @5:03 PM

Article image
No-deal Brexit will not be clean break, Irish PM warns Boris Johnson
Leo Varadkar says UK and EU will still have to negotiate, with same problems on agenda

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

09, Sep, 2019 @10:51 AM

Article image
Johnson risks rift with Biden by pressing ahead with Brexit bill
Prime minister says changes to legislation will protect Northern Ireland peace deal

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

08, Nov, 2020 @1:54 PM

Article image
UK archbishops urge ministers not to breach international law over Brexit
Leaders of Anglican church say internal market bill risks being a ‘disastrous precedent’

Harriet Sherwood

18, Oct, 2020 @10:39 PM